Skip to main content

Red cards...

Red cards...

Joined
Dec 29, 2007
Messages
305
That reflex save by Gallagher......things like that don't warrant a red card.....it's not as if it was pre- meditated. It was obvious from his reaction that he had no say in the matter.It was fuckin electrical impulses in his head caused it......such incidents should be seen for what they are....involuntary twitches.
 
Red card and sending off every day of the week for me , it is a normal reflex to stop the ball with any means but it stopped a certain goal .
 
This handball fiasco needs sorting out. The ball was on it's way into the net when Gallagher made a superb save. Penalty and red card; I have no problem with that. In certain cases (when in all probability a goal would have been scored) a penalty goal could be awarded.
All this hand to ball and ball to hand, in my opinion, is such a massive judgement for referees and so there is a lack of consistency in games as referees have different views. To cut this inconsistency out, if the ball hits the hand, it is hand ball, end of. In hockey, if the ball is struck against the foot, it is a free hit whether it is intentional or not. Perhaps if the FA were to look at other sports things might improve. With so much money involved in the game, it is time we consistency among match officials.
 
This handball fiasco needs sorting out. The ball was on it's way into the net when Gallagher made a superb save. Penalty and red card; I have no problem with that. In certain cases (when in all probability a goal would have been scored) a penalty goal could be awarded.
All this hand to ball and ball to hand, in my opinion, is such a massive judgement for referees and so there is a lack of consistency in games as referees have different views. To cut this inconsistency out, if the ball hits the hand, it is hand ball, end of. In hockey, if the ball is struck against the foot, it is a free hit whether it is intentional or not. Perhaps if the FA were to look at other sports things might improve. With so much money involved in the game, it is time we consistency among match officials.

What do you mean? Award the goal anyway and not send the player off?

As it stands the law is the right one, you can't have players making saves to give away a penalty but stay on the pitch.
 
Amazing how anyone can argue against that one.

He stopped a certain goal with both hands...
 
What do you mean? Award the goal anyway and not send the player off?

As it stands the law is the right one, you can't have players making saves to give away a penalty but stay on the pitch.

Sorry, I haven't made myself clear Tino. I mean award the goal and send the player off.
 
What happened to Gallagher was obviously correct but the way it's gone with players having to put their hands behind their back so that the ball doesn't by chance hit the hand is ridiculous. Penalties just be based on intent.
 
This handball fiasco needs sorting out. The ball was on it's way into the net when Gallagher made a superb save. Penalty and red card; I have no problem with that. In certain cases (when in all probability a goal would have been scored) a penalty goal could be awarded.
All this hand to ball and ball to hand, in my opinion, is such a massive judgement for referees and so there is a lack of consistency in games as referees have different views. To cut this inconsistency out, if the ball hits the hand, it is hand ball, end of. In hockey, if the ball is struck against the foot, it is a free hit whether it is intentional or not. Perhaps if the FA were to look at other sports things might improve. With so much money involved in the game, it is time we consistency among match officials.

Ludicrous suggestion....after the first week of the season there would be uproar as dozens of penalties are given. The game would become a farce as players just try to hit the ball against a defenders arms to get a penalty.
 
What happened to Gallagher was obviously correct but the way it's gone with players having to put their hands behind their back so that the ball doesn't by chance hit the hand is ridiculous. Penalties just be based on intent.

You're quite right, handballs have to be deliberate but I reckon 90% of those given are not deliberate. Deliberate handball is also a yellow card offence so if a player doesnt get booked the ref is admitting that it wasn't deliberate.
 
You're quite right, handballs have to be deliberate but I reckon 90% of those given are not deliberate. Deliberate handball is also a yellow card offence so if a player doesnt get booked the ref is admitting that it wasn't deliberate.

Yes, the wording of the law does say deliberate but it's the wording in the further guidance that gives direction to referees to award free kicks or penalties in circumstances that aren't necessarily deliberate in the more literal sense of the word, essentially the arm being in an unnatural position, the sort of penalty you can get when a player is blocking a shot or cross.

Handball is also not necessarily a yellow card offence, the guidance is to issue a caution when a player deliberately strikes the ball with his hand. This is mainly when they do so to stop an attack developing.

The other main time handball is a yellow card offence is when a player tries to score with a handball. For me, there is an argument that should be a red card. If a player is sent off for denying a goal scoring opportunity by handball, why shouldn't a player be sent off for trying to score via a handball?
 
Football needs a 10 minute sin-bin for yellow cards. That way, the team fouled against gets an advantage during the game, rather than some other team later in the season when 'totting-up' comes into the equation. Such a penalty might also reduce red cards in the first 10 minutes which ruin the game as a spectacle. It also gives the 4th official something to do during the game.
 
Back
Top