Skip to main content

Questionable Grammar

Questionable Grammar

Language is a tool to communicate ideas.

Grammar is an attempt to control communication to silence views.

The majority of written communication is redundant anyway as we can work out what something means without even half of the words that actually appear.

The BBC is terrible at the moment, but to be honest who really cares?

???

Without grammar there is no language - it is an integral part.

Words/vocabulary communicate ideas: grammar delivers it in a format that the listener/reader can understand. I understand your point, made in your later post, about grammar being unfairly used to denigrate the views of others, but it is still a very odd statement.

As for your second point - you could strip out many words and keep the meaning. However, this would also strip out context, emotion, tone, voice, and all of the other hidden aspects of written language that convey ideas. They are just as important as the words actually written on the page. 🙂
 
???

Without grammar there is no language - it is an integral part.

Words/vocabulary communicate ideas: grammar delivers it in a format that the listener/reader can understand. I understand your point, made in your later post, about grammar being unfairly used to denigrate the views of others, but it is still a very odd statement.

As for your second point - you could strip out many words and keep the meaning. However, this would also strip out context, emotion, tone, voice, and all of the other hidden aspects of written language that convey ideas. They are just as important as the words actually written on the page. 🙂
Well said, Sepp Blatter.

Probably quite a rare sentence, that.
 
I like the fact that so many of this forum's users actually care about about what they have said when posting. Only the very worst offenders are upbraided by other users when it descends into text talk or chavdom.
I always try and re-read any post I want to place before hitting "Post Quick Reply", and it's only when I'm exceptionally drunk that I've not regretted not having done so. A glass or two this evening, but I've made several corrections to the above already.
It's the 'closed season' ffs. A thread about how we may want to moderate ourselves is as valid as any rumour about about us buying Messi or a Torquay reserve striker or somesuch.
Which reminds me - I'm sure its 'closed', not 'close' season. The latter makes no grammatical sense.
 
???

Without grammar there is no language - it is an integral part.

Words/vocabulary communicate ideas: grammar delivers it in a format that the listener/reader can understand. I understand your point, made in your later post, about grammar being unfairly used to denigrate the views of others, but it is still a very odd statement.

As for your second point - you could strip out many words and keep the meaning. However, this would also strip out context, emotion, tone, voice, and all of the other hidden aspects of written language that convey ideas. They are just as important as the words actually written on the page. 🙂


I'd love to contrbute to this discussion but I'm afraid you make me feel a bit unintelligent.
 
Sometimes they are - sometimes they are not. It depends upon what definition you use. 🙂

In the good old days an idiot was a person of profound mental retardation having a mental age below 3 years and generally being unable to learn connected speech or guard against common dangers.

A person who is thick is commonly described as someone who is either not easy to hear or understand or lacking mental agility.

Therefore, judging on the basis that I don't any 3 year-olds who can use the Internet to the degree that they can post on a forum I'd summarize by claiming that this board isn't infiltrated by idiots but by people who are a bit thick.
 
Last edited:
In the good old days an idiot was a person of profound mental retardation having a mental age below 3 years and generally being unable to learn connected speech or guard against common dangers.

A person who is thick is commonly described as someone who is either not easy to hear or understand or lacking mental agility.

Therefore, judging on the basis that I don't any 3 year-olds who can use the Internet to the degree that they can post on a forum I'd summarize by claiming that this board isn't infiltrated by idiots but by people who are a bit thick.

That did make me chuckle - might be useful for a spot of Nobber baiting now that he is a mod/viable target.

Go back even further, and 'idiot' meant someone who was completely self-centered and took no interest in their community, hence its other meaning of a person who is ignorant. Now, it can mean many things - in my case, a charmless, lumbering oaf 😀
 
In the good old days an idiot was a person of profound mental retardation having a mental age below 3 years and generally being unable to learn connected speech or guard against common dangers.

A person who is thick is commonly described as someone who is either not easy to hear or understand or lacking mental agility.

Therefore, judging on the basis that I don't any 3 year-olds who can use the Internet to the degree that they can post on a forum I'd summarize by claiming that this board isn't infiltrated by idiots but by people who are a bit thick.

Or in other words a professional footballer ??
 
Back
Top