Skip to main content

Reid

Reid

Tried too hard to impress, going for glory himself rather than passing or crossing to better placed team mates again and again. Brownhill and Kilkenny were impressive last night but Reid was hopeless (against opposition largely letting us attack them, ideal for a winger you would think, but there was zero end product from Kyle). League 2 standard at best sadly - time to loan him out or sell him.
 
Poor. Went missing for long periods. Not a left winger IMHO. Missed a golden opportunity when through on goal. Needs to go out on loan.
 
For his 1st game of the season I didn't think it was quite as bad as the last 2 posts described. Caused them trouble with his pace and hassled their full backs. Also tracked back and helped the defence out at times. Could be a dangerous weapon to bring off the bench.
Yes he messed up a 1 on 1 and had a few wayward efforts but he'll come on for getting some game time. We haven't got anyone else with his kind of pace.
 
Reid was decent last night, Impressed with how he got in the faces of their players and looked very pacy.
 
Reid was decent last night, Impressed with how he got in the faces of their players and looked very pacy.

Are you talking about Beryl Reid.

The Reid which played last night, could'nt hit a cows arse with a banjo.!
 
No composure when it mattered last night,did not make the keeper work from several opportunities.
 
Overall I thought he did okay. Considering this was his first full pre-season in how long since his injury too.

Yes, he messed up a good chance and hit a few wayward shots but all in all, he was fairly solid and his pace caused them an issue or two.
 
Reid, has loads of pace and is not short of talent, his problem is his attitude, he is in the same position as Huntingdon around eighteen months ago, out of favour and on his way out. Could he show the same dedication as hunts and come through, I doubt it, it would to radical a change of attitude, he seems to me a lazy player, shame !
A bit of a simon whaley.
 
Tried too hard to impress, going for glory himself rather than passing or crossing to better placed team mates again and again.

He was trying hard too impress yes, and like you say looking for a goal when maybe there was a pass on, but he's not the only one who does that, our main striker is probably the worse for it!!

Poor. Went missing for long periods. Not a left winger IMHO. Missed a golden opportunity when through on goal. Needs to go out on loan.

A golden opportunity? I assume you're talking about the one where he was on his own against 2 defenders, he shrugged one off, turned the other one and then hit a decent effort from the edge of the box?

Reid was decent last night, Impressed with how he got in the faces of their players and looked very pacy.

I agree really. I thought he did ok.

Reid, has loads of pace and is not short of talent, his problem is his attitude, he is in the same position as Huntingdon around eighteen months ago, out of favour and on his way out. Could he show the same dedication as hunts and come through, I doubt it, it would to radical a change of attitude, he seems to me a lazy player, shame !
A bit of a simon whaley.

Wow, that's not what I saw. I saw him tracking back, getting stuck in and closing down their full backs to block clearances etc. I doubt he'll have a turnaround ala Huntington but calling him lazy just seems an easy thing to say.

Wingers are by and large inconsistent, at least he looked to put crosses in early rather than cutting back all the time, but he looked desperate to either score, hence the shots in the 2nd half - no doubt after Grayson had encouraged him to get involved and try a few shots - or to grab an assist.
 
Thought Reid was alright last night to be honest, caused them a few problems and covered a lot of ground.

Think 'golden opportunity' is a bit strong when talking about his chance on the break, he still had a lot to do, barged past one player and was up against another pacey player so decided to get a shot away from outside the box, rather than going past him.

His right foot is bad though, some absolutely wild shooting.
 
I didn't mind the wayward shooting but was concerned when twice, he failed to clear the ball from just outside our penalty area. He will never be a wing back, just a tricky left winger. Substitute at best for me.
 
Thought Reid was alright last night to be honest, caused them a few problems and covered a lot of ground.

Think 'golden opportunity' is a bit strong when talking about his chance on the break, he still had a lot to do, barged past one player and was up against another pacey player so decided to get a shot away from outside the box, rather than going past him.

His right foot is bad though, some absolutely wild shooting.

+1 spot on for me this. He has pace, and did work at times last to close opposition down, but I feel just lacking confidence. Perhaps a months loan would do him good.
 
+1 spot on for me this. He has pace, and did work at times last to close opposition down, but I feel just lacking confidence. Perhaps a months loan would do him good.
Might be a decent shout, that. for me he needs game time but Im not sure thats going to happen here, right now.

Sorry, I know some need to victimise a player, its a tradition, but this lads a decent footballer working his way back from a serious injury. Only game time will now get the best out of him.

Lazy? Get a grip!!
 
Reid, has loads of pace and is not short of talent, his problem is his attitude, he is in the same position as Huntingdon around eighteen months ago, out of favour and on his way out. Could he show the same dedication as hunts and come through, I doubt it, it would to radical a change of attitude, he seems to me a lazy player, shame !
A bit of a simon whaley.


Any comparison with Whaley is pure folly. During Whaleys purple patch he was very good & his goal return was impressive. Dont forget that there was once whispers of him being valued at more than Nugent. Yes, his career went rapidly downhill, but some people have short memories. As for Reid. There is a player there but I struggle to see him getting many opportunities with the way Grayson sets us up . Impact sub at best? I'd really like to be wrong
 
Any comparison with Whaley is pure folly. During Whaleys purple patch he was very good & his goal return was impressive. Dont forget that there was once whispers of him being valued at more than Nugent. Yes, his career went rapidly downhill, but some people have short memories. As for Reid. There is a player there but I struggle to see him getting many opportunities with the way Grayson sets us up . Impact sub at best? I'd really like to be wrong

My comparison with whaley was from a talented but under achieving perspective, as for whaleys scoring record 14 goals in 120 games hardly leaves room for a purple patch !
 
Simon Whaley was absolute class under Billy Davies, it all went to shit under Simpson.

During that spell under BD, i'd probably say he was the best right winger i've seen for PNE.
 
Any comparison with Whaley is pure folly. During Whaleys purple patch he was very good & his goal return was impressive. Dont forget that there was once whispers of him being valued at more than Nugent. Yes, his career went rapidly downhill, but some people have short memories. As for Reid. There is a player there but I struggle to see him getting many opportunities with the way Grayson sets us up . Impact sub at best? I'd really like to be wrong

It's difficult getting the balance of the bench right.

Should we go for 3 impact subs, 2 barely noticeable ones and 2 bugger all difference ones?
 
Back
Top