Proof Reach was onside
Adam Reach's goal offside??? Not a chance.
This was the moment Gally crossed.
Its not easy being a linesman, but this was a bit of a shocker.
![]()
Not Found
The requested URL /forum/webkit-fake-url://e28a54a5-6415-4993-ba78-6c479df9928c/imagejpeg was not found on this server.
This was the moment Gally crossed
![]()
Yup, bad call, good job nothing relied on it.
Possibly 3 players playing him onside there.
Definitely 3 players and if you look at the shadows from the stand which runs along the edge of the 6 yard box there could even be 5 players playing him on.
It pisses me off that this happens and nothing is done about it with regards to the officials. It wasn't borderline - he's blatantly onside 🙁
Leeds have had the rub of the green 3 times against us this season.
Pickfords dodgy Red Card (rescinded)
Browne's Own Goal
Reach's obviously onside goal disallowed.
Scabby gits!
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2004
- Messages
- 995
Sometimes, when the ball ends up in the net, as a fan you your doubts and immediately look to see what the linesman and referee make of it, on this occasion it never crossed my mind that there would be a problem, I've rarely been so surprised to see a goal disallowed.
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2005
- Messages
- 29,601
I don't think the offside was given against Reach. Going by the Sky highlights, when Reach shoots Doyle is encroaching on goal and possibly in an offside position. If that is the case then it's still a stupid decision because there's no way he was interfering with play.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
Leeds have had the rub of the green 3 times against us this season.
Pickfords dodgy Red Card (rescinded)
Browne's Own Goal
Reach's obviously onside goal disallowed.
Scabby gits!
I didn't think it was a penalty either JD.
I'm pretty sure the liner gave a corner and I thought Kirkland clearly got the ball.
I didn't think it was a penalty either JD.
I'm pretty sure the liner gave a corner and I thought Kirkland clearly got the ball.
Watched the highlights this morning and Kirkland clearly gets the ball, but don't know why he has made the decision to come out. The Leeds player isn't going towards goal, silly decision from him.
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2005
- Messages
- 22,726
Watched the highlights this morning and Kirkland clearly gets the ball, but don't know why he has made the decision to come out. The Leeds player isn't going towards goal, silly decision from him.
Yeah, you're right mate.
I think he was right to come out for it. Only last week he was getting slated for being too stationary, yet when he runs out he gets slated again. There was a loose ball and he went for it. He clattered their player.
Fair enough to Kirkland.
Fair enough re the penalty.
Just football.
Fair enough to Kirkland.
Fair enough re the penalty.
Just football.
Watched the highlights this morning and Kirkland clearly gets the ball, but don't know why he has made the decision to come out. The Leeds player isn't going towards goal, silly decision from him.
Unfortunately getting the ball isn't the only thing the referee has to consider - essentially it's how he got the ball that's the issue and it was a correct decision.