Skip to main content

Referee

Referee

The ref was a pratt - all to happy to blow up and too harsh in PNE. Although the sending off was, maybe, deserved - the refs lack of control of the match certainly contributed.
 
Cos he had an MK Dons shirt on?

Nah he was ok, MK played him. During the game I thought he was a TW*T but watched it again and his only crime was allowing MK to pick his decisions, he didn't see clearly. Was right to wave their Penalty appeal away, disallowed Clarkes goal because his view was blocked and they claimed pushing. Keanes yellow I think he got wrong, but was looking elsewhere when it happened and only saw the ball come off keane. Hugill Red, was deffo straight red and a learning Curve. Pickfords Yellow was down to the constant Moaning about time wasting even though he was within his rights to go to that side of the Goal Area. So Ref rating 6, because he was weak at dealing with them and also allowed the false Garner Reputation to decide his decisions.
 
I thought in the play off final he had a very good game, however today he made some poor decisions.
 
If he didn't see the alleged push then the goal stands!

In Theory yes, but in the heat on the moment with so many players claiming pushing, because they was embarrassed about how easy the goal was. Sadly not many PNE Players harass the refs. Clarke just seemed to accept it. It was 1 of 2 decisions he got wrong in my view, and we have had a few refs that have got 10-15 decisions wrong in the past. Maybe Grayson needs to get the players to get in the Refs faces a little more.
 
In Theory yes, but in the heat on the moment with so many players claiming pushing, because they was embarrassed about how easy the goal was. Sadly not many PNE Players harass the refs. Clarke just seemed to accept it. It was 1 of 2 decisions he got wrong in my view, and we have had a few refs that have got 10-15 decisions wrong in the past. Maybe Grayson needs to get the players to get in the Refs faces a little more.
Apologies but I don't see the point in players harassing the referee. Refs won't change a decision due to that.
 
Apologies but I don't see the point in players harassing the referee. Refs won't change a decision due to that.

If the ref knows he's going to get an ear full he might be reluctant to give a decision against the team that might give him the ear full.

Not saying every ref is like this but alot are , its the same way they bow to home croud pressure and give the home team the favourable decisions sometimes, human nature I think to be a coward ha-ha
 
In Theory yes, but in the heat on the moment with so many players claiming pushing, because they was embarrassed about how easy the goal was. Sadly not many PNE Players harass the refs. Clarke just seemed to accept it. It was 1 of 2 decisions he got wrong in my view, and we have had a few refs that have got 10-15 decisions wrong in the past. Maybe Grayson needs to get the players to get in the Refs faces a little more.

So you are saying our players should harass referees?

What is the point, he was not going to change his mind.
 
Refereeing is the one area of sport where I think rugby has it 100% spot-on. Total respect.

Football on the other hand................
 
So in your opinion Tom Clarke contests the decision and the Ref changes his mind and gives the goal?

If protested, the referee may of changed his mind on discussion with his Assistant.

So you are saying our players should harass referees?

What is the point, he was not going to change his mind.

The point is other teams do it and get the decisions, as long as players know where to draw the line. If we just accept every wrong decision we going to be in for a very hard season.
 
If protested, the referee may of changed his mind on discussion with his Assistant.



The point is other teams do it and get the decisions, as long as players know where to draw the line. If we just accept every wrong decision we going to be in for a very hard season.

I'm sorry but I don't know what else to say but that is just complete bollocks especially when you look at the new FA guidance.
 
Back
Top