- Joined
- Jun 26, 2008
- Messages
- 3,889
Answer the question why didn't they beat us 4/5-0
Thats what most Rotherham fans are asking them selfs
Answer the question why didn't they beat us 4/5-0
Yeah, that's what the Huddersfield and Blackpool fans think as well after they failed in the play offs.
🙄
This season has already exceeded my expectations. If we fail to go up, I think there's still reason for optimism, with the key members of the squad already under contract for another season. Plus, I'm sure that Grayson has already identified players who will strengthen the squad and if we don't do it this time around, I feel quite confident we can avoid this lottery next season and gain automatic promotion.
Do you think we should sack him neal? Be honest.Exceeded expectations!? Where were you expecting to finish!?
After last season when we were in play-off form under Grayson, then with the summer signings, you thought we'd return to being midtable shite again did you!?
Do you think Mr Hemmings would be happy to piss about with the also-rans after splashing out on the likes of Davies x 2, Gallagher, Hume, and the APPARENTLY much sought after Humphrey?
As pessimistic as I am, even I EXPECTED to be challenging for promotion with this squad and Grayson's excellent league one record.
With Wolves pretty much nailed on for one spot from day one, I still think automatic could have been achieved with a more proactive, less cautious manager. Brentford away, who were wobbling at the time, was a shit or bust game, and our approach and total no-show that day, was for me, and I'm sure the majority of the 1600 travelling hordes that day, pretty inexcusable.
Think the only reason he got away with that one, was that most people were too pissed to care!
Good job Sheff U & Bristol City got off to such a shit start and MK Dons were a bit hit and miss, or we could have missed out altogether.
Most clubs in our league would give their right arm for the resources available to Grayson. Make on mistake, if we perform as we did on Saturday in the second leg, we'll be on the end of a hiding, and Mr H might not be as deliriously happy about another play-off failure as a lot of you mugs seem to be.
My take on him is, he's a a safe pair of hands, but with limitations. I would bet my last pound that he's probably the most thorough of all the other managers in this league, and very methodical, etc.
But you can over complicate things and worry too much about the opposition, which I belive is Grayson's achilles heel.
Someone like Ferguson Jnr. probaly does less than half the graft SG gets through but he's not afraid to take teams on. IMO, and obviously no way of proving this, but with the players at SGs disposal, I reckon DF could get better results, due to the generally poor standard of defending in this league.
I like the guy as a person, but I could say the same about Irvine, Brown x 2, and hell, even Westley made me smile on occasion!
I predict another meek surrender on Thursday, much like Bramall Lane in 2009. Then more play-off disappointment in 2014/15.
Mr H, on the other hand may get a tad impatient by then, and appoint someone who can inject some excitement back into PNE again? Next season will not be the cake-walk the deluded masses are predicting.
Que sera sera(we're not going Wembley, even though I've already bought my bastard train ticket, so I actually blame myself for our failure, not Simon, for tempting fate.)!
Exceeded expectations!?
Que sera sera(we're not going Wembley, even though I've already bought my bastard train ticket, so I actually blame myself for our failure, not Simon, for tempting fate.)!
Exceeded expectations!? Where were you expecting to finish!?
After last season when we were in play-off form under Grayson, then with the summer signings, you thought we'd return to being midtable shite again did you!?
Do you think Mr Hemmings would be happy to piss about with the also-rans after splashing out on the likes of Davies x 2, Gallagher, Hume, and the APPARENTLY much sought after Humphrey?
As pessimistic as I am, even I EXPECTED to be challenging for promotion with this squad and Grayson's excellent league one record.
With Wolves pretty much nailed on for one spot from day one, I still think automatic could have been achieved with a more proactive, less cautious manager. Brentford away, who were wobbling at the time, was a shit or bust game, and our approach and total no-show that day, was for me, and I'm sure the majority of the 1600 travelling hordes that day, pretty inexcusable.
Think the only reason he got away with that one, was that most people were too pissed to care!
Good job Sheff U & Bristol City got off to such a shit start and MK Dons were a bit hit and miss, or we could have missed out altogether.
Most clubs in our league would give their right arm for the resources available to Grayson. Make on mistake, if we perform as we did on Saturday in the second leg, we'll be on the end of a hiding, and Mr H might not be as deliriously happy about another play-off failure as a lot of you mugs seem to be.
My take on him is, he's a a safe pair of hands, but with limitations. I would bet my last pound that he's probably the most thorough of all the other managers in this league, and very methodical, etc.
But you can over complicate things and worry too much about the opposition, which I belive is Grayson's achilles heel.
Someone like Ferguson Jnr. probaly does less than half the graft SG gets through but he's not afraid to take teams on. IMO, and obviously no way of proving this, but with the players at SGs disposal, I reckon DF could get better results, due to the generally poor standard of defending in this league.
I like the guy as a person, but I could say the same about Irvine, Brown x 2, and hell, even Westley made me smile on occasion!
I predict another meek surrender on Thursday, much like Bramall Lane in 2009. Then more play-off disappointment in 2014/15.
Mr H, on the other hand may get a tad impatient by then, and appoint someone who can inject some excitement back into PNE again? Next season will not be the cake-walk the deluded masses are predicting.
Que sera sera(we're not going Wembley, even though I've already bought my bastard train ticket, so I actually blame myself for our failure, not Simon, for tempting fate.)!
I had to read all that to get to the important bit. We will lose on Thursday because you bought a train ticket. Wtf possessed you to tempt fate like that?
I think you'll find the whole post was important.
FYI, from what I'm told, should we achieve the impossible and scrape through on pens, it will be a logistical nightmare getting a train back from London to Preston on the 25th, and highly expensive.
Myself, and it seems 100s of others have bought Manc to London returns for a mere £19. I've squandered much larger amounts on more ridiculous things, but I must admit when purchasing, knew I was letting myself/PNE in for trouble.
Much apologies all round.
I think you'll find the whole post was important.
FYI, from what I'm told, should we achieve the impossible and scrape through on pens, it will be a logistical nightmare getting a train back from London to Preston on the 25th, and highly expensive.
Myself, and it seems 100s of others have bought Manc to London returns for a mere £19. I've squandered much larger amounts on more ridiculous things, but I must admit when purchasing, knew I was letting myself/PNE in for trouble.
Much apologies all round.
Excellent post Neil, exactly as i see it. Mind you you are now about to be a labled as a surrender monkey or towel thrower or some other insult for daring to question the success to resources ratio.
I don't advocate sacking Grayson, but i don't believe he should be immune from criticism either. He was dealt a bloody good hand, but there have been a few too many "bad days at the office". He can't afford another one.
Do you think we should sack him neal? Be honest.
I always read your posts with great interests and certainly take on board performances like the one at Brentford. I thnk the highlighted bit is an over reaction, in fairness. It would have taken something epic for 2 clubs to have overtaken the points total that we actually made.
No I wouldn't sack him right now. He has earnt his right to be given a fair crack, due to the way he has settled us down, organised us, got everyone singing from the same hymn sheet, galvanised the players, etc. Clearly all brilliant qualities.
BUT, and it's only my opinion, he is not immune from criticism, and he does have his limitations and for my money at least, can be way too cautious.
Some of the joke defending in this league should have been exploited to a greater extent from our wealth of strikers. The way we have allowed teams back into games on aregular basis when dominating, frustrates the hell out of me.
Plus sloppy defending has become an issue when previously, even last season(under SG) we had looked rock solid.
I fear, he still, even after 47 games, has no idea what his best team is, and frankly neither do I.
Call me old fashioned, but I'd prefer an approach of play your best XI, let them grow and improve as a team. Let the oppo, usually not up to much in Div 3, worry about us, and see where that takes us?
Not done any checks but I guess the other teams in the top 6, did much less chopping and changing than Mr Grayson? His horses for courses style, shows the opposition you're worried about them, and offers them too much respect.
The majority on here seem to be totally anti-Irvine, but for me there are many similarities.
Excitement at PNE games is, like it or not, a very rare thing. However after the madness of King Graham, SG was probably the right appointment, to steady the ship.
I'm still behind the guy, and at the moment we're still in with a chance, but it would take a top performance on Thursday to see us through. After we have been found wanting on the big occasion, so many times this season and in the past, why does so many think it will be any different this time?
Would love to be proven wrong, but no point getting your hopes up with PNE, as they have a nasty habit of kicking you in the balls when it really matters. Don't know how anybody can dispute that if they've been following us for any length of time?
Our policy of hiring a manager somewhat quickly and with what appeared to be very little ong term consideration had the amazing result of dumping us into the third division of which I feel we would have languished for many a season had Mr Grayson not joined us.
Yes he is no messiah but when you consider our end of season placing, our general performances over the season, our signings by the main and finally the most important to me which is the positive feeling around the club then I for one will pin my colours to the Grayson mast !
Idiot.
A view I more or less concur with. A little over 12 months ago we were in total turmoil after simply the worst managerial appointment since probably Docherty. Mr Grayson took over we have steadied the ship, the fans are (almost) as one and we finally look to be moving forward. If we don't go up, I'm pretty sure he will use what he has learned about his players to move us forward again next season.
I for one would have taken this at the start of the season.
You state you are behind Grayson but with due respect if you read back your feelings come over very strongly that you are in truth not behind him at all.
Or maybe that's my interpretation ?