Skip to main content

Refs

Refs

Libertine

Thick Nomark
Joined
May 23, 2005
Messages
10,506
Location
Costa Del Leylando
I'm sorry, but the standard of the refereeing is shocking.
I thought it was bad in League 1, but we again saw last night that the officials are inept. Right down to basic decisions like giving a throw-in the right way, spotting a deflection from a shot for a corner and recognising a push in the defenders back (for Bristols goal). There were also fouls on Garner which were completely ignored (half his own fault). I'm not saying the decisions were all against us either, Bristol had a fair shout for a penalty, that I've not seen again on television, but it looked pretty nailed on at the time.
I'd be really interested to see the assessors report on the officials last night.
Is there a case for making the reports public do you think?
 
There were one or two dodgy decisions for both sides last night but nothing outrageous. The refs are the least of our problems to be honest.
 
The ref was about par for the course. The linesman on the Finney side, now that's a different issue. Totally inept. Couldn't make a decision about anything and from where I sat, almost behind the linesman, that was a stonewall penalty.
 
Aren't the majority of refs the same in L1 and Championship? There's probably an 'elite' group for big games but I thought they just tried to mix it up and have refs all over the leagues?
 
There were one or two dodgy decisions for both sides last night but nothing outrageous. The refs are the least of our problems to be honest.

I disagree, Garner could have had a penalty very early on when he was bundled over from a corner after shouting at the ref to look at the lads arms wrapped right around him. Not long after Welsh was bundled over in the box and the ref seemed to ignore that as well. Correct decisions in these circumstances can affect the whole game.

Aren't the majority of refs the same in L1 and Championship? There's probably an 'elite' group for big games but I thought they just tried to mix it up and have refs all over the leagues?

I didn't know that, but it's believable. But how about the refs reports being made public?
 
Have to say I thought there was a blatant push on Hunts I think it was in the run up to their goal.

That said we should've defended it better.
 
Still think that it should have been a foul on Bailey Wright that led to their goal! Clear push in the back

Just watched it back on Sky Sports video and the push is by Wilbraham, so he takes Bailey out with the push which allows him to trot into the box unmarked.
 
we were lucky we had a shit ref. Cunningham played basketball in the box at one point and the ref didn't give handball.
 
free kick should have been given to Welch on the edge of the box, not given, then he was brought down in the box, still nowt. May brings their player down, free kick, they do almost identical to one of ours....nowt. Having said that, they should have been at least 6 up by full time, shocking defending, Well done Pickford.
 
There were one or two dodgy decisions for both sides last night but nothing outrageous. The refs are the least of our problems to be honest.

The ref's failure to award an obvious foul by Wilbraham on Wright lead to the equaliser, I'd say that was fairly fundamental. There were also several yellow card offences unpunished. The alleged handball by Cunningham was clearly unintentional. There was also nearly a fight on the final whistle due to the ref's failure to stop play when Wright was being assaulted.
 
The Madley brothers always have stinkers when they ref PNE games. And they are suipposed to be premier league guys.
 
Back
Top