Skip to main content

Rating Vrs Crewe

Rating Vrs Crewe

Joined
May 7, 2009
Messages
918
Rudd 7 - Didn't have masses to do but made some good saves when he had to

Connolly 6 - Steady if unspectacular
Huntington 7 - defensively good but too many hoofs upfield
Wright 7 - as above
Buchannon 6 - Steady if unspectacular

Holmes 7 - couldn't seem to get going 1st half but improved 2nd. Unlucky to hit post with a rocket.
Keane 8 - some excellent challenges. put himself about and broke up crewe's play.
Wroe 5 - Shocking today. Couldn't pick a pass
Monakana 4 - As per when he makes an appearance, anonymous.

Garner 5 - God gave you 2 feet for a reason.... To move with. Stay on them!!! offered little
Cummins 6 - worked hard but shocking finishing

King 6
Hayhurst 6
Foster (not on long enough to comment)
 
Last edited:
Rudd 7 - Didn't have masses to do but made some good saves when he had to

Connolly 6
Huntington 7 - defensively good but too many hoofs upfield
Wright 7 - as above
Buchannon 6

Holmes 6 - couldn't seem to get going
Keane 8 - some excellent challenges. put himself about and broke up crewe's play.
Wroe 5 - Shocking today. Couldn't pick a pass
Monakana 4 - As per when he makes an appearance, anonymous.

Garner 5 - God gave you 2 feet for a reason.... To move with. Stay on them!!! offered little
Cummins 6 - worked hard but shocking finishing

King 6
Hayhurst 6
Foster (not on long enough to comment)

Agree except I thought Homes was very good second half and deserves a 7. Connolly I also thought did well defensively. His strong suit isn't attacking 7.
 
Agree except I thought Homes was very good second half and deserves a 7. Connolly I also thought did well defensively. His strong suit isn't attacking 7.

Now you mention it I agree about Holmes. Forgot about his effort that hit the post too. Edited my scores.
 
Rudd - 7. Not much to do. Did well to get a hand to their goal.

Connolly - 6. Did okay a bit sloppy
Hunts - 7. Solid
Wright- 7. Ditto
Buchs- 6. Okay.

Holmes - 7. Not much in first half very good second
Wroe - 4. awful. Touch of Simon Whaley.
Keane - 9. Motm by a mile was quality.
Monakana - 4. Simon Whaley.

Garner - 5.5. Missed chances and couldn't get the ball down.
Cummins - 6. Worked very hard and did well off the ball.
 
Rudd 7
Connolly 5
Huntington 7
Wright 7
Buchanan 7
Holmes 7
Keane 8
Wroe 5
Monakana 4
Garner 4
Cummins 5

King 8
Hayhurst 6
Foster N/A
 
]Rudd 7

Connolly 5
Huntington 7
Wright 7
Buchanan 7

Holmes 8
Wroe 4
Keane 9
Monakana 4

Garner 4
Cummins 6
 
Rudd - 7

Connolly - 6
Huntington - 6
Wright - 7
Buchanan - 7

Monakana - 4
Wroe - 4
Keane - 8
Holmes - 7

Garner - 4
Cummins - 6

King - 7
Hayhurst - 6
 
I wasn't there guys but to give 2/3 players an 8, or even 9(!) is a bit weird, especially when we lost. Listened tot some of it on the radio and agree with most things but bit generous on the scores I reckon. No doubt a good day out. UTW!
 
I wasn't there guys but to give 2/3 players an 8, or even 9(!) is a bit weird, especially when we lost. Listened tot some of it on the radio and agree with most things but bit generous on the scores I reckon. No doubt a good day out. UTW!

Keane was excellent to be fair, deserving of a high score

I thought King had a great cameo too
 
Rudd 7 good save first half.

Connolly 4 worst player today giving ball away
Wright 7 good game and important tackles
Huntington 7 same as above
Buchnann 6 solid but let pogba in a lot

Holmes 8 good ball never gave up
Keane 8 great tackle good passes
Wroe 5 coul not pick pass
Monakana 6 couple good crosses struggled on bad surface dribbling

Garner 5 missed to sitters
Cummins 7 holdeld ball well good shot early on

King 6 won every header and looked sharp
Hayhurst 6 gave ball away a bit but did some good crosses
 
Interesting that Buchanan getting good scores yet his 'defending' for the goal was piss poor which in the end cost us a point.
 
Interesting that Buchanan getting good scores yet his 'defending' for the goal was piss poor which in the end cost us a point.

Just shows you how bad the rest were cause he was 1 off the better 1s

Jeff didn't help him much to his defence
 
Last edited:
Keane was excellent to be fair, deserving of a high score

I thought King had a great cameo too

I agree Keane stood out. Strong in the tackle, aggressive. Ball winner. Makes you realise how shit we have become. A game used to be remembered for a cracking 90th minute winner, not a 52nd minute tackle on the halfway line.
 
I agree Keane stood out. Strong in the tackle, aggressive. Ball winner. Makes you realise how shit we have become. A game used to be remembered for a cracking 90th minute winner, not a 52nd minute tackle on the halfway line.

You never watched Gregan play, did you?

It makes you realise how much Deepdale has missed a player like that.
 
Rudd - 6

Connolly - 5
Huntington - 5
Wright - 7
Buchanan - 7

Holmes - 7
Wroe - 4
Keane - 8
Monakana - 4

Garner - 3
Cummins - 6

Subs -
King - 5
Hayhurst - 5
Foster - N/A
 
Interesting that Buchanan getting good scores yet his 'defending' for the goal was piss poor which in the end cost us a point.

He was definitely one of the better players and although he should have done better with the goal, I thought Huntington was even at more fault for leaving his area at the centre and not covering his lines and allowing the player to easily take him on after he looked to have over touched it from taking on Buchanan.

Huntington was awful today. Hoofed it every time he got the ball and looked dodgy yet again. Think we need a proper CB alongside Wright as Huntington isn't the answer for me.
 
Back
Top