Skip to main content

Rudd

Rudd

Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
2,563
Location
New Deer
I have just seen the goal that we conceded on Saturday and I cannot understand why Rudd didn't catch the ball.
The initial shot was from way out and surely he had enough time to get behind the ball and not simply punch it to one of their forwards.
Gave away a penalty recently, doesn't 'boss the box'.
I know that he has had good games for us but has he lost his 'edge' recently?

On a different note, if anyone wants cheering up this Monday morning have a look at Blackpool's forum comments.
I've signed up just to suggest to them that if they want to watch a team on the up, come to Deepdale, only I'd like my face to remain unaltered.
 
I have just seen the goal that we conceded on Saturday and I cannot understand why Rudd didn't catch the ball.
The initial shot was from way out and surely he had enough time to get behind the ball and not simply punch it to one of their forwards.
Gave away a penalty recently, doesn't 'boss the box'.
I know that he has had good games for us but has he lost his 'edge' recently?

.

Are you forgetting the top class save he made in the final seconds.

Rudd has over 17 clean sheets this season and without question is becoming the best goal keeper I have seen in my lifetime as a PNE supporter.
 
Rudd does have a habit of punching unnecessarily occasionally but he's still learning his trade, most keepers only get first team football when they reach 25/26.

He's still the best keeper we've had since Nash and could play at the highest level one day.
 
It was a powerful shot and he did well to parry, but probably should of parried it over or out wide.

This - the first shot was a decent one and I didn't think anything of him not catching it at the time, though I thought he could maybe have done better with where he parried it to. That said the throw in and poor defending leading up to it were far more culpable.

To be fair to him he did also pull off a blindingly good save at the end to a swerving shot or else we'd have had another draw.
 
Rudd does have a habit of punching unnecessarily occasionally but he's still learning his trade, most keepers only get first team football when they reach 25/26.

He's still the best keeper we've had since Nash and could play at the highest level one day.

The main reason Rudd is here is to learn and you will always get this sort of error with anyone who is learning. That's not a criticism in any way, he's the best we've had since Kelly Snr in my opinion.
 
Are we going to have a keeper crisis in the summer? If Norwich dont stay up we won't be able to get him on loan again
 
The save he made at the end was world class. He saved us 2 points there.

Perhaps he could have parried the first half one to the side, but from where I was sat in the Kelly, the shot was hit with power and the ball was moving all over the place in the air.
 
Are you forgetting the top class save he made in the final seconds.

Rudd has over 17 clean sheets this season and without question is becoming the best goal keeper I have seen in my lifetime as a PNE supporter.

I sat on the Invincibles Saturday for a change and had 3 guys behind me constantly calling Rudd "rubbish " along with Gallagher (Block B). In the end I had a word, of course they scuttled out pretty sharp after the save at the end.
Lets be fair Rudd and Gally are class for league 1 and I for one am delighted to have them.
 
IF we go up TH might dip into his pocket and sign him. Providing we do it wit no sell on clause he would become a profit making transfer in the future.
 
The save he made at the end was world class. He saved us 2 points there.

Perhaps he could have parried the first half one to the side, but from where I was sat in the Kelly, the shot was hit with power and the ball was moving all over the place in the air.

Even on the replay you can see that shot was hit hard. As for the second shot that beat him - it was awkwardly placed just too far for him to stick his foot out.
 
I sat on the Invincibles Saturday for a change and had 3 guys behind me constantly calling Rudd "rubbish " along with Gallagher (Block B).

Probably descended from the idiots who used to barrack the great Nobby Lawton when he was struggling with the after-effects of injury. Every club has its small minority of fans who drag it down in some way. Ours has always been that of a few miserable idiots who target a particular player - Kevin Kilbane comes to mind as a more recent example - for constant whinging and denigration. Well done for telling them to shut up.
 
Last edited:
I have just seen the goal that we conceded on Saturday and I cannot understand why Rudd didn't catch the ball.
The initial shot was from way out and surely he had enough time to get behind the ball and not simply punch it to one of their forwards.
Gave away a penalty recently, doesn't 'boss the box'.
I know that he has had good games for us but has he lost his 'edge' recently?

On a different note, if anyone wants cheering up this Monday morning have a look at Blackpool's forum comments.
I've signed up just to suggest to them that if they want to watch a team on the up, come to Deepdale, only I'd like my face to remain unaltered.


Ive noticed you have had a few pops at Rudd lately one on Saturday before you even seen the goal apparently , its pretty obvious you have a problem with the lad but with 17 clean sheets this season you should probably drop the agenda and be bloody thankful we have such a talent at our disposal , its people like you who will blow his confidence as weve seen in the past with the likes of Kilbane , then will you be happy ?
 
Yes, he will make mistakes, as already pointed out he is young and here to learn.

That save at the end though was a worldy!

That it was Drunks, that it was!

FWIW, Rudd is a quality keeper in my opinion. He should have done better though with the initial shot which lead to the goal.
 
I sat on the Invincibles Saturday for a change and had 3 guys behind me constantly calling Rudd "rubbish " along with Gallagher (Block B). In the end I had a word, of course they scuttled out pretty sharp after the save at the end.
Lets be fair Rudd and Gally are class for league 1 and I for one am delighted to have them.

The chap next to me was shouting out to Grayson to bring Stuckman and substitute Rudd .
 
I think that Rudd is a talented young keeper who has tightened up the defence and just as importantly genuinely seems to want to play for us and likes it here.
 
I sat on the Invincibles Saturday for a change and had 3 guys behind me constantly calling Rudd "rubbish " along with Gallagher (Block B). In the end I had a word, of course they scuttled out pretty sharp after the save at the end.
Lets be fair Rudd and Gally are class for league 1 and I for one am delighted to have them.

Think I may have heard the same people.

After Rudd's save near the end one of them said something along the lines of "He's just doing his job".

I agree he should have done better with the first shot for their goal, but at least give credit where it is due.
 
Back
Top