I thought the referee had a shocker. He was picky,never let the game flow and insisted on lecturing players. He pulled up for foul throws, kicks from the wrong place and moving balls. Garner got no protection at all from the ref who just seemed to encourage them to provoke him. I know they have a hard task trying to sort out who is leaning in and who pushed, but I think if Mr Wright studies a video of the match, he will realise that he was Mr Wrong.
Referees & Garner
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,671
He pulled up for foul throws, kicks from the wrong place and moving balls.
And this is an issue why?
When we were at kick off to start the game, the ref went along the line and warned players not to move before he blew his whistle. I knew straight away what type of ref he was.......shite.The only reason the ref didn't book Garner in this incident was because he didn't want to book their guy as well and therefore have to send him off...
Ref was doing fine until the Vermijl throw in incident which was a strange one and then after that seemed to go massively downhill.
Agree!Garner was superb for us last night, their CBs were all over him and most of it wasn't legal. He got clattered a lot and got no protection from the ref at all. It is annoying when people start getting on his back about falling on the ground because the majority of the time its because a 6 foot plus defender has leaned on the back of him and simple physics dictates that if he is standing still and the defender is running forward and jumping at the same time he will get flattened.
He's definitely matured in the last couple of months since he got sent off against Wolves. We need his aggression in this league as some of the CBs are just going to be big lumps like Plastics and Reading so if he can get them wound up or booked early doors it will create space and time for everyone else. Yes he may pick up the odd booking but I'd rather have him in our team than be up against him.
He's also become a pretty useful defender at set pieces as his heading ability is unreal for someone of his height.
Garner for me has a right to go down a lot of the times because he puts his body in a position where the defender either can't get a good enough run/jump to win the ball or they have to clear him out to get to it, Referee's seem to think that every time he goes down he is faking the contact when if they actually watched him play on a regular basis you can tell he constantly puts his body on the line to win the ball, his work at defensive corners goes un-noticed quite a lot as well.
Birmingham last night decided to punch/kick and batter Garner as it plays into the Referee's hands because of his reputation meaning that he doesn't win as much from the referee, against Burnley he was smart and the defenders played him in a respectful manner and he had a field day.
Birmingham last night decided to punch/kick and batter Garner as it plays into the Referee's hands because of his reputation meaning that he doesn't win as much from the referee, against Burnley he was smart and the defenders played him in a respectful manner and he had a field day.
And if I was an opposing manager, or an opposing player, I would go out of my way to wind him up..... 🙂Garner for me has a right to go down a lot of the times because he puts his body in a position where the defender either can't get a good enough run/jump to win the ball or they have to clear him out to get to it, Referee's seem to think that every time he goes down he is faking the contact when if they actually watched him play on a regular basis you can tell he constantly puts his body on the line to win the ball, his work at defensive corners goes un-noticed quite a lot as well.
Birmingham last night decided to punch/kick and batter Garner as it plays into the Referee's hands because of his reputation meaning that he doesn't win as much from the referee, against Burnley he was smart and the defenders played him in a respectful manner and he had a field day.
Wouldn't change his playing style for anything. He intelligently waited for contact on Saturday from the Reading player to earn the penalty, its entirely up to the refs to give him more protection.
Plus the fact that from the 1st minute he is constantly winding at the opposition defenders its no wonder he gets kicked for an entire game. If he wasn't so in your face he'd lose that edge to his game and defenders would have a much easier time.
Last season his playing style had him adored by the fans, I don't see why that should change...
Plus the fact that from the 1st minute he is constantly winding at the opposition defenders its no wonder he gets kicked for an entire game. If he wasn't so in your face he'd lose that edge to his game and defenders would have a much easier time.
Last season his playing style had him adored by the fans, I don't see why that should change...
And this is an issue why?
It's an issue when he doesn't apply the laws consistently. When Brum took a throw from the wrong place, he made them take it again. When we did it he gave the throw to Brum.
I thought he was weak in the first half, kept shirking decisions. Eg when the keeper punched Tom Clarke in the first few minutes and he gave a goal kick, and a dangerous challenge on Browne when he blew for half time rather than deal with the offender. Second half he seemed to want to be the centre of attention. His numerous 'chats' with Garner were bizarre considering it was the defenders who were the aggressors.I thought the referee had a shocker. He was picky,never let the game flow and insisted on lecturing players. He pulled up for foul throws, kicks from the wrong place and moving balls. Garner got no protection at all from the ref who just seemed to encourage them to provoke him. I know they have a hard task trying to sort out who is leaning in and who pushed, but I think if Mr Wright studies a video of the match, he will realise that he was Mr Wrong.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 18,711
Garner for me has a right to go down a lot of the times because he puts his body in a position where the defender either can't get a good enough run/jump to win the ball or they have to clear him out to get to it, Referee's seem to think that every time he goes down he is faking the contact when if they actually watched him play on a regular basis you can tell he constantly puts his body on the line to win the ball, his work at defensive corners goes un-noticed quite a lot as well.
Birmingham last night decided to punch/kick and batter Garner as it plays into the Referee's hands because of his reputation meaning that he doesn't win as much from the referee, against Burnley he was smart and the defenders played him in a respectful manner and he had a field day.
Agree with that. Garner is a tough cookie and takes a right battering from a lot of big physical guys every week. He must wake up the next morning black and blue. All for the cause, of course.
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2008
- Messages
- 2,105
It's an issue when he doesn't apply the laws consistently. When Brum took a throw from the wrong place, he made them take it again. When we did it he gave the throw to Brum.
Were you at the game? ...... He reversed the throw in after shouting to our player twice to take it from the right place.
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2005
- Messages
- 29,601
Heard it more than once on hear that Garner is a knob head but he's our knob head. 🙂
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2005
- Messages
- 111,058
This is fact.Were you at the game? ...... He reversed the throw in after shouting to our player twice to take it from the right place.
I think Garner is good enough at this level, he's just got a different role this season... Unfortunately against Brum they knew what he was about and therefore played him at his own game, being a annoying little shit.
I love Garner though, gives his all and he does a job for us even when the goals dry up.
I love Garner though, gives his all and he does a job for us even when the goals dry up.