Skip to main content

Rudd v Stuckman

Rudd v Stuckman

norfolk white

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 10, 2004
Messages
16,899
I'm asking this as an excile and would like the views of those who have seen these two a number of time this season - If we do get Rudd for all of next season who do you think should be our number 1 goalie and what are each of their strengths and weaknesses?
 
I like both of these goalies but Rudd is head and shoulders ahead of Stucky in all aspects of his game.

If we could get Rudd on a loan for next season, that would be a great signing in my opinion and could be the difference between going up or not.

I would liek us to retain both keepers for next season but i think that Stuckers will leave and i think there will be teams in a higher division monitoring Rudd.
 
I'm asking this as an excile and would like the views of those who have seen these two a number of time this season - If we do get Rudd for all of next season who do you think should be our number 1 goalie and what are each of their strengths and weaknesses?

Rudd has all the good qualities of Stuckmann but has much better distribution. Rudd seems confident in all he does but Stuckmann sometimes lacks it.
Overall Stuckmann is good enough for us but I would give the gloves to Rudd all day long.
 
Rudd. Don't think I'd be too fussed if we just had Stuckmann next season though if the Rudd deal does fall through. Both are more than competent at this level.
 
Rudd all day long, don't get me wrong I love Stuckers. For his age Rudd is in another league technically, with time he will deffo play top half premier league football.
 
Rudd all day long, don't get me wrong I love Stuckers. For his age Rudd is in another league technically, with time he will deffo play top half premier league football.

Nail on head for me this. Rudd is a different class, Stuckmann helped keep us up last season and is a good keeper at this level, but Declan Rudd is just head and shoulders above anything I've seen in the past 5 years.
 
I have got to agree with all of the above. I think Stuckmann with a bit of confidence and a run in the side would be one of the better keepers in this league. However, I think Rudd is already of a quality which vastly outshines this division and it would be an absoloute coup to keep hold of him for next year.
 
Stuckmann's form has suffered this season due to all the needless changes that Westley made earlier on but we know from last season that he's a top keeper.

For me, I'd go for Rudd as at the moment he makes me, and prob the back 4, feel very comfortable.
 
Rudd all day long, don't get me wrong I love Stuckers. For his age Rudd is in another league technically, with time he will deffo play top half premier league football.

I'm not so sure that he will play top-half Premier League Football, as there are not that many English goalies doing so, as their place seems to be taken by the better ones from Europe and beyond. I seem to remember that a certain young local Prestonian, given his start by Moyes, and who became a fixture with PNE, as well as England U21s, was also destined for the "top" by many big names in football. It did not materialise, and it is true that Lonergan didn't have much competition to make him improve.
I expect Rudd to emulate, eventually, someone like Mark Bunn of Norwich: in for a bit, out for a bit longer, eventually getting a break of sorts.
Anyway Rudd is a better GK than Stuckmann; his handling, distribution, agility with crosses, speed of relaunch, and tactical awareness, as well as instinctive reactions, are all better than TS, and he is more athletic. Stuckmann however is now locally based, is getting on slightly age-wise, to contemplate restarting somewhere else. He has taken the decision to relocate here from Germany, and has settled his family in the area. So he'll probably be looking to carry on as he has been doing for the foreseeable future, whether that is as 1st/2nd choice.
 
Don't really rate Stuckmann. Would like to see Rudd back, and another keeper in as No2. For me everytime Stucks makes a good save, there's always an opponent to stick the ball away. His handling is not good enough, and his kicking is not that great. No room for sentiment because he was player of the year in his first season.
 
Stuckmann is a good keeper at this level who this season has suffered from mismanagement from Westley. I remember him winning us points on his own last season and without him we could well have been in a serious relegation battle. It is clear to see that Rudd is a class apart though and I would be very happy if both are still at Preston next year
 
Stuckers has suffered from Westley's reign and the chopping and changing between him and Simonsen. He seems more hesitant to come for things and overall a little bit more...nervous perhaps? His body language just doesn't exude that confidence we saw last year. However we all know how good a shot stopper he is and form is temporary etc.

As everyone has said, Rudd is just a class act. Would be fantastic to get him on a season long loan or (dreamland) a permanent deal.

If we could keep hold of both I'd be delighted.
 
I like Stuckmann a lot but Rudd could go on to be a Premier League goalie one day, he's faultless at this level.
 
Rudd all day long for me.

But as Tino said under Westley TS's all round game has suffered even though he was POTY last season, ditto his team mates. However i look forward to seeing a revamped TS next season pushing for that shirt, would be great to have 2 crackin' goalies pushing each other next season.
 
Stuckers has suffered from Westley's reign and the chopping and changing between him and Simonsen. He seems more hesitant to come for things and overall a little bit more...nervous perhaps? His body language just doesn't exude that confidence we saw last year. However we all know how good a shot stopper he is and form is temporary etc.

As everyone has said, Rudd is just a class act. Would be fantastic to get him on a season long loan or (dreamland) a permanent deal.

If we could keep hold of both I'd be delighted.

Sure but it seems at least as likely that we’ll have neither of them.

No doubt Larry is all over it though.
 
I'm not so sure that he will play top-half Premier League Football, as there are not that many English goalies doing so, as their place seems to be taken by the better ones from Europe and beyond. I seem to remember that a certain young local Prestonian, given his start by Moyes, and who became a fixture with PNE, as well as England U21s, was also destined for the "top" by many big names in football. It did not materialise, and it is true that Lonergan didn't have much competition to make him improve.

Lonergan was a good instinctive keeper, but had no anticipation of the flight of the ball from beyond 10 yards in front or to the side of him. Whereas Rudd is pretty much always Immaculately positioned to make a save/catch the ball from wherever it is struck. I have only seen him play a handful of times, but Declan Rudd is possibly the most impressive prospect of a Goalkeeper I have seen in a North End shirt.
 
Last edited:
Stuckmann has been very poor this season.

Could have done better for the Crawley goal and out of position for the one at Carlisle.

If we want to get promotion, we need a good goalie. I can't see him being anything other than a backup keeper at most going forward.
 
I like Stuckmann a lot but Rudd would be number 1 if he came back without a doubt.

Don't think he will though.
 
Back
Top