Skip to main content

RIP Fred Else

RIP Fred Else

Whilst I appreciate and understand your reasoning, I had to smile that you used the name of Ernie Hannigan in the same sentence as such great players as Kendall Thompson and Gemmill, he only moved on to Coventry and wasn't a great IMO. Maybe Kel did get offers to move away, but stayed loyal to PNE, who knows maybe Kel junior will let us know one day. Yes RIP Fred

You can smile as much as you wish, I put Ernie Hannigan in that list because he deserved to be. I did not use the word 'great' either.
 
I don't entirely agree with your summary of AK's ability. HOWEVER, I do agree that Fred Else isn't afforded the level of recognition he deserves. No argument from me on that one. After the one and only "Tommy", Fred was my next in line "hero" as a boy.
I used to squat on the cinders and had many a good view of his saves........fabulous goalie.

Sorry if I didn't make myself totally clear roy. I actually didn't give a summary of AK's ability. If pushed, I would definitely put AK as the second best goalie that I have seen play for PNE. Fred Else of course being my first choice.

But facts are facts, and one can't compare a goalkeeper who played virtually his entire career (at his peak) at the highest level (Else), and who was at the same time recognised as one of the best at that level with another goalkeeper (AK) who spent virtually all of his career at the second and briefly the third (?).

AK was a reasonably reliable goalie (at the level he played at), although somewhat injury prone when faced by the more 'aggressive' opposing forwards. Who would your money have been on if AK had to face Alex Dawson for example? He was 100% North End, and a good guy also.

But not in Fred Else's class, that is all I am saying.
 
Sorry if I didn't make myself totally clear roy. I actually didn't give a summary of AK's ability. If pushed, I would definitely put AK as the second best goalie that I have seen play for PNE. Fred Else of course being my first choice.

But facts are facts, and one can't compare a goalkeeper who played virtually his entire career (at his peak) at the highest level (Else), and who was at the same time recognised as one of the best at that level with another goalkeeper (AK) who spent virtually all of his career at the second and briefly the third (?).

AK was a reasonably reliable goalie (at the level he played at), although somewhat injury prone when faced by the more 'aggressive' opposing forwards. Who would your money have been on if AK had to face Alex Dawson for example? He was 100% North End, and a good guy also.

But not in Fred Else's class, that is all I am saying.

I don't disagree, we share the same opinion on this. I was only trying to speculate as to why the club honoured AK in the way they did and yet, as you say, virtually ignore, or at least don't acknowledge the contribution of Else as much as perhaps they should. 'Tis all
 
I don't disagree, we share the same opinion on this. I was only trying to speculate as to why the club honoured AK in the way they did and yet, as you say, virtually ignore, or at least don't acknowledge the contribution of Else as much as perhaps they should. 'Tis all

The reason for honouring Alan Kelly was the combination of length and quality of service he gave the club - quality in terms of both performance, though like any keeper he made the odd mistake here and there, and character. Else may well have been a better keeper but I never saw him play for us so I can't say - but either way he was like Kelly obviously a fine man. For what it's worth the player from that era who at least matches Alan Kelly in terms of both the length and quality of his service to the club but who has not been accorded a similar honour is Alan Spavin.
 
The reason for honouring Alan Kelly was the combination of length and quality of service he gave the club - quality in terms of both performance, though like any keeper he made the odd mistake here and there, and character. Else may well have been a better keeper but I never saw him play for us so I can't say - but either way he was like Kelly obviously a fine man. For what it's worth the player from that era who at least matches Alan Kelly in terms of both the length and quality of his service to the club but who has not been accorded a similar honour is Alan Spavin.

ernest, if we are giving honours out for longevity of service I am thinking there maybe a couple of tea ladies who qualify.

Here is the bottom line ernest..........at a time when bigger clubs were lining up at the end of every season to buy one or other of some very good players that we had, not one club came in for AK or AS.

What does that tell you? And don't give me the 'loyalty' answer, even Finney would have left (twice) had he had the power so to do.

AK and AS were average to maybe slightly better than average division two players of their era. That is not meant as a criticism, just an honest opinion.
 
Back
Top