Skip to main content

Rumors

Rumors

I think Garner should be given another season before he is usurped by anyone else, has chipped in with a lot of assists this season and has been adapting to the division as much as anyone else.

You could make excuses but the facts remain he has been playing in a team finding their feet and confidence in a new division without an on form strike partner.

A note on Doyle as well, on Saturday he set one up and won the penalty and has played some key parts in goals this season when he has been in and out of the team.

Goal vs Rotherham
Goal vs QPR
Goal vs Bolton
Goal vs Forest
Assist vs Brentford
Assist vs Ipswich
Assist vs MK Dons
Assist vs Bristol City

In a low scoring team he has definitely contributed, I would sign at the end of the season, good option from the bench and if Beckford is not injured. I think people judge him too much on his lack of hold up play when his movement in the box and sniffing out a goal is quite good.

People also forget Garner has played up top alone most of the season.
 
I think Garner should be given another season before he is usurped by anyone else, has chipped in with a lot of assists this season and has been adapting to the division as much as anyone else.

You could make excuses but the facts remain he has been playing in a team finding their feet and confidence in a new division without an on form strike partner.

A note on Doyle as well, on Saturday he set one up and won the penalty and has played some key parts in goals this season when he has been in and out of the team.

Goal vs Rotherham
Goal vs QPR
Goal vs Bolton
Goal vs Forest
Assist vs Brentford
Assist vs Ipswich
Assist vs MK Dons
Assist vs Bristol City

In a low scoring team he has definitely contributed, I would sign at the end of the season, good option from the bench and if Beckford is not injured. I think people judge him too much on his lack of hold up play when his movement in the box and sniffing out a goal is quite good.

Beckford will be great for next season, hopefully if he stays fit. I think Doyle would be a good shout, depending on how much Cardiff want for him. Forget anything more than £400k. I hope you're right and we can get these two scoring, but I think we need to sign someone like Nahki Wells to get scoring and push for the play offs. Re: his price, if we wanted him enough, we could get him. I think we may be a more attractive club to players of his quality this summer, due to our great season. If we had someone like him up front this season, a top 6 finish would not have been far away.
 
I agree to some extent that he has missed Beckford, however.....

You can make all the excuses in the world - luck, his strike partners, lack of creativity in the side, and so on. The list could be endless, but the fact remains that his goalscoring record at this level is not very good whatsoever, at all the clubs he's been at.

There is no doubt that he still has a role to play over the next few seasons, he offers a lot in terms of aerial challenges and he gets a few assists here and there.

However, PneFinney is correct in stating that "we can't rely on him to get the goals in the Championship", all the stats back that up including this season. "Not up to it" is probably a little strong, but all the stats confirm that we can't rely on him for goals at this level.

He still has a role to play, but if we are ever to kick on, I think we need a better first choice centre forward.

As for the Nahki Wells talk, I think some people need to be realistic. He is closing in on 20 goals for the season and has so far outscored Jordan Rhodes. Firstly I think Wells would be out of our price range and secondly I think Huddersfield will be desperate to hold on to him. I'm also unsure if he would leave Huddersfield for Preston.

Given our financial capalbilites in the market compared to other clubs in this league, I have no idea how we will solve this goalscoring problem as strikers are going for insane amounts of money now. Is Bradshaw really the answer ? Who else could we get ? It will be interesting to see.

Decent post. I do wonder if SG ever considers the foreign market in these scenarios? Or does he consider it too much of a gamble? Over the years some cheap gems have been found
 
Beckford will be great for next season, hopefully if he stays fit. I think Doyle would be a good shout, depending on how much Cardiff want for him. Forget anything more than £400k. I hope you're right and we can get these two scoring, but I think we need to sign someone like Nahki Wells to get scoring and push for the play offs. Re: his price, if we wanted him enough, we could get him. I think we may be a more attractive club to players of his quality this summer, due to our great season. If we had someone like him up front this season, a top 6 finish would not have been far away.

Huddersfield to PNE wouldn't be a big enough step up for Nakhi Wells, both in terms of club status and wages. Forget it
 
Arguably if we look set to start next season with (a fit again) Beckford, Garner and Hugill and have May set to return by around November then - even more if we were to sign Robinson - we might be best off with a loan signing of a more experienced striker until the New Year after which we can reassess the situation. The priorities for serious money outlay this summer are a goalkeeper and a mobile central defender.
 
Our problem this season has been a shortage of goals,so if we can improve that area then that would be my priority.
 
Back
Top