Skip to main content

Retained List

Retained List

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
Who stays, who goes?

GK's

Maxwell - Keep
Lindegaard - Release
Hudson - Keep

Def's

Vermijl - Keep
Baptiste - Sign if possible
Woods - Keep
Hunts - Keep
Clarke - Keep
Boyle - Keep
Cunningham - Keep
Spurr - Sell
Davies - Sell
Browning - Send Back

Mid's

Horgan - Keep
Browne - Keep
Gally - Keep
Pearson - Keep
Robinson - Keep
DJ - Keep
Welsh - Keep
Pringle - Sell
Grimshaw - Sell
McGeady - Keep but will never happen

Strikers

Hugill - Keep
Bark-Hay-Zen - Keep (New contract asap please)
Beckford - Release
May - Sell/Loan out for season
Makienok - Keep
Doyle - Sell if we can find a sucker
 
Can't see us selling Spurr. He has another year left I think and will probably see out his contract.

I wouldn't sign Makienok permanently. The team has evolved massively this season and although he is a 'different' option, I think we could sign better. Cauley Woodrow would be on my list.

What happens with May is anyone's guess, he hasn't had a decent run yet but with a full pre season under his belt who knows, he could surprise a few.

Wouldn't be against a season long loan for Browning, but his injury record is a slight concern. We need to solidify the RB position.
 
- Not bothered about keeping Baptiste or Browning, the former is a quality player but we can't afford to carry crocks.

- Trying to re-sign McGeady is a given.

- Makienok is a decent targetman but I reckon we could easily find someone similar from the lower leagues who would want less money.
 
Sorry but there's more than a couple of questionable ones in there for me.

You think we should sell a 21-year-old left-sided CB/LB who has been crucial to a run of form that has seen a side move into the automatic promotion places the league below.

You think we should sell a 22-year-old who has captained Manchester United's U21 side and has not played a single league game in his preferred position for us, and when he has played in the league he has been out of position sometimes as far as RWB.

You think you've seen enough of May to know that he needs to be moved along - a player that has just spent over a year out injured and has barely touched a ball for us.

You think we should sell a LB who has been kept out by one of the best left-backs in the league and, despite some slow starts, really hasn't looked all that bad when called upon.

In response to all of the above, I'll refer you to your initial judgement of Ben Pearson: ie, fucking miles out.
 
Sorry but there's more than a couple of questionable ones in there for me.

You think we should sell a 21-year-old left-sided CB/LB who has been crucial to a run of form that has seen a side move into the automatic promotion places the league below.

You think we should sell a 22-year-old who has captained Manchester United's U21 side and has not played a single league game in his preferred position for us, and when he has played in the league he has been out of position sometimes as far as RWB.

You think you've seen enough of May to know that he needs to be moved along - a player that has just spent over a year out injured and has barely touched a ball for us.

You think we should sell a LB who has been kept out by one of the best left-backs in the league and, despite some slow starts, really hasn't looked all that bad when called upon.

In response to all of the above, I'll refer you to your initial judgement of Ben Pearson: ie, fucking miles out.

Agree on all those points.
 
- Not bothered about keeping Baptiste or Browning, the former is a quality player but we can't afford to carry crocks.

- Trying to re-sign McGeady is a given.

- Makienok is a decent targetman but I reckon we could easily find someone similar from the lower leagues who would want less money.

Charlie Wyke has had 4 goals, and 3 assists in 8 games at Bradford. His value will have gone up since his January move from Carlisle.
 
Charlie Wyke has had 4 goals, and 3 assists in 8 games at Bradford. His value will have gone up since his January move from Carlisle.

Plenty more Barkhuizen's, Robinson's and Hugill's out there.

Sounds like we had a good look at Wyke but didn't think he was up to it.
 
Can't see us selling Spurr. He has another year left I think and will probably see out his contract.

I wouldn't sign Makienok permanently. The team has evolved massively this season and although he is a 'different' option, I think we could sign better. Cauley Woodrow would be on my list.

What happens with May is anyone's guess, he hasn't had a decent run yet but with a full pre season under his belt who knows, he could surprise a few.

Wouldn't be against a season long loan for Browning, but his injury record is a slight concern. We need to solidify the RB position.

Spurr has 2 years left. So do Vermijl, Pringle and Doyle but I would still bin them if poss. I don't mind Spurr to be honest, contrary to popular opinion.

As for Makienok, SG normally has a striker like this in the squad like who isn't a goalscorer but is a target man who creates chances for other strikers and etc. Kevin Davies springs to mind. If Makienok doesn't return we'll probably just sign another target man anyway as even if we're not using one regularly, it's daft not to have that option in the squad, as Tuesday at Derby showed when he got the flick on for the goal.

We do need another typical no.9 forward though as well and Woodrow isn't a bad shout.

I like Browning and Baptiste but despite their difference in ages, they both carry injury issues. If Baps was on a free I'd take him.

I think May will stick around until August, at which point if he isn't playing he will leave on loan or even permanently because as other posters have said in the last few days, for the sake of his career he can't afford a THIRD season of doing absolutely nothing.
 
Sorry but there's more than a couple of questionable ones in there for me.

You think we should sell a 21-year-old left-sided CB/LB who has been crucial to a run of form that has seen a side move into the automatic promotion places the league below.

You think we should sell a 22-year-old who has captained Manchester United's U21 side and has not played a single league game in his preferred position for us, and when he has played in the league he has been out of position sometimes as far as RWB.

You think you've seen enough of May to know that he needs to be moved along - a player that has just spent over a year out injured and has barely touched a ball for us.

You think we should sell a LB who has been kept out by one of the best left-backs in the league and, despite some slow starts, really hasn't looked all that bad when called upon.

In response to all of the above, I'll refer you to your initial judgement of Ben Pearson: ie, fucking miles out.

Don't worry, if it was up to SportsLawyer we would have sold Ben Pearson ages ago...
Barkhuizen was terrific on Sat & looks a real prospect, but he only signed a lengthy contract 2 months back. They're not going to be sitting him down to discuss a new contract, even if he has scored a few goals.

SportsLawyer is taking a very short sighted approach to some names above.
I'm happy to leave it up to Grayson & staff to make the right calls, they usually get it spot on.

Edit: Just read your last paragraph... Exactly!
 
Last edited:
Plenty more Barkhuizen's, Robinson's and Hugill's out there.

Sounds like we had a good look at Wyke but didn't think he was up to it.

Exactly. Just highlighting it shows there are players out there who seem capable of playing at a higher level and aren't demanding massive fees or wages.
 
Sorry but there's more than a couple of questionable ones in there for me.

You think we should sell a 21-year-old left-sided CB/LB who has been crucial to a run of form that has seen a side move into the automatic promotion places the league below.

You think we should sell a 22-year-old who has captained Manchester United's U21 side and has not played a single league game in his preferred position for us, and when he has played in the league he has been out of position sometimes as far as RWB.

You think you've seen enough of May to know that he needs to be moved along - a player that has just spent over a year out injured and has barely touched a ball for us.

You think we should sell a LB who has been kept out by one of the best left-backs in the league and, despite some slow starts, really hasn't looked all that bad when called upon.

In response to all of the above, I'll refer you to your initial judgement of Ben Pearson: ie, fucking miles out.

On Ben Davies, I'm glad he is doing well at Fleetwood but lets not forget how poor he has been for us when he has actually played, and he's miles away from our first team. His last league appearance was when Campbell-Ryce destroyed him and he was hooked at half-time in August 2014.

As for Grimshaw, some Chesterfield fans are saying he's possibly the worst signing they've ever made. Yes, he's not played much in central midfield but there must be a reason for that, and that is that Grayson clearly deems him much worse than our other options. He couldn't even get a game in midfield at Rotherham when our other tacklers, Browne, Welsh and Pearson, were all out injured. I don't usually take much notice of opposition fan opinions but they are worryingly and unanimously bad comments about Grimshaw, at a lower level too.

I don't have an issue keeping these types of cheap, young squad fillers around as they aren't exactly a financial burden, but I just can't see either of those two ever making a big impact and establishing themselves in the first team squad, especially considering what we've already got.

As for May, I won't do yet another long paragraph about it but as I said yesterday, something has to give soon. If he isn't going to play then he needs to leave to get his career back on track.
 
It would appear you are forgetting Woods who can,t be far off a return. Sorry I am wrong. Lazy reading.
 
Last edited:
Spurr is a limited player, but he's not a bad fill in option in the events that Cunningham is injured/suspended, we've had worse options inn the past
 
Who stays, who goes?

GK's

Maxwell - Keep
Lindegaard - Release
Hudson - Keep

Def's

Vermijl - Keep
Baptiste - Sign if possible
Woods - Keep
Hunts - Keep
Clarke - Keep
Boyle - Keep
Cunningham - Keep
Spurr - Sell
Davies - Sell
Browning - Send Back

Mid's

Horgan - Keep
Browne - Keep
Gally - Keep
Pearson - Keep
Robinson - Keep
DJ - Keep
Welsh - Keep
Pringle - Sell
Grimshaw - Sell
McGeady - Keep but will never happen

Strikers

Hugill - Keep
Bark-Hay-Zen - Keep (New contract asap please)
Beckford - Release
May - Sell/Loan out for season
Makienok - Keep
Doyle - Sell if we can find a sucker

Why is Pearson on your keep list?
 
On Ben Davies, I'm glad he is doing well at Fleetwood but lets not forget how poor he has been for us when he has actually played, and he's miles away from our first team. His last league appearance was when Campbell-Ryce destroyed him and he was hooked at half-time in August 2014.

As for Grimshaw, some Chesterfield fans are saying he's possibly the worst signing they've ever made. Yes, he's not played much in central midfield but there must be a reason for that, and that is that Grayson clearly deems him much worse than our other options. He couldn't even get a game in midfield at Rotherham when our other tacklers, Browne, Welsh and Pearson, were all out injured. I don't usually take much notice of opposition fan opinions but they are worryingly and unanimously bad comments about Grimshaw, at a lower level too.

I don't have an issue keeping these types of cheap, young squad fillers around as they aren't exactly a financial burden, but I just can't see either of those two ever making a big impact and establishing themselves in the first team squad, especially considering what we've already got.

As for May, I won't do yet another long paragraph about it but as I said yesterday, something has to give soon. If he isn't going to play then he needs to leave to get his career back on track.

Grimshaw and Davies have time on their side as they are both relatively young and if we keep judging them on how they have played for us then they might as well move on, both deserve a second chance whether that be this season or in seasons to come.

Davies as a perfect example is starting to develop you can see that from the reviews he has got from the Fleetwood fans, he might be 2-3 seasons away from being a first team regular with us but I'm sure when he is Grayson will make sure that the time is right.

Lets not judge all our players on the progression of Pearson, he is a freak of nature.
 
To go for me:

Lindegaard, Browne (Loan), Pringle, Beckford, Doyle.

Browning would be nice to have back but can see him being wanted at Everton. Sign Baps. Get McGeady. Get Mak. Sorted.
 
Sorry but there's more than a couple of questionable ones in there for me.

You think we should sell a 21-year-old left-sided CB/LB who has been crucial to a run of form that has seen a side move into the automatic promotion places the league below.

You think we should sell a 22-year-old who has captained Manchester United's U21 side and has not played a single league game in his preferred position for us, and when he has played in the league he has been out of position sometimes as far as RWB.

You think you've seen enough of May to know that he needs to be moved along - a player that has just spent over a year out injured and has barely touched a ball for us.

You think we should sell a LB who has been kept out by one of the best left-backs in the league and, despite some slow starts, really hasn't looked all that bad when called upon.

In response to all of the above, I'll refer you to your initial judgement of Ben Pearson: ie, fucking miles out.

On the money.
 
To go for me:

Lindegaard, Browne (Loan), Pringle, Beckford, Doyle.

Browning would be nice to have back but can see him being wanted at Everton. Sign Baps. Get McGeady. Get Mak. Sorted.

You forget to mention the crap non league donkey we have up front. Or is he okay to stay now?
 
Back
Top