Skip to main content

Referee bias

Referee bias

Dry your eyes Girls !! The Ref had a decent game. Got the big decision correct for the penalty. Made a few silly mistakes e.g. The corner which he initially signalled a GK. I'm more disappointed Kevin Davies didn't score when he had the goal gaping and should have headed us in front.

What a surprise!!

You defending a ref!

Some of his decisions were shocking.
 
the ref was typical of what we see in this league. Poor rather than biased.

Rudd handled way out of his box, could have had a red. Penalty was soft, at best. They got away with no yellow cards. Keane was probably lucky not to have had 2 yellow cards.

I came off the game in quite a reflective mood, really. I think events caught up with everyone today. I think weve played a lot better than that and lost. Kev davies' miss was horrendous.

You mean the incident in the 2nd half? Rudd was about 5 yards out of his box but the ball clearly hit his chest, I could even hear it smash against his ribcage. It may have brushed part of his arm but no way was it deliberate, which a handball has to be for a player to be shown a straight red.
 
What a surprise!!

You defending a ref!

Some of his decisions were shocking.

He was one of the poorer ones IMO. The goal kick was only given as a corner due to the linesman, he allowed a number of their players (the 15 in particular) to consistently badger him throughout the game, the time wasting was not clamped down on once and the niggly fouls they committed consistently went unpunished.
 
You mean the incident in the 2nd half? Rudd was about 5 yards out of his box but the ball clearly hit his chest, I could even hear it smash against his ribcage. It may have brushed part of his arm but no way was it deliberate, which a handball has to be for a player to be shown a straight red.
Cheers for clearing that one up.
 
He missed Garner taking his shirt off after the goal - well, taking his shirt half off before being told to stop being a silly boy and then seeming to put it on the wrong way round!

I was under the impression that Garner turned his shirt around and then patted Finney's name. I assumed this was his way of dedicating the goal to Sir Tom.
 
the ref was typical of what we see in this league. Poor rather than biased.

Rudd handled way out of his box, could have had a red. Penalty was soft, at best. They got away with no yellow cards. Keane was probably lucky not to have had 2 yellow cards.

I came off the game in quite a reflective mood, really. I think events caught up with everyone today. I think weve played a lot better than that and lost. Kev davies' miss was horrendous.

Bang on with this Raefil, apart from the Rudd incident, i missed that
 
Last edited:
Ref was very poor - but equally for both sides.

I'm sure that in his pre-match preparation, he will have been mentally telling himself NOT to be biased towards North End.... something that would be easy given the emotion of the day... and for a while, I wondered if this was working against us. But ultimately, it was clear that he just had a bad day. Either he's crap, or the day got to him too... he is human after all.

Keane well deserved his yellow. It was at least his third significant foul. JG probably deserved it. But others from both sides deserved yellows too.

I've seen no replays, so might look a fool... but I thought our penalty was given using the totting up procedure! We deserved one overall... and Davies was fouled... but if that particular one had not been given, I would not have gone ballistic.

At the end of the day, if KD had not missed a header that my granny would have put in, this thread would never have been started.
 
I'm surprised Keane didn't a booking when he nailed that lad when the ball bounced and they both went in with their heads, he was clearly late and took him out. I think the ref just had a word.

The ref was like a Sunday morning ref, fucking shit!
 
I'm surprised Keane didn't a booking when he nailed that lad when the ball bounced and they both went in with their heads, he was clearly late and took him out. I think the ref just had a word.

The ref was like a Sunday morning ref, fucking shit!

He did have a word but it looked like he was saying one more and you're in the book. True to his word, as soon as Keane fouled their lad before the goal the card was straight out. One of the few things he got right.
 
At the end of the day, if KD had not missed a header that my granny would have put in, this thread would never have been started.

Kev should have done better, but a ball lobbed over from behind your shoulder is not the easiest thing to latch on to.
I'm staggered, fuming actually, that some of you are prepared to defend the ref. His first 10 mins in the 2nd half were so abysmal that if were the League assessor in the stands monitoring the fairness of the game, I would have come down on to the pitch and told him to fuck off back to Matchroom HQ and taken control of the game myself. We see many shite refs at our level (our two Cup matches officialled by Premiership refs this season have shown the gulf in class) but the double standards accepted by yesterday's ninkumpoop should not be acceptable at any level of the game.
I don't think Orient were particularly dirty and have nothing against them - they played to his whistle and got away with so much it's untrue. Yet they got away with so many ankle kicks, holding decisions, time wasting - not to mention the felling of Brownhill that went ignored that deliberate bias, bribery or corruption is the only explanation I can find. It was way beyond total incompetance, and were it not for a pair of good liners correcting the worst of his 'mistakes' on several occasions, we would have been totally shafted.
I was livid as I left Deepdale.
And yet, that all said, we didn't work their cheating cunt of a keeper hard enough, even though he should have been sent off for his clattering challenge into Garner with no attempt to play the ball.
We're better than Orient, but don't deserve an automatic spot at the moment.
Still - a third of the season to go, and lots might change yet. Unfortunately, cretinous refs won't be one of those things.
 
Kev should have done better, but a ball lobbed over from behind your shoulder is not the easiest thing to latch on to.
I'm staggered, fuming actually, that some of you are prepared to defend the ref. His first 10 mins in the 2nd half were so abysmal that if were the League assessor in the stands monitoring the fairness of the game, I would have come down on to the pitch and told him to fuck off back to Matchroom HQ and taken control of the game myself. We see many shite refs at our level (our two Cup matches officialled by Premiership refs this season have shown the gulf in class) but the double standards accepted by yesterday's ninkumpoop should not be acceptable at any level of the game.
I don't think Orient were particularly dirty and have nothing against them - they played to his whistle and got away with so much it's untrue. Yet they got away with so many ankle kicks, holding decisions, time wasting - not to mention the felling of Brownhill that went ignored that deliberate bias, bribery or corruption is the only explanation I can find. It was way beyond total incompetance, and were it not for a pair of good liners correcting the worst of his 'mistakes' on several occasions, we would have been totally shafted.
I was livid as I left Deepdale.
And yet, that all said, we didn't work their cheating cunt of a keeper hard enough, even though he should have been sent off for his clattering challenge into Garner with no attempt to play the ball.
We're better than Orient, but don't deserve an automatic spot at the moment.
Still - a third of the season to go, and lots might change yet. Unfortunately, cretinous refs won't be one of those things.

Well clever Bollocks, get your big gob down to Lancashire FA and take the refs course and make a difference.

I love all these Row 26 refs who think they know it all. The ref might as well go and sit with you as you clearly can see and read the game much better than him.
 
Standard referees defence I see.

Worth saying I have done a referees course, and have done some quite big games and I agree 100% with Tark's assessment.

There are certain things that you are taught that the referee simply did not do yesterday afternoon.
 
Standard referees defence I see.

Worth saying I have done a referees course, and have done some quite big games and I agree 100% with Tark's assessment.

There are certain things that you are taught that the referee simply did not do yesterday afternoon.
what level?
 
Level 1: National List Referees
Referees selected by The PGMOL to Referee on the National List (Football League or Premier League).
Thats very good, is that.
 
Still not shabby.

Used to do the line on a few of the Leicester City academy games, and conference reserve teams.

Uni and a few other things got in the way though so I lost registration and decided to get into playing with the supporters team.

Either way the referee yesterday was not good, and many of the decisions seemed to get in the way of good control of the match.
 
Back
Top