Skip to main content

Proof Reach was onside

Proof Reach was onside

Initial though was that he was not offside from my view on AKTE ... this proves that to be correct.

I was totally pissed off at that point as I though that we did not deserve to lose but up we popped with an equaliser and I was over the moon.

Bit of a min-roller coaster and the subject of much debate afterwards in the pub.

Do we really want to ruin this with endless stop/start video replays ?
 
Initial though was that he was not offside from my view on AKTE ... this proves that to be correct.

I was totally pissed off at that point as I though that we did not deserve to lose but up we popped with an equaliser and I was over the moon.

Bit of a min-roller coaster and the subject of much debate afterwards in the pub.

Do we really want to ruin this with endless stop/start video replays ?

Im not sure that you would think the same if that goal was for promotion.............
 
Im not sure that you would think the same if that goal was for promotion.............

Good point. If this goal was the difference between us getting playoffs and not, then the thread discussing this would be 20 pages long at least.
 
I thought my old fella was winding me up when he stopped my screaming and dancing to tell me it was offside. I knew it wasn't. Mind you, the equaliser was sweet 🙂
 
I've no idea what the linesmen are watching half the time in our league. It's not that difficult is it?

It's simply a question of being able to see what is happening when the ball is played and not what happens half a second later when a player looks to be offside. Don't linesmen have to pass some sort of visual reference test to ensure that they can see both the offside line and the player who's playing the ball?
 
It's simply a question of being able to see what is happening when the ball is played and not what happens half a second later when a player looks to be offside. Don't linesmen have to pass some sort of visual reference test to ensure that they can see both the offside line and the player who's playing the ball?

It's actually a rule which is impossible to implement correctly a lot of the time.

And with no lining on the pitch it's pure guesswork by the officials in real time.
 
It's actually a rule which is impossible to implement correctly a lot of the time.

And with no lining on the pitch it's pure guesswork by the officials in real time.

I don't think it's that difficult but then I have excellent eyesight. I know for a fact that Trevor Toaster has absolutely shit eyesight and it wouldn't surprise me one bit to find out that 87% of all other officials are the same.
 
I don't think the offside was given against Reach. Going by the Sky highlights, when Reach shoots Doyle is encroaching on goal and possibly in an offside position. If that is the case then it's still a stupid decision because there's no way he was interfering with play.

I'm struggling to see how Doyle could have got himself in to an offside position from the time it left Gallys foot & arrived at Reach from that photo. Even then , how would he be interfering with play. A rank bad decision that trained officials are paid to get right
 
I don't think it's that difficult but then I have excellent eyesight. I know for a fact that Trevor Toaster has absolutely shit eyesight and it wouldn't surprise me one bit to find out that 87% of all other officials are the same.

Who said that?
 
I thought my old fella was winding me up when he stopped my screaming and dancing to tell me it was offside. I knew it wasn't. Mind you, the equaliser was sweet 🙂

Same boat as me, felt a bit stupid when I finally saw the flag flapping in the wind tbh.

Ended up ok though so no harm done and an interesting 'wrong' decision to discuss in the pub afterwards.
 
Back
Top