RIP Fred.
He'll be remembered on Gentry Day and the minutes applause before the Hull game in December.
He'll be remembered on Gentry Day and the minutes applause before the Hull game in December.
Agree completely with what you say. Fred Else was my favourite player and I was was very upset when he had to leave for Blackburn .In my opinion he was a far better keeper than Alan Kelly .RIP MY HERONothing at all against Alan Kelly Snr, but if we were going to name a stand after a goalkeeper, and no offence meant to anyone on here of the Kelly family, it should have been Fred Else, not Alan Kelly in my opinion.
I understand the reasons for Alan Kelly Snr being given the honour, number of appearances for PNE, longevity of service, full international, but I believe Fred Else to be the superior goalie, and he played all his career when at his peak at the top of English football v the very best around at the time, whereas Alan Kelly did anything but that, spending most of his peak in division two.
One of my early heroes gone. Fred Else, one of the best English goalkeepers of his day.
Nothing at all against Alan Kelly Snr, but if we were going to name a stand after a goalkeeper, and no offence meant to anyone on here of the Kelly family, it should have been Fred Else, not Alan Kelly in my opinion.
I understand the reasons for Alan Kelly Snr being given the honour, number of appearances for PNE, longevity of service, full international, but I believe Fred Else to be the superior goalie, and he played all his career when at his peak at the top of English football v the very best around at the time, whereas Alan Kelly did anything but that, spending most of his peak in division two.
One of my early heroes gone. Fred Else, one of the best English goalkeepers of his day.
I have to agree with you about how good Fred was in comparison to the excellent Alan Kelly Snr. However, I think the decision to honour AK with the stand being named after him was probably due to the sheer longevity of his service. He was a loyal servant for many, many years in more than one capacity. Therefore, in my opinion, deserves his place in North End's history.
Still doesn't dilute how good Fred was.
Yes AK was a good servant to the club, no argument on that score, but am I the only one who has often wondered why it was that if he was such a good goalie, that unlike many of his fellow PNE players such as Peter Thompson, Gordon Milne, Kendall, Gemmill, Hannigan etc etc that no bigger club came knocking on our door for him?
Longevity is to be admired, but class and ability should also be recognised. I just think that Fred Else deserves similar recognition that Alan Kelly has been honoured with. Alan Kelly Snr played a handful of games at the top level, Fred Else lived there.
Yes AK was a good servant to the club, no argument on that score, but am I the only one who has often wondered why it was that if he was such a good goalie, that unlike many of his fellow PNE players such as Peter Thompson, Gordon Milne, Kendall, Gemmill, Hannigan etc etc that no bigger club came knocking on our door for him?
Longevity is to be admired, but class and ability should also be recognised. I just think that Fred Else deserves similar recognition that Alan Kelly has been honoured with. Alan Kelly Snr played a handful of games at the top level, Fred Else lived there.
That wasn't with the Brindle Brass Band by any chance Roy?I don't entirely agree with your summary of AK's ability. HOWEVER, I do agree that Fred Else isn't afforded the level of recognition he deserves. No argument from me on that one. After the one and only "Tommy", Fred was my next in line "hero" as a boy.
I used to squat on the cinders and had many a good view of his saves........fabulous goalie.
By-the-way, has the passing of Fred been acknowledged on Radio Lancs and/or SSN? I haven't heard or seen anything. Pretty poor if not mentioned yet.
That wasn't with the Brindle Brass Band by any chance Roy?
Unlikely to hear about it on SSN, they're too busy advertising what's on their other channels or showing tweets from Joey Barton, and really they're unlikely to report on the death of every former player, but it's been on the local radio yes.