Reid ?
Wasn't there today. But unless he has improved his form immencely since Swindon and H&W then I'd say No.
Is it time for us to start him now by doing so, it will help him to gain his form & Fitness quicker?
Given the fact I've yet to see him beat a man in a league game, no Keith, this isn't the time to start him.
But I think Grayson may give him a chance next Saturday.
Today was an obvious game to start with Reid against his former club but I ended up feeling glad he only came off the bench, such was his pathetic contribution. He seemed determined to do anything but run to the byline. Another dismal Grayson signing on current form.
Today was an obvious game to start with Reid against his former club but I ended up feeling glad he only came off the bench, such was his pathetic contribution. He seemed determined to do anything but run to the byline. Another dismal Grayson signing on current form.
I am taking the Bradford fans applause when he came on to be they valued this guy. I think he will come good
Humphrey and Robinson were terrific today. Which one would you replace?
- Joined
- May 31, 2013
- Messages
- 612
Humphrey and Robinson were terrific today. Which one would you replace?
Neither, Reid on left,Humphrey on right, Robinson up front with Garner,Gallagher behind the front two,Welsh and Kilkenny sitting with Wiseman,Clarke,Wright and Buchanan and Stuckman in goal.
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2012
- Messages
- 151
^12 a side???
Neither, Reid on left,Humphrey on right, Robinson up front with Garner,Gallagher behind the front two,Welsh and Kilkenny sitting with Wiseman,Clarke,Wright and Buchanan and Stuckman in goal.
If only we could have 12 in our team!
- Joined
- May 31, 2013
- Messages
- 612
If only we could have 12 in our team!
Sorry should be Welsh OR Kilkenny sitting.
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2009
- Messages
- 2,876
Wasn't there today. But unless he has improved his form immencely since Swindon and H&W then I'd say No.
This, so far I fail to see why he was signed. Another injured player that we are carrying as a paid passenger.
I'd play Reid on the left and Humphrey on the right with Robinson and Garner up top. I'd leave Gallagher on the bench but then we have the problem in centre mid. Do we sacrifice all creativity through the middle and play Kilkenny and Welsh as you'd need Welsh ideally to offer some support to the back four. Or do you play Browne or Brownhill and risk getting bullied. This is the key area we need to strengthen.
Sorry should be Welsh OR Kilkenny sitting.
Which would give us a pathetically weak central midfield that would just get overrun. If you want Gallagher behind two strikers then you either have a four-man defence with a three-man midfield and width provided by the fullbacks or a three-man defence with the 'wing-back' four-man midfield - nothing else will work.
If SG persists with the ploy of playing Garner upfront by himself then he will be be out of a job before too long
I am taking the Bradford fans applause when he came on to be they valued this guy. I think he will come good
Only time will tell, but for North End, especially this season we do not have that time, something we knew when we signed him! 😕
V
villager
Which would give us a pathetically weak central midfield that would just get overrun. If you want Gallagher behind two strikers then you either have a four-man defence with a three-man midfield and width provided by the fullbacks or a three-man defence with the 'wing-back' four-man midfield - nothing else will work.
If SG persists with the ploy of playing Garner upfront by himself then he will be be out of a job before too long
I don't think he'll change his ways Ernest but I agree one upfront is no good.
Only time will tell, but for North End, especially this season we do not have that time, something we knew when we signed him! 😕
Garner, Humphrey, Wiseman etc are all examples of players fans wanted to right off but have come good..... not all players hit it off straight away
Garner, Humphrey, Wiseman etc are all examples of players fans wanted to right off but have come good..... not all players hit it off straight away
I am not disagreeing with you, but from North End's point, we have not the time to wait for Reid to regain full fitness,his speed and confidence back. We need some one now, promotion for me this season is a must and a player who is still not ready and looks along way off the player who played against us for Bradford last season is something that is not helping our situation.
I am not disagreeing with you, but from North End's point, we have not the time to wait for Reid to regain full fitness,his speed and confidence back. We need some one now, promotion for me this season is a must and a player who is still not ready and looks along way off the player who played against us for Bradford last season is something that is not helping our situation.
We have to pay money for someone to hit the ground running and the top of their game unfortunately
We have to pay money for someone to hit the ground running and the top of their game unfortunately
If that was what was needed then we should have bought some one, we still do not know if Reid will get his pace and confidence back, which we witnessed playing against us last season.
If that was what was needed then we should have bought some one, we still do not know if Reid will get his pace and confidence back, which we witnessed playing against us last season.
That's what every team in the country needs though.