Ratings
Id add Kilkenny to the better scores. Yeah he got motm (I dont always agree with them) but he was one of the only players who actually wanted the ball and tried doing something with it. Thought humphrey was ok too. Biggest flop for me today was King. Should never play in defence again
Only Garner and Robinson looked like members of a promotion team. Felt sorry for them out there. Kilkenny huffed and puffed but their midfield outstripped us all game. Browne looked like he was running on empty out there in terms of both ideas and ability. Was surprised he wasnt subbed to be honest.
Humphrey played wwll
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2010
- Messages
- 160
Jones - 3 - no presence at set pieces and doesnt command area.
Clarke - 4 - Wasted at RB, average by his standards at CB.
King - 3 - why he is still in the squad i have no idea...poor today shouldve been subbed.
Huntington - 5 - won most things in the air, lacked pace, best CB today.
Buchanan - 4 - didnt offer much going forward today, Morais tore him apart
Browne - 2 - very poor today, looked lost, zapped of energy...shouldve been subbed.
Kilkenny - 6 - a lot of running not enough quality, retains possession well.
Humphrey - played well to start, until he was moved to RWB, wrongly subbed.
Gallagher - 3 - very poor, too slow in moving the ball, looked disinterested.
Robinson - 4 - tried hard, assist. Not much else though...
Garner - 4 - poor, no support. Had to create own chances as midfield were poor...
For me Grayson had it wrong from the first minute, Humphrey shouldve started RB like Fleetwood second half and King sent to the bench. We rely on Garner to much as he has no competition in K.Davies...new striker required in Jan! Welsh needs to be in next game as he shows Hunger and desire for the ball, what was missing today! Too much long ball...old school north end wingplay was required today...of which you dont get by playing 3 CBs...
Clarke - 4 - Wasted at RB, average by his standards at CB.
King - 3 - why he is still in the squad i have no idea...poor today shouldve been subbed.
Huntington - 5 - won most things in the air, lacked pace, best CB today.
Buchanan - 4 - didnt offer much going forward today, Morais tore him apart
Browne - 2 - very poor today, looked lost, zapped of energy...shouldve been subbed.
Kilkenny - 6 - a lot of running not enough quality, retains possession well.
Humphrey - played well to start, until he was moved to RWB, wrongly subbed.
Gallagher - 3 - very poor, too slow in moving the ball, looked disinterested.
Robinson - 4 - tried hard, assist. Not much else though...
Garner - 4 - poor, no support. Had to create own chances as midfield were poor...
For me Grayson had it wrong from the first minute, Humphrey shouldve started RB like Fleetwood second half and King sent to the bench. We rely on Garner to much as he has no competition in K.Davies...new striker required in Jan! Welsh needs to be in next game as he shows Hunger and desire for the ball, what was missing today! Too much long ball...old school north end wingplay was required today...of which you dont get by playing 3 CBs...
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
Jones - 7
Clarke - 5
King - 4
Huntington - 7
Buchanan -6
Kilkenny - 7
Browne - 6
Gallagher - 5
Humphrey - 7
Robinson - 6
Garner - 7
Laird - 6
K. Davies - 6
Reid - 6
Clarke - 5
King - 4
Huntington - 7
Buchanan -6
Kilkenny - 7
Browne - 6
Gallagher - 5
Humphrey - 7
Robinson - 6
Garner - 7
Laird - 6
K. Davies - 6
Reid - 6
Humphrey played wwll
Yes - he plays well every 20 minutes or so.
( in fairness he is by passed by the defense playing hoofball to a lone striker instead of passing it wide)
Yes - he plays well every 20 minutes or so.
( in fairness he is by passed by the defense playing hoofball to a lone striker instead of passing it wide)
He put in some great crosses today. Didn't do much wrong
I thought Humphrey was the nan of a poor match
I agree.
Apart from the 'nan' bit.
I'm assuming all these scores are out of 20?
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2008
- Messages
- 7,051
. Did you go to the match with your guide dogJones - 7
Clarke - 5
King - 4
Huntington - 7
Buchanan -6
Kilkenny - 7
Browne - 6
Gallagher - 5
Humphrey - 7
Robinson - 6
Garner - 7
Laird - 6
K. Davies - 6
Reid - 6
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2010
- Messages
- 850
Tactics cost us today. Grayson is reliable, consistent but he doesn't plan a thorough game plan like our opponents. A couple of standard tactics - the 451, the 3-5-2. Some players went about their jobs quite well, considering the constraints placed upon them. Some players like King and Clarke, subsequently got found out.
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2014
- Messages
- 717
I thought Killkenny palyed better than most, and showed more appetite than most (which shows how bad the rest were!). King and Hunts were awful, Browne looking lost. Big Kev could've boosted his ratings with 2 easy chances to score but fluffed as usual.
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2006
- Messages
- 1,496
Your knowledge is on par with the linesman on the inv pav side.Jones - 7
Clarke - 5
King - 4
Huntington - 7
Buchanan -6
Kilkenny - 7
Browne - 6
Gallagher - 5
Humphrey - 7
Robinson - 6
Garner - 7
Laird - 6
K. Davies - 6
Reid - 6