In my opinion Maxwell has been miles ahead of Rudd since he came back in to the team, bad game today with two errors made but Rudd would never come out in those scenarios instead opting to stay stuck to his line like glue. Shocking performances that led to Rudd being dropped if anything far too late, note Bolton and his inability to move when a corner ball comes into the box. Hopefully he has had some time to get his act together but I think Rudd will be sorely missed in the next game.
Rudd
Despite what happened today I'd give Maxwell the shirt back unless Rudd has a really great game. The mistakes Maxwell makes are much more frustrating to watch and downright stupid but Rudd gives away more goals overall, I'd rather have Maxwell being a moron every now and again than Rudd making a more understandable mistake that still gives away a goal every other game.
I'm expecting Rudd will be playing next game?PNEJack;n3399931 said:
Gally has the shirt now
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2015
- Messages
- 7,872
Mancunian White;n3399947 said:
100% career save percentage
Recall Hudson and give him his big big chance?
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2010
- Messages
- 10,942
Rudd is Massimo Taibi
Maxwell is Jens Lehmann
Maxwell is Jens Lehmann
JK;n3400131 said:
In the changing room photo ahead of yesterday’s game showed a picture of three GK kits which included Crowe’’s. Wasn’t he also involved in the pre-match warmup for the Rotherham game?
PS. For some reason, the apostrophes in this post have disappeared.
Last edited:
City’s keeper brought down Ings today and gave away a penalty,so he should be dropped for the next match! Keepers are the last line of defence and mistakes are always crucial. Personally I like watching the pro active Maxwell rather than the reactive Rudd but I’ll support whoever gets the shirt.