Skip to main content

Sacking Grayson will be a HUGE mistake

Sacking Grayson will be a HUGE mistake

Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
639
Location
Bamber Bridge
I can understand everyone's current frustrations at the moment.

This man has brought a massive amount of stability to the club.
It may sound ridiculous but the difference between Grayson and previous sacked PNE managers is that we know Grayson has already proved he's a good manager at PNE judging from the remainder of season 12/13 when he took over and all of the season 13/14 so this does show he can do it on top of already promoting 3 clubs out of this league!

Give the guy a chance and all the support he needs to the end the season at least but I really do think this guy is in the job long term whether we gret promoted this season or not.

Yes RIGHT NOW things do need to change results wise but this should return if the encouragement is there throughout this current poor run of form. His tactics may be negative at times but currently he is by far the best manager we could have right now.

Today I got very frustrated with the amount of bottle and fight the team lacked but I do believe Grayson is aware of this and will look to try and change it.

Feel free to dissagree.
 
This man has brought a massive amount of stability to the club. . . . currently he is by far the best manager we could have right now.

Today I got very frustrated with the amount of bottle and fight the team lacked but I do believe Grayson is aware of this and will look to try and change it.

Things are looking far from stable, we're in poor shape.
He's certainly not the best manager we could have, agree there's a lot worse out there and any change is a risk but there comes a point you have to take that risk.
 
Completely daft to talk of a sacking now, automatic to be honest is looking very difficult to achieve to say the least although next 6 matches might change that. Play offs are looking good and I know that fills everyone with dread but you never know, this hoodoo can't go on forever.

If by the end of May were still going to be in L1 next season then I think it would be a time to thank Simon for his efforts and move on with someone else. That also might be the time to question the decision makers of the club because the Hemming/Ridsdale era will not be remembered fondly by supporters that's for sure.
 
I can understand everyone's current frustrations at the moment.

This man has brought a massive amount of stability to the club.
It may sound ridiculous but the difference between Grayson and previous sacked PNE managers is that we know Grayson has already proved he's a good manager at PNE judging from the remainder of season 12/13 when he took over and all of the season 13/14 so this does show he can do it on top of already promoting 3 clubs out of this league!

Give the guy a chance and all the support he needs to the end the season at least but I really do think this guy is in the job long term whether we gret promoted this season or not.

Yes RIGHT NOW things do need to change results wise but this should return if the encouragement is there throughout this current poor run of form. His tactics may be negative at times but currently he is by far the best manager we could have right now.

Today I got very frustrated with the amount of bottle and fight the team lacked but I do believe Grayson is aware of this and will look to try and change it.

Feel free to dissagree.

This. While i understand abd share peoples frustrations at moment, SGs record since he got here shows what a good manager he is, even if you want tonignore his success elsewhre.
True, his tactics are overly negative and his signings, esp this season, have been very disappointing, but I firmly believe he knows whst hes doing, sees the same probs as us and will sort it out.
I dont see how getting rid of a successful and experienced manager andd giving the job to, for example, inexperienced and unproven Dreyer will change things for the better.
frankly, our squads not good enough to go straight up. SG must take a lot of the blame for that, but look where we are desoite the obvious mistakes he's made 🙂
Have faith and look again at end of the season.
 
This. While i understand abd share peoples frustrations at moment, SGs record since he got here shows what a good manager he is, even if you want tonignore his success elsewhre.
True, his tactics are overly negative and his signings, esp this season, have been very disappointing, but I firmly believe he knows whst hes doing, sees the same probs as us and will sort it out.
I dont see how getting rid of a successful and experienced manager andd giving the job to, for example, inexperienced and unproven Dreyer will change things for the better.
frankly, our squads not good enough to go straight up. SG must take a lot of the blame for that, but look where we are desoite the obvious mistakes he's made 🙂
Have faith and look again at end of the season.

This post is contradictory, you say he is a good manager and then catalogue all the mistakes he has made.
 
Sacking Grayson will be a HUGE mistake

Completely daft to talk of a sacking now, automatic to be honest is looking very difficult to achieve to say the least although next 6 matches might change that. Play offs are looking good and I know that fills everyone with dread but you never know, this hoodoo can't go on forever.

If by the end of May were still going to be in L1 next season then I think it would be a time to thank Simon for his efforts and move on with someone else. That also might be the time to question the decision makers of the club because the Hemming/Ridsdale era will not be remembered fondly by supporters that's for sure.

The playoffs aren't looking good to be honest and at the beginning of Feb I can pretty much tell you we will be in L1 next season.

The club is in a stronger position than before Ridsdale arrived.
 
I just don't buy into this "the club is in better shape" bollocks, anyone could have come in after Magic and done a better job, ffs he was/is a rugby league person (was going to say man and forgot). Ridsdale has sacked and hired so many players and managers in such a short space of time, crowds are dwindling and still we see ourselves not being able to beat piss poor opposition.

TH has shuffled debt from one pocket to another and has had to install Kay (his own man as ceo) to put a professional front to the club yet Ridsdale still lords it over all at Deepdale, his not being able to speak on any footy related matters left Westley hung out to dry and the same is happening to Grayson, we hear nothing from those in charge, we are left wondering just wtf is happening on the pitch, changes every bloody week, no settled team, no obvious plan with dubious selections, tactics and a seeming reluctance to play anything bar 451, Grayson has to be responsible for this as nobody else is putting their hands up.
 
I just don't buy into this "the club is in better shape" bollocks, anyone could have come in after Magic and done a better job, ffs he was/is a rugby league person (was going to say man and forgot). Ridsdale has sacked and hired so many players and managers in such a short space of time, crowds are dwindling and still we see ourselves not being able to beat piss poor opposition.

TH has shuffled debt from one pocket to another and has had to install Kay (his own man as ceo) to put a professional front to the club yet Ridsdale still lords it over all at Deepdale, his not being able to speak on any footy related matters left Westley hung out to dry and the same is happening to Grayson, we hear nothing from those in charge, we are left wondering just wtf is happening on the pitch, changes every bloody week, no settled team, no obvious plan with dubious selections, tactics and a seeming reluctance to play anything bar 451, Grayson has to be responsible for this as nobody else is putting their hands up.

But the differance is many fans see it with an open view and seen the club in really hard times. You are blinkered and bitter about your losing your £4.50 worth of shares and have an anti PR and TH agenda that you like to thrust upon everyone. Your a Jonny come lately PNE fan who came on board when we were in the Championship so have a level of expectation. Your money is as welcome as anyone and you have a lifestyle that means you can go home and away when many can't but your anti PR and TH agenda is tedious.....

Yes it wasn't hard to follow a rugby league chairman but from the direction the club was heading to where it is stability wise now is an improvement that works in the same timeframes as Ridsdales appointment. Yes he has made mistakes along the way but name me a chairman that hadn't....

Why hasn't Kay come out and said anything?

I know and I think half the board know what your reply will be in terms of it all. We've heard the negative anti establishment drivel before. 'Tax cheat' this 'libor' that....
 
I agree that I don't want to go through another sacking, another average tenure under the assistant manager, another manager coming in and another 'season of transition'. It's another two years in league one for me.

However, if he doesn't drop this 451 bollocks then he has got to go. Simple as.
 
Different take on things.
Having understood Westley previous description of the set up he inherited as a holiday camp where the players were swanning around in the robes and slippers all day, I appreciate the work he did to create what he called a "front foot" mentality on the pitch and a more humble set of players off the pitch.
Westley left a very average squad that was infused with a stick together spirit. It needed an influx of talent and skill, and for some players to step up to the plate and improve.
In Garner and Gallagher North End had an injection of inspiration that blended well with the tough spirit that Simon Grayson inherited.
The threat, as I saw it, to this high calibre team spirit, was always going to be the new influx of players. Significantly, the influx of more than 3 or 4 new players in a short time, and how these players affect the team dynamic. Clearly, with the injury to Garner and the return of Robinson to his preferred substitute's bench, has reduced the goal tally as expected. And replacements have not obliged with goals.
The Walsall home match saw the complete dissolving of the team in one 90 minute period. Gallagher appeared completely exasperated by the 70th minute, having provided at least 8 killer crosses or passes, to see no end product from his strikers.
Defensive errors are always going to happen and be highlighted, but the real criticism should be aimed at the strikers.
However, A converse angle on things may view the cause of the drop in morale and team spirit as the fault, not of the new players, but perhaps the core of former Westley players possibly forming a mini gang within the squad that feels threatened by the new faces.
If this is the case, then it should be emphasised that while any mini player gangs (regularly seen in the Black Bull) that have established themselves are probably a good thing in principle, if they are unable to absorb new blood then a wedge can be driven into the squad.
The introduction of Reid, Beckford, and Blake may have dissolved that gang mentality within the squad, making for a team with a split personality, where half go out socially in midweek, and the new people are not involved. A divisive situation, rather than a solid coherence from back to front as was the case for the first 18 matches.
Grayson, and the squad, need time to readjust to the heavy traffic of recent weeks. Nobody in their right mind would even consider sacking Grayson at this point. But he has work to do if he is to reset the squad morale out of this depression.
Kyel Reid shows enough promise at this level. Beckford gets into great positions and has good pace to feed off Kevin Davies. Sam Johnstone has a good pedigree. Let's hope Grayson can blend his new squad quickly, albeit a strange time of the year to completely revamp your squad.
 
Last edited:
So we are here again the Battle of Faiths.

NO Faith <<< ----
11981310.jpg
---->>> Blind Faith​

I just going to sit on the fence, but if he doesn't sort out the striker situation and stop fucking defending the 2-nil downs then I will get off and join the No Faith. I have no faith in the forwards in the team.
 
So we are here again the Battle of Faiths.

NO Faith <<< ----
11981310.jpg
---->>> Blind Faith​

I just going to sit on the fence, but if he doesn't sort out the striker situation and stop fucking defending the 2-nil downs then I will get off and join the No Faith. I have no faith in the forwards in the team.

I actually do, just not as lone strikers. Pair Ebanks or Beckford with Davies and throw the kitchen sink at the opposition for twenty minutes and we'd kill teams
 
We're fucking shite and getting worse every week.

Bollocks to our false league position, we look like a relegation side and will drop out of the play-offs at this rate.
 
Different take on things.
Having understood Westley previous description of the set up he inherited as a holiday camp where the players were swanning around in the robes and slippers all day, I appreciate the work he did to create what he called a "front foot" mentality on the pitch and a more humble set of players off the pitch.
Westley left a very average squad that was infused with a stick together spirit. It needed an influx of talent and skill, and for some players to step up to the plate and improve.
In Garner and Gallagher North End had an injection of inspiration that blended well with the tough spirit that Simon Grayson inherited.
The threat, as I saw it, to this high calibre team spirit, was always going to be the new influx of players. Significantly, the influx of more than 3 or 4 new players in a short time, and how these players affect the team dynamic. Clearly, with the injury to Garner and the return of Robinson to his preferred substitute's bench, has reduced the goal tally as expected. And replacements have not obliged with goals.
The Walsall home match saw the complete dissolving of the team in one 90 minute period. Gallagher appeared completely exasperated by the 70th minute, having provided at least 8 killer crosses or passes, to see no end product from his strikers.
Defensive errors are always going to happen and be highlighted, but the real criticism should be aimed at the strikers.
However, A converse angle on things may view the cause of the drop in morale and team spirit as the fault, not of the new players, but perhaps the core of former Westley players possibly forming a mini gang within the squad that feels threatened by the new faces.
If this is the case, then it should be emphasised that while any mini player gangs (regularly seen in the Black Bull) that have established themselves are probably a good thing in principle, if they are unable to absorb new blood then a wedge can be driven into the squad.
The introduction of Reid, Beckford, and Blake may have dissolved that gang mentality within the squad, making for a team with a split personality, where half go out socially in midweek, and the new people are not involved. A divisive situation, rather than a solid coherence from back to front as was the case for the first 18 matches.
Grayson, and the squad, need time to readjust to the heavy traffic of recent weeks. Nobody in their right mind would even consider sacking Grayson at this point. But he has work to do if he is to reset the squad morale out of this depression.
Kyel Reid shows enough promise at this level. Beckford gets into great positions and has good pace to feed off Kevin Davies. Sam Johnstone has a good pedigree. Let's hope Grayson can blend his new squad quickly, albeit a strange time of the year to completely revamp your squad.

Very interesting, what I take from this is that Grayson has realised that the second time round the squad he inherited is not good enough for automatic promotion, therefore he has started setting the stones in place for next season if promotion is not achieved.

The young signings of Johnstone and Johnson suggest this may be the case, as well the constant inclusion of Brownhill.

Could be an explanation to why some contracts have not been renewed.
 
Its a confusing time to be a PNE fan. Should Grayson go or not? Immediately after another tepid defeat the answer seems obvious. Tactically we seem to be outfought on a regular basis and we don't dominate teams. The constant squad rotation smacks of someone who has lost the plot.

But once the dust settles a day after a defeat, I have to admit I still come back to the thought that Grayson should be given the chance to make amends. His win ratio rate at PNE has been solid even though the 1 in 9 run of form (soon to be 1 in 10 no doubt) we are enduring has been totally woeful.

We need approx 28 pts from the remaining 19 league games to secure a play off berth. An average of 1.5 pts a game. If we manage 9 wins we can afford to draw 1 and lose 9. This is not a herculean task. I think Grayson could grind out those results. Obviously if this poor run continues (say we dont win any of our next 5 games) that task becomes much harder and Grayson might not survive the chop.

But with Garners return from injury coming very soon combined with the acquisition of Johnson I truly believe we will have a really cutting edge to our play once more. Obviously there is a concern Joe won't come back 100% but those two players can create something from nothing and that's what we have been missing.

In my view Grayson just needs to settle on a team selection. We need a first choice back four. The full back rotation is not working. Its also a shame we didn't capture someone like Ben Pearson in the transfer window. I think we are really lacking a combative box to box midfielder. None of our current central midfielders seem to meld very well together. Will we sign someone tomorrow? It doesnt seem so sadly.

Out wide Humphrey can no longer be an automatic first choice - his form has been appalling of late. And when we need to win games we can't resort to lumping balls to SKD. I think once Garner returns we will have two brand new attacking options: a) team him up with Beckford who I think could be a real livewire combination b) return to the 451 formation that got us early season success but with Johnson in the hole behind Garner. These two set-ups could revolutionise our success up front.

A fundamental change which needs to happen is our passing has to become more composed. We need to frustrate teams, be patient and unlock defences. Our play has become rushed and lacks control. Far too often our attacks consist of 4 or 5 passes/punts before we lose possession. This can not continue and I think if Grayson does not instil a renewed belief in this team we will have no chance in the playoffs.

To sum up I think Grayson deserves the chance to see out the season (I realise thats not a very popular view right now). If it all ends in failure then I think he should be potted in May. And allow someone to come in, shake up the squad, bring in some new players and get a full pre-season with the squad.

We have had some dogturd managers of late (Brown, Fergie, Westley) and I don't believe Grayson deserves to be branded with that tag just yet. Fans are frustrated because automatic promotion seems very much out of reach. But when Garner is named on the bench in a few weeks I think there may well be a renewed optimism both in the squad and in the stands. Hopefully on this forum too!
 
The team is what it is. It's been built in the mould of Grayson's creation. It's not good enough. It's of no use blaming this, that and t'other. It's his team. They're awful. He should go now. Give the job to Dreyer till the end of the season and then take stock.
 
Disagree

Disagree

I can't agree with the OP. I'm of the opinion that when I go to a football match I want to be entertained. I don't get that at PNE matches. It is total non football, very little skill, poor ball control, little or no craft, tedious, apathetic build up, no leadership on the pitch. It goes on and on and on. Now this guy has not been here for a few months; he's been here 2 years this month. Yes the Garner injury has had a big effect on our striking capabilities but he's had enough time to sort this out. I'll breath a big sigh of relief when he's gone to be honest rather than the euphoria of GW's departure.

The teams performances on the pitch is a reflection of the manager IMHO and that says everything to me. Boring, negative with little or no passion particularly when the going gets tough. He should do the honorable thing and admit he's totally devoid of ideas and I don't think the players have any belief in him or themselves.

Unless there is a change and it must happen now then I can't see us even making the play offs this season.

Resign!
 
The team is what it is. It's been built in the mould of Grayson's creation. It's not good enough. It's of no use blaming this, that and t'other. It's his team. They're awful. He should go now. Give the job to Dreyer till the end of the season and then take stock.

Kind of agree when you say the team is awful. At least half of yesterday's starting 11 aren't good enough and had no fight, grip or bottle. At the end of the game (loosing to bottom of the league!) a few of us started singing 'your not fit to wear the shirt' then a guy in front turned round and had a go giving personal abuse to myself bearing in mind he already slagged the team off during the game, especially Josh Brownhill. Was quite entertaining watching an individual in the crowd get his knickers in a twist.

If some fans don't agree to what's being sung, they should just put up and keep quiet. Some Preston fans are so contradicting and delusional at times.

The manager is going no-where, people need to accept this. It's time for everyone to give the players a rocket.
 
Back
Top