Skip to main content

Proof it works

Proof it works

It also helps if you have a Chief Executive who has vision, knowledge, contacts and most of all the brains to help the football club grow at the same time.

Step up Tony Scholes.

The man that the FOPNE decided was too well paid and his job could be done part time for free.

Coupled with a passionate chairman, prepared to back his manager and speak to the fans.
 
I completely disagree with your final point. If this guy was for some reason appointed manager of a big Championship club like, say, Leicester or Nottingham Forest, one of his first signings would be John Mousinho. He'd also still be trying to sign non league grafters. Let's face it, Westley = AIMITA and sadly, it doesn't work.

You are bang on mate, I agree. Especially with the way nearly every signing he makes is an attempt to make a rags to riches signing. I think if he was united boss. He.would still Go for such plqyers. He is that arrogant.
 
While an interesting point and useful stick with which to beat GW it is clearly incorrect to suggest that he a) only, b) mainly or c) more often than not signs non league players. It is fact that the players from Stevenage played in a team that finished top 6 in our league and knocked Reading out of the cup and opinion that they are league 2 at best. A quick glance at our squad will show that at least 10 of the new players in the closed season dropped to a team who finished below them last season.
 
While an interesting point and useful stick with which to beat GW it is clearly incorrect to suggest that he a) only, b) mainly or c) more often than not signs non league players. It is fact that the players from Stevenage played in a team that finished top 6 in our league and knocked Reading out of the cup and opinion that they are league 2 at best. A quick glance at our squad will show that at least 10 of the new players in the closed season dropped to a team who finished below them last season.

Again, does one successful season at (sorry- feel free to yawn) Stevenage make them league 1 players? They had the likes of Bostwick and Laird really pulling them through. Without those two these guys look useless. Mousinho's pass completion on Saturday must have been the worst from a PNE player in recent history. Beardsley barely touched the ball in the first half. They ain't good enough, their performance last season is irrelevant.

People's argument that Westley is too quick to look to the non league when his club allows him to pull in a better calibre of player is a fair one and proven by the signing of Anthony Fucking Elding. He has 'untapped potential' apparently.
 
A good read, but I disagree with the conclusions.

Stoke's managerial record before Pulis was appointed for the second time was:

Johan Boskamp 29 Jun 2005 to 01 May 2006
Tony Pulis 01 Nov 2002 to 28 Jun 2005
Dave Kevan 10 Oct 2002 to 01 Nov 2002
Steve Cotterill 27 May 2002 to 10 Oct 2002
Gudjon Thordarson 15 Nov 1999 to 15 May 2002

Aside from Pulis himself, they all lasted 6-18 months.

So surely the take-home message from Stoke is: keep sacking your underachieving managers until you appoint a good one; and if a successful previous manager of yours comes back a-calling, do everything you can to hire him back for the second spell.

Haha, that's a great post mate and a very interesting look at things.

You could argue that Pulis and his philosophy was simply never going to fail given time. They never even flirt with relegation these days. I wouldn't say I feel the same about the AIMITA philosophy!
 
I am not discussing or disputing their performance this season but they were not non league players when he brought them here. On the balance of facts you can not say he favours non league as he clearly hasn't.
Most Stevenage fans said that Moose was the one they'd really miss and I think to say that Laird and Bostwick pulled them through is not really something you can substantiate.

I don't doubt they have played badly - I have little hope for Beardsley and Elding. But it is not correct to imply all he can do is work with non league players. It is another myth similar to we play long ball football.

My views.

Again, does one successful season at (sorry- feel free to yawn) Stevenage make them league 1 players? They had the likes of Bostwick and Laird really pulling them through. Without those two these guys look useless. Mousinho's pass completion on Saturday must have been the worst from a PNE player in recent history. Beardsley barely touched the ball in the first half. They ain't good enough, their performance last season is irrelevant.

People's argument that Westley is too quick to look to the non league when his club allows him to pull in a better calibre of player is a fair one and proven by the signing of Anthony Fucking Elding. He has 'untapped potential' apparently.
 
Firstly, I am on the fence with Westley and do not know whether he will be a success or not.. But a stubborn manager with a team everybody else hates has been successful.

Living 5 minutes away from the Britannia Stadium, Stoke I have seen and heard first hand divided opinions of a club manager, Tony Pulis. When he took over at Stoke for the 2nd time many of the Stoke fans never gave him or his team a chance.

1/ Why doe he play his favourites all the time (Rory Delap)
2/ He makes stupid comments that make him sound like he's clueless.
3/ Changes a winning team (why has he dropped Huth)
4/ Stoke never get penalties.
5/ Referees are biased against us.

Sounds familiar? So far Pulis has got Stoke:-

a/ Into the Premier League
b/ Into an FA Cup Final
c/ Into the Europa Leage
d/ And has the club as an established Premier League Club.

Even, now there are still fans who don't like Pulis. (unbelievable)

IMHO, I think Stoke have some of the most passionate fans around and on match day they support their team to the hilt. (17 home games unbeaten in the Prem).

So what can we learn from this?

Don't sack your manger every 12 months.
Support the team on match days for 90 mins through thick and thin.
Give a manager time to be successful.
With step one of success then increased financial backing from the board will increase.

I know it's shit when your in a position like us but just looking at what Stoke have achieved proves it can be a success. (trust me I've had it rammed down my throat for the last 8 years how good it is to have a successful team).

So I believe patience and support will help us succeed and TH may just start to increase his financial input into the club the higher we go up the leagues.

As I said at the start I'm not sure if Westley is the man but I'm prepared to give him a chance as he is no different to Pulis.


COYW thanks for reading

Historically Stoke are a club very similar in size/crowd/income potential to PNE, and I would love us to follow their/Pulis philosophy in building a team to move forwards with, and if that means fielding 11 six foot hoofers, then so be it. A similar philosophy worked for Wimbledon all those years ago, and it worked for Stoke City, maybe it can work for us?
 
A good read, but I disagree with the conclusions.

Stoke's managerial record before Pulis was appointed for the second time was:

Johan Boskamp 29 Jun 2005 to 01 May 2006
Tony Pulis 01 Nov 2002 to 28 Jun 2005
Dave Kevan 10 Oct 2002 to 01 Nov 2002
Steve Cotterill 27 May 2002 to 10 Oct 2002
Gudjon Thordarson 15 Nov 1999 to 15 May 2002

Aside from Pulis himself, they all lasted 6-18 months.

So surely the take-home message from Stoke is: keep sacking your underachieving managers until you appoint a good one; and if a successful previous manager of yours comes back a-calling, do everything you can to hire him back for the second spell.

That sounds a great idea, but I think Jimmy Milne has sadly passed away now 🙂
 
It also helps if you have a Chief Executive who has vision, knowledge, contacts and most of all the brains to help the football club grow at the same time.

Step up Tony Scholes.

The man that the FOPNE decided was too well paid and his job could be done part time for free.

Well done Derek.
 
Historically Stoke are a club very similar in size/crowd/income potential to PNE, and I would love us to follow their/Pulis philosophy in building a team to move forwards with, and if that means fielding 11 six foot hoofers, then so be it. A similar philosophy worked for Wimbledon all those years ago, and it worked for Stoke City, maybe it can work for us?

Maybe it could but with a clown like Westley in charge this will never happen.
 
While an interesting point and useful stick with which to beat GW it is clearly incorrect to suggest that he a) only, b) mainly or c) more often than not signs non league players. It is fact that the players from Stevenage played in a team that finished top 6 in our league and knocked Reading out of the cup and opinion that they are league 2 at best. A quick glance at our squad will show that at least 10 of the new players in the closed season dropped to a team who finished below them last season.
Surely this must mean that it's not the players at fault but the management of them.
 
Back
Top