We had our spells in the Barnsley and Fulham games of playing well and playing badly, like we did against Villa.
Second half against Villa we resorted to the counter attack and defended deep some conceive that as negative tactics when they don't get their way.
The Fulham and Barnsley performances really aren't in the same bracket as the Villa one.
We were awful for the whole first halves vs Barnsley/Fulham, and had a good 20 minutes in each of the second halves because we were behind and chasing the game. 20 decent minutes isn't good enough, especially at home. Personally I felt it was mainly down to systems. We played a crap, rigid 4-4-2 against Fulham which didn't work and a very strange 3-4-3 against Barnsley which didn't work either. Imho the 4-3-3 used against Villa finds the right balance in midfield (finally) and offers attacking threat too (we don't have to play 2 strikers as some on here say).
Villa was a much more complete performance and we actually came out of the traps quick for a change, which imho is very important because taking the lead in the Championship is vital. If you go behind it's very hard to pull it back and win the game and the stats, particularly for us, show that.
Fwiw I'm happy for us, in certain games/match situations, to play on the counter as we now have the tools to do so. There were a few away games last season when we came away with good draws, but it could've been much more had we had that extra pace on the counter. Now we have McGeady and a rejuvenated Callum Robinson we are much more of a threat when sitting back and playing on the counter attack.