Skip to main content

Progress or get the points?

Progress or get the points?

Joined
Jan 7, 2013
Messages
433
Location
darn sarf
Often in situations like this we're two teams play each other in the same weeek they both get a win each. With that in mind which game would you rather we won?
Would you rather we progress to the quarter final of the cup with the possibility of a bigger team in the next round, good day out and more money in the bank or 3 points on Saturday?

For me I'd rather win the game on Tuesday. We go through to the next round and then get a decent side away or even at home for the money. Newcastle have won the league already no matter what anybody says so there is no harm in getting beat off them in the league then kicking on again against Rotherham.

So what is it. Points or progression?
 
Often in situations like this we're two teams play each other in the same weeek they both get a win each. With that in mind which game would you rather we won?
Would you rather we progress to the quarter final of the cup with the possibility of a bigger team in the next round, good day out and more money in the bank or 3 points on Saturday?

For me I'd rather win the game on Tuesday. We go through to the next round and then get a decent side away or even at home for the money. Newcastle have won the league already no matter what anybody says so there is no harm in getting beat off them in the league then kicking on again against Rotherham.

So what is it. Points or progression?

On this occasion I'd rather progress in the cup.
 
There won't be many that pick up points against Newcastle this season, so if we lose it's not too bad. But a win Tuesday and we're in to the Quarter finals for the first time and a chance at a massive away game. In my opinion, just this once, i'd rather win in the cup.
 
I'm going to be greedy and say both.

The lads are buzzing at the moment and we are capable of winning both games. I don't expect us to win both and wouldn't be surprised if we lost both, but I expect us to be very competitive in both games.
 
False dichotomy - it is not a question of either/or. You imagine some players who have not featured in the starting line-up lately will get a start on Tuesday - Makienok most obviously, after Bournemouth he deserves to do so. With Vermilj ineligible then someone else - Huntington or Davies - will have to replace Baptiste who is also cup-tied. Otherwise it really is SG's call about how far he rejigs the side to rest some players and give others a chance.

Presuming Makienok starts then we either play him as a lone striker with maybe Johnson 'in the slot' behind him or we provide him with a partner. Who that might be is a real poser - Doyle or a fit-again Beckford or Hugill are the candidates. I am not too sure how a Makienok-Hugill partnership would work but you can bet that younger players like Hugill would be more than eager to get out in front of what is likely to be a 30,000+ crowd.
 
Hugill, a lad from the NE, will relish both games.

As for the OP, lets make history by reaching the League Cup QFs for the 1st time in our history. I think we'll do em on penalties. Would take a draw at Deepdale.

Lets dare to dream like Bradford did...
 
Hugill, a lad from the NE, will relish both games.

As for the OP, lets make history by reaching the League Cup QFs for the 1st time in our history. I think we'll do em on penalties. Would take a draw at Deepdale.

Lets dare to dream like Bradford did...
Absolutely. There are plenty more games to kick on with in the league. This is a one off with the chance of achieving something we haven't done before. In the league, if we are outside the top six by the end of the season I don't really care massively if it is 7th or 15th place but that would be sweetened by advancing to the latter stages of a cup competition.
Of course, there is no reason why we can't advance in both.
 
I want to make the quarters.

Our results this month mean that any result against Newcastle at Deepdale is a bonus.
 
A cheeky win on Tuesday night when they turn out their reserve team. Then a draw on Saturday. That'll do me.

I can't see them playing their first team on Tuesday, if we play a strong team and get beaten that puts us on a downer for Saturday. We could got for it on Tuesday and put a weakened team out on Saturday knowing it's a really tough one.

We could field a strong team in both games possibly.

Or we could do the expected and put a weakened team out Tuesday, and a strong team Saturday.

However I shouldn't say a weakened team because these guys did it at Bournemouth, we have some excellent players who need a game and are bursting to prove themselves.

Interesting innit.

I trust in Larrys decision whatever, they will have done their homework on Newcastle.
 
We've never been in the quarters of either of the 2 cup competitions in my 45 years plus of loyal support.

I think I deserve to see it!

Cup has priority for me.
 
We've never been in the quarters of either of the 2 cup competitions in my 45 years plus of loyal support.

I think I deserve to see it!

Cup has priority for me.

Last reached a quarter final in the FA Cup in 1966 I think. Drew 1-1 with Man Utd at Deepdale before losing the replay 3-1. Beating Newcastle would be a good way to mark the 50th anniversary of that appearance
 
The quarter finals is absolutely reachable for the first time in a generation of Preston fans and people want us to field a weakened team. I'm genuinely surprised. I'm in the give it everything we've got camp.
 
Back
Top