Skip to main content

Referee bias

Referee bias

Another one - Coventry being allowed to score on 96:20 at Deepdale the other week?

If we weren't so consistent at letting in late goals I might agree with you.
The fact that it happens as much as it does suggests there is more too it than simply adding a bit too much time.
 
Referees, for some reason, now have massive egos.

Graham Poll, for example, refers to himself in the third person.

One of my lecturers from uni writes for FIFA and was covering the game that Poll gave the same player three yellow cards in the 2006 World Cup.

Poll and the lecturer/journalist were staying in the same hotel and got a taxi to the ground together. On the way back, Poll was asked about the incident. Poll, completely unaware of the errors he made, thought about it for a moment before saying "nah, that doesn't sound like Graham Poll." Unbelievable.

Some do have egos but then some really don't
Point in question is our own Neil Swarbrick
A fantastic guy who has gently made his way from running the line on a cold Sunday under 11's match to now going fully professional - not an ego in sight
And still you will often see him on worden park or penny Holme with his son supporting him in his referring career.

We tend to only ever focus on a "bad" ref, it's not that common to hear "good ref today" being banded around when walking from the grounds of our clubs - we also by nature as fans show bias but then hey that's football.

All in all judging now by the speed of the game and the somewhat "dramatic" behaviour of many players I don't think that refs do such a bad job at all

Ps

Saturdays ref was consistent though !
 
If we weren't so consistent at letting in late goals I might agree with you.
The fact that it happens as much as it does suggests there is more too it than simply adding a bit too much time.

Yes, though in that instance we had survived the amount of time that should have been added.

I find it disappointing that a referee would come on here and talk about no one being able to comment until they had passed the referee exam. Then when faced with someone who has make up games that they had seen said person officiating and claim they were stealing match fees. That is not a very good attitude to have.

For me Tark summed up Saturdays game perfectly.
 
I find it disappointing that a referee would come on here and talk about no one being able to comment until they had passed the referee exam. .

I agree - by the same token, nobody should be able to talk about managers until they have coaching badges or talk about the merits of various players until they've played at a decent level.
 
I agree - by the same token, nobody should be able to talk about managers until they have coaching badges or talk about the merits of various players until they've played at a decent level.
Known on BBC Radio 5's 606 as the "Robbie Savage Law".
 
I agree - by the same token, nobody should be able to talk about managers until they have coaching badges or talk about the merits of various players until they've played at a decent level.

And, by the same logic, nobody should be able to point out that Nicholas Cage is a bloody awful actor unless they have done some acting.
 
This season will live long in the memory for me of when we just haven't had the rub of the green when it comes to referee decisions, I have never known anything like it. I have compiled a list of some of the serious discrepancies against our great club during the 2013/2014 season.

vs Port Vale - Garner Sent Off when there player signed a written statement that Garner did not touch him. Outcome Garner banned for 3 games, our top goal scorer.

vs Coventry - 5 Minutes of Extra Time allotted, 7 minutes played. Outcome an equaliser in the 96th minute costing us 3 points.

vs Nottingham Forest - 3 penalties not awarded. 1 Handball against Halford, 1 Handball against Henderson, 1 push in the back of Kevin Davies. Outcome, we are eliminated from the FA cup.

vs Leyton Orient - Time wasting and niggling fouls by the away side. Outcome, a draw but a fair result but still one of the worst refereeing performances ever seen at Deepdale.

vs Bradford - Kilkenny Sent Off, for a "push" on Kyle Bennett, leaving us without one of our most influential players in the centre of the pitch for most of the game. Outcome, a draw card later overturned.

If you can add anymore to this feel free.

However, I will argue that this is in no way and excuse for our failings, regardless of the referee on Saturday we had plenty of chances to score. C.Davies was put clean through by Keane and put it straight at there keeper, Gallagher should have scored from Wisemans cut back and the K.Davies header the less we say about that the better.
 
I've just watched the highlights of the games from Sunday and noticed Halford getting penalised for exactly the same thing he did at Deepdale - handball whilst lying on the floor. I cannot believe the referee didn't see the incident at Deepdale so can only come to the conclusion that the laws were applied in an inconsistent manner by two top referees.
 
This season will live long in the memory for me of when we just haven't had the rub of the green when it comes to referee decisions, I have never known anything like it. I have compiled a list of some of the serious discrepancies against our great club during the 2013/2014 season.

vs Port Vale - Garner Sent Off when there player signed a written statement that Garner did not touch him. Outcome Garner banned for 3 games, our top goal scorer.

vs Coventry - 5 Minutes of Extra Time allotted, 7 minutes played. Outcome an equaliser in the 96th minute costing us 3 points.

vs Nottingham Forest - 3 penalties not awarded. 1 Handball against Halford, 1 Handball against Henderson, 1 push in the back of Kevin Davies. Outcome, we are eliminated from the FA cup.

vs Leyton Orient - Time wasting and niggling fouls by the away side. Outcome, a draw but a fair result but still one of the worst refereeing performances ever seen at Deepdale.

vs Bradford - Kilkenny Sent Off, for a "push" on Kyle Bennett, leaving us without one of our most influential players in the centre of the pitch for most of the game. Outcome, a draw card later overturned.

If you can add anymore to this feel free.

However, I will argue that this is in no way and excuse for our failings, regardless of the referee on Saturday we had plenty of chances to score. C.Davies was put clean through by Keane and put it straight at there keeper, Gallagher should have scored from Wisemans cut back and the K.Davies header the less we say about that the better.

Talk about "Blue&White tinted glasses"!! This should be on a thread called "supporter bias" 😛
 
Talk about "Blue&White tinted glasses"!! This should be on a thread called "supporter bias" 😛

Have you taken your supporters exams?

I am about to fail mine and go to sleep having only just arrived at my Suzhou place. Somewhat poor effort but I promise I will do better with the commentary on Saturday night.
 
Back
Top