Skip to main content

Remember this...

Remember this...

Gregan was a midfield enforcer / bully .... Gallagher is more of a cultured footballer .

Depends what you want in player I suppose ... different type's of player I suppose so hard to compare IMHO

SG stats probably slightly better than Davies but BD's stats at a higher level so again hard to compare ... as for styles of play think Davies maybe edges it but did have a better standard of player at is disposal. But neither played what you would call 'Barcelona' style football if were being honest.

Look at what BD inherited compared to what SG inherited and that will give you an indicator of who is the better manager.

BD inherited players like McKenna, Alexander, Nugent, Lewis, Hill, Davies, Mears, Cresswell, and O'Neil.

SG inherited players like Wroe, Robertson, Monakana, Procter, Mousinho, Byrom, Laird, Buchanan, King, Keane, Cummins, Beardsley and Foster.

Even if different leagues I think you can compare who did a better job.

SG had a failed play off campaign and a successful one in just over 2 season of management, BD had 2 failed ones and didn't have to rebuild a club.
 
Look at what BD inherited compared to what SG inherited and that will give you an indicator of who is the better manager.

BD inherited players like McKenna, Alexander, Nugent, Lewis, Hill, Davies, Mears, Cresswell, and O'Neil.

SG inherited players like Wroe, Robertson, Monakana, Procter, Mousinho, Byrom, Laird, Buchanan, King, Keane, Cummins, Beardsley and Foster.

Even if different leagues I think you can compare who did a better job.

SG had a failed play off campaign and a successful one in just over 2 season of management, BD had 2 failed ones and didn't have to rebuild a club.

You make a fair point there Ron about it being a rebuilding job for SG perhaps started by 'Hatchet' man Westley who pruned the high earners brought in by Irvine so on reflection SG may just about edge BD on who has been most successful. The proof of this of course may well be proved if TH opens the cheque book in the summer and allows SG to bring in some quality to the squad.
One thing that I think is overlooked by many is the actual amount of time Beckford probably out most potent threat up front has been sidelined this season.
Maybe I am biased but the way in which BD eventually left the club also left a sour taste in my mouth.

Gregan v Gallagher ? What's your view ?
 
You make a fair point there Ron about it being a rebuilding job for SG perhaps started by 'Hatchet' man Westley who pruned the high earners brought in by Irvine so on reflection SG may just about edge BD on who has been most successful. The proof of this of course may well be proved if TH opens the cheque book in the summer and allows SG to bring in some quality to the squad.
One thing that I think is overlooked by many is the actual amount of time Beckford probably out most potent threat up front has been sidelined this season.
Maybe I am biased but the way in which BD eventually left the club also left a sour taste in my mouth.

Gregan v Gallagher ? What's your view ?

It may come as a shock but during the Gregan era I wasn't as involved with PNE as I am now, so can't really comment but with the way the coffin dodger father talks about him he seemed a bit of a legend.

Times are changing in football and the way Gregan has been described by some on here and my father he would be a perfect fit for the era of the game he was involved in but nowadays he might not fair as well as someone like Gallagher where skill and panache are needed more than brute force to drive you forward in a game.

The rise of Gallagher I think has directly contributed to the rise of PNE, he has grabbed some games by the scruff of the neck attacking wise Rotherham, Wolves and Bristol City to name a few and wouldn't like him to go for an op before the games against Burnley and Rovers.
 
Such totally different kinds of players that any comparison is meaningless. In fact at Championship level Gregan was really a central defender not a midfielder.

Think your right about comparisons Ernie , totally different type of players.
Out of interest when Gregan went to Leeds was he CB or midfield ? Seem to remember him being skinned when Nugent scored that wonder goal 'John BARNES v Brazil style' at Elland Road but not sure where he played.
 
It may come as a shock but during the Gregan era I wasn't as involved with PNE as I am now, so can't really comment but with the way the coffin dodger father talks about him he seemed a bit of a legend.

Times are changing in football and the way Gregan has been described by some on here and my father he would be a perfect fit for the era of the game he was involved in but nowadays he might not fair as well as someone like Gallagher where skill and panache are needed more than brute force to drive you forward in a game.

The rise of Gallagher I think has directly contributed to the rise of PNE, he has grabbed some games by the scruff of the neck attacking wise Rotherham, Wolves and Bristol City to name a few and wouldn't like him to go for an op before the games against Burnley and Rovers.

GREGAN in his day was awesome and many on here have waxed lyrical about him and rightly so. many a game we were one down and Gregan picked the team up got them going and we won 2-1, it was an exciting time with MOYES then Billy DAVIES playing some great football.

I have to agree with Ron regarding the teams that these managers took over and SG comes out on top by a country mile.

the team we have now is nothing compared to what SG took over and he hasn't spent a fortune getting that team together.

My worry is that the higher up the league we go the more a club with big bucks may try and poach him.

SG has done a fantastic job and long may that continue.
 
It may come as a shock but during the Gregan era I wasn't as involved with PNE as I am now, so can't really comment but with the way the coffin dodger father talks about him he seemed a bit of a legend.

Times are changing in football and the way Gregan has been described by some on here and my father he would be a perfect fit for the era of the game he was involved in but nowadays he might not fair as well as someone like Gallagher where skill and panache are needed more than brute force to drive you forward in a game.

The rise of Gallagher I think has directly contributed to the rise of PNE, he has grabbed some games by the scruff of the neck attacking wise Rotherham, Wolves and Bristol City to name a few and wouldn't like him to go for an op before the games against Burnley and Rovers.

Think Gregan and his partner Rankine for that matter are hero worshipped by a lot of nobbers because they were part of a long overdue bit of success that the fans craved. Ability wise they could do a good job in the team at that time but both had their limitations with Gregan perhaps having more scope due to his size and lead by example mindset he had.
Again your bang on the button about Gallagher whereas this season he has stepped up-to the plate on some big occasions and gone someway to dispel the rumour that he was a 'flat track' bully in some people's eyes.
And with this in mind I agree that we may well need his undoubted ability in the 'big derbies' that we have to come against very average Bolton & Blackburn teams, he could make all the difference if he puts his best foot forward.
 
Think Gregan and his partner Rankine for that matter are hero worshipped by a lot of nobbers because they were part of a long overdue bit of success that the fans craved. Ability wise they could do a good job in the team at that time but both had their limitations with Gregan perhaps having more scope due to his size and lead by example mindset he had.
Again your bang on the button about Gallagher whereas this season he has stepped up-to the plate on some big occasions and gone someway to dispel the rumour that he was a 'flat track' bully in some people's eyes.
And with this in mind I agree that we may well need his undoubted ability in the 'big derbies' that we have to come against very average Bolton & Blackburn teams, he could make all the difference if he puts his best foot forward.

Difficult to compare players of different styles objectively but my view is that there'd be a place (as captain) for Gregan in every North End team in my era (1986 onwards).
 
Think Gregan and his partner Rankine for that matter are hero worshipped by a lot of nobbers because they were part of a long overdue bit of success that the fans craved. Ability wise they could do a good job in the team at that time but both had their limitations with Gregan perhaps having more scope due to his size and lead by example mindset he had.
Again your bang on the button about Gallagher whereas this season he has stepped up-to the plate on some big occasions and gone someway to dispel the rumour that he was a 'flat track' bully in some people's eyes.
And with this in mind I agree that we may well need his undoubted ability in the 'big derbies' that we have to come against very average Bolton & Blackburn teams, he could make all the difference if he puts his best foot forward.

Forgot to add Charlton and MK Dons to that as well.

I think he pips Cunningham for my player of the season now thinking about it.

We are lucky to have him.
 
Difficult to compare players of different styles objectively but my view is that there'd be a place (as captain) for Gregan in every North End team in my era (1986 onwards).

As I said previously Simo perhaps you choice is based on good memories/era/age rather than footballing ability maybe ?

I liked Gregan but in the right team at the right time hence the fond memories. Nice bloke off the field also.
 
Tried my best but it doesn't work.... Comparing Gallagher and Gregan is almost on a par with comparing a keeper to a striker...You can't !..In fact you could very easily accomodate both in a team( and be blessed) which sort of proves the point.
 
Tried my best but it doesn't work.... Comparing Gallagher and Gregan is almost on a par with comparing a keeper to a striker...You can't !..In fact you could very easily accomodate both in a team( and be blessed) which sort of proves the point.

We agree then Libs , Gallagher is totally different gravy in terms of pure footballing prowess/ability, nice one.
 
Eyres away at Wigan.

You simply had to be there.

Even the Pie Eaters applauded the goal.

I've never seen the goal since that night but I recall their goalie just standing there also applauding. No frustration or anger, he just accepted that he'd been beaten by an unstoppable shot. Must have been at least 30 yds out.
 
Back
Top