Skip to main content

Quality Performance

Quality Performance

For once we did not let ourselves down on national tv. Sadly the team selection was over cautious, if Gallagher and Garner had been on from the start we would have had a far better chance off going through. The team had done a great job in bringing Forest back to Deepdale, if you are not going to set up to have a go at home whats the point ? Very poor tactics imo.
 
You could see why Grayson brought Craig Davies in though. He's what we have been missing. Probably wouldn't have won on Saturday without him and might have got a goal last night if he'd been playing.
 
The closing down and winning the ball back was incredible last night, felt very proud to be a North End fan at the final whistle. Thought we made a very good side look piss poor especially in the 2nd half.
 
For once we did not let ourselves down on national tv. Sadly the team selection was over cautious, if Gallagher and Garner had been on from the start we would have had a far better chance off going through. The team had done a great job in bringing Forest back to Deepdale, if you are not going to set up to have a go at home whats the point ? Very poor tactics imo.

I was surprised when I heard the starting line up but for the first 45 I thought it was (with hindsight) spot on. The only change I'd have made would have been bringing Garner and Gallagher on 10 or 15 minutes earlier.
 
The first goal was crucial if we don't get it then we had to make sure they didn't get it. It was a killer for us but the lads will take great heart from their performance.

I think I know what you mean, 'cos if you mean what I think you mean then I think the same!

The team that SG put out was not (on paper) what you would consider an attacking team, but (and I know this sounds stupid) didn't do too bad apart from letting in the goal! If things had gone to plan and we didn't concede that goal I'm sure SG would have brought on Garner and Gallagher (as he did) late in the second half to score the winning goal!

That first crucial goal of theirs certainly fucked it up didn't it?
 
If we had been robbed of our leading scorer through injury or suspension,all would have been moaning,but he was missing by the managers choice and because Grayson is doing a good job overall nobody is mentioning it.So on this occasion he made a mistake ,in my opinion.
 
If we had been robbed of our leading scorer through injury or suspension,all would have been moaning,but he was missing by the managers choice and because Grayson is doing a good job overall nobody is mentioning it.So on this occasion he made a mistake ,in my opinion.

I think Davies did a decent job leading the line against Forest, the problem is he can't finish (even in the warm-up he often blazes shot after shot wide or into the Town End)! Garner and Craig Davies are obviously going to be our first choice strike pairing but I would have Beavon as third choice, then Kevin Davies, then Hume.

I thought Humphrey had his best game at Deepdale last night. Some decent balls into the box (including an absolute beauty late in the first half), lots of intelligent passes and movement, and tracking back very well. It feels like he's finally starting to turn the corner now, looks to have more confidence and he's showing more consistently what Grayson presumably saw in him.

Keane would probably have been in my first choice XI even prior to last night but I think it was arguably his best game for the club too.
 
I think Davies did a decent job leading the line against Forest, the problem is he can't finish (even in the warm-up he often blazes shot after shot wide or into the Town End)! Garner and Craig Davies are obviously going to be our first choice strike pairing but I would have Beavon as third choice, then Kevin Davies, then Hume.

I thought Humphrey had his best game at Deepdale last night. Some decent balls into the box (including an absolute beauty late in the first half), lots of intelligent passes and movement, and tracking back very well. It feels like he's finally starting to turn the corner now, looks to have more confidence and he's showing more consistently what Grayson presumably saw in him.

Keane would probably have been in my first choice XI even prior to last night but I think it was arguably his best game for the club too.

I suppose it's all about opinions but Kevin Davies would be the second name on my team sheet behind Declan Rudd...unless he lost a limb.
 
If we had been robbed of our leading scorer through injury or suspension,all would have been moaning,but he was missing by the managers choice and because Grayson is doing a good job overall nobody is mentioning it.So on this occasion he made a mistake ,in my opinion.


I think Waddie's analysis is pretty spot on (except he's totally wrong with his view on how crucial the first goal was!)... in that the manager decided on a game-plan to play tight for the first 60-70 minutes.. and try and push on in the final 25 minutes. Was that tactic really a "mistake"... against such accomplished opposition?

I bet Simon Grayson was as surprised as the rest of us, about how totally dominant our starting line-up proved to be. That was probably not really in the game-plan... but you seem to be blaming him for it!

The only thing I'd have done differently would have been to have brought on Gally and Garner a bit sooner. Because it really looked like Forest were never going to significantly threaten us... we could have 'gone for it' from perhaps 55-60 minutes into the game.

... but then, if he'd brought them on and we'd lost our dominance (against this good opposition)... then we'd be saying "Why did Grayson change it... it was going so well!"
 
SG had a game plan and it almost worked - fair enough. You could say that the initial line-up was over-cautious - if he wanted to keep Garner and Gallagher back then maybe Hume could have started at the expense of Humphrey or Keane or Holmes. To start at home with only one striker when we do have reserve options in that department is a bit unadventurous. But once we had gone behind then again we maybe should have brought Garner and Gallagher on earlier 55 minutes instead of 65 minutes might have made a difference - the initial line-up never really created a clear-cut chance.
But, as I've said elsewhere, the line-up with which we finished - a back-four with attacking fullbacks, a strong midfield trio with Gallagher in front of them and then two strikers upfront - looked really good. We really should settle on that as our consistent starting formation with Holmes held back as an alternative option for later in the game if necessary. That really should be the lesson from last night.
 
Last edited:
Everybody has their own opinions and mine are that I feel we have the best squad of players since our last promotion out of this league.
 
I think Waddie's analysis is pretty spot on (except he's totally wrong with his view on how crucial the first goal was!)... in that the manager decided on a game-plan to play tight for the first 60-70 minutes.. and try and push on in the final 25 minutes. Was that tactic really a "mistake"... against such accomplished opposition?

I bet Simon Grayson was as surprised as the rest of us, about how totally dominant our starting line-up proved to be. That was probably not really in the game-plan... but you seem to be blaming him for it!

The only thing I'd have done differently would have been to have brought on Gally and Garner a bit sooner. Because it really looked like Forest were never going to significantly threaten us... we could have 'gone for it' from perhaps 55-60 minutes into the game.

... but then, if he'd brought them on and we'd lost our dominance (against this good opposition)... then we'd be saying "Why did Grayson change it... it was going so well!"
Spot on great post. I would imagine all football minded people wold agree with this summing up.
 
I think Waddie's analysis is pretty spot on (except he's totally wrong with his view on how crucial the first goal was!)... in that the manager decided on a game-plan to play tight for the first 60-70 minutes.. and try and push on in the final 25 minutes. Was that tactic really a "mistake"... against such accomplished opposition?

I bet Simon Grayson was as surprised as the rest of us, about how totally dominant our starting line-up proved to be. That was probably not really in the game-plan... but you seem to be blaming him for it!

The only thing I'd have done differently would have been to have brought on Gally and Garner a bit sooner. Because it really looked like Forest were never going to significantly threaten us... we could have 'gone for it' from perhaps 55-60 minutes into the game.

... but then, if he'd brought them on and we'd lost our dominance (against this good opposition)... then we'd be saying "Why did Grayson change it... it was going so well!"

Agreed. Good post.

But, as I've said elsewhere, the line-up with which we finished - a back-four with attacking fullbacks, a strong midfield trio with Gallagher in front of them and then two strikers upfront - looked really good. We really should settle on that as our consistent starting formation with Holmes held back as an alternative option for later in the game if necessary. That really should be the lesson from last night.

Yeah that's not a bad shout, seeing as we don't really have any top class wide players. Only problem is it's pretty narrow and ideally we want to be exploiting the width of our pitch. But, then again, you've got to make the most out of what you've got and find the best fit. It could see us overrunning teams in the middle of the park, like we did to Forest last night. It's just whether we can make that possession count against the sides at our level!
 
To say we got what we deserved, fuck all, after two performances like that has to be one of the most stupid fucking comments ever. Just ask billy Davies and every other tv pundit, dont know what game you were watching but it certainly wasnt the same one the majority of us were, utter tripe.

It would seem whatever the club do or however well the team performs there are people on this forum who deliberately stir the shit and cause argument.
Before any smart arse says its "its a forum about opinions " I know.
 
To say we got what we deserved, fuck all, after two performances like that has to be one of the most stupid fucking comments ever. Just ask billy Davies and every other tv pundit, dont know what game you were watching but it certainly wasnt the same one the majority of us were, utter tripe.

The objective of the game is to put it in the net. Simple as that and there's no use getting your kegs in a twist because you thought we deserved to win; we didn't. Forest kept us from scoring that was their job and they succeeded.

Scoring is our weakness this season. And it is the weakness of scores of teams that put up a great display in cup games yet get knocked out. I've been watching and observing football long enough to say I saw it coming.

Yes we played out of our skins, but how many times have teams done that in the cup and been beaten.

Fuck me, let's all start feeling sorry for ourselves because we nearly won. We don't score enough goals, simple as that. And Craig Davies will likely remedy that.
 
Go back to making us laugh... because you're not too good at this proper football stuff 😛


I don't think I've seen a single post today which could be construed as someone 'feeling sorry for ourselves'. The vast majority are just marvelling at how well we played, and that we were unlucky.

In common football parlance, we "deserved to win". That's obvious. But we didn't win. That's also obvious.

But you are'nt using common football parlance. It's all black and white - because according to your opening line, every team in every match gets exactly what they deserve... so no point in any further chat. 🙄
 
Back
Top