Skip to main content

Safe Standing

Safe Standing

If that was the case I doubt any stadium or stand built in last 5 years would have been built with permanent seating. Unless Bristol City are the only ones anywhere with this knowledge? Unlikely.

Its a multi-purpose stadium and benefits that way. It wont be the football fans benefiting any time soon.

Most clubs know about it, because it's what the majority of fans want. Bristol City are currently only on a pilot scheme and are waiting, like most clubs interested, for new legislation to be passed. Once this has been done the devolpment of Ashton Gate will ensue. There haven't been many major stands built in the past couple of years, and even if there has, I don't think it'd be too costly to install a standing section. After all the majoity of the clubs interested in safe standing are in either the Championship or Premier League. Inevitably it will be benefitting football fans in the near future, it's already being gradually introduced.
 
Last edited:
Personally I'm in favour of all seated stadiums. You can stand up enough if you want to as is.

Why on earth would be need to go back to olden days? No need whatsoever.

You can still shout and sing from a seated position.

The mind boggles.

Merely a matter of personal opinion. I prefer standing, you prefer sitting. I don't have a problem with that. I just think that the option to stand should be available for the people who wish to do so. Safe standing certainty wouldn't see a resurgence of the dark days when standing was dangerous, hence the term "safe". Each person has an allocated standing area; which avoids overcrowding and sudden surges forward. Correct me if I am wrong, but I don't see many people singing sat down in their seat for the majority of the 90 minutes at Deepdale on a Saturday afternoon.
 
Personally I'm in favour of all seated stadiums. You can stand up enough if you want to as is.

Why on earth would be need to go back to olden days? No need whatsoever.

You can still shout and sing from a seated position.

The mind boggles.

My mind boggles that you can make a comment like that.

It's a matter of choice.

Why should it bother you if some people want to stand? 😕
 
I've been to european matches with safe standing and I do agree it does add to the atmosphere. When you can see a whole stand buzzing with activity and passion it has a knock on effect with on the other stands and what's happening on the field. I would welcome its arrival to Preston. The safety issues of yesteryear have been solved as far as i'm concerned.

If safe standing was to come to Deepdale, it would than be the discussion of which stand to convert. Historically, standing areas are the cheapest tickets and also house the younger or more vocal supporters. So if we were to follow this trend it would be the AKTE that would be converted. It's been mentioned before on an older thread that the AKTE's steepness might not make it suitable for safe standing, however there are much steeper stands in the Europe that successfully achieved standing areas without having to modify the stand's foundations.

I would miss the AK mural and that would be a reason to not modify the Kelly, so making the Invincibles a standing area would be the second option. Using the old Invincible seats could possibly be the solution to replacing the seats at the bottom of the Kop and Town End.

Interesting one.
 
Move the mural further downwards and make the last 10 rows of the AKTE Safe Standing then if it's to be done in the future.

This is probably the answer.
 
I've been to european matches with safe standing and I do agree it does add to the atmosphere. When you can see a whole stand buzzing with activity and passion it has a knock on effect with on the other stands and what's happening on the field. I would welcome its arrival to Preston. The safety issues of yesteryear have been solved as far as i'm concerned.

If safe standing was to come to Deepdale, it would than be the discussion of which stand to convert. Historically, standing areas are the cheapest tickets and also house the younger or more vocal supporters. So if we were to follow this trend it would be the AKTE that would be converted. It's been mentioned before on an older thread that the AKTE's steepness might not make it suitable for safe standing, however there are much steeper stands in the Europe that successfully achieved standing areas without having to modify the stand's foundations.

I would miss the AK mural and that would be a reason to not modify the Kelly, so making the Invincibles a standing area would be the second option. Using the old Invincible seats could possibly be the solution to replacing the seats at the bottom of the Kop and Town End.

Interesting one.

It is a very interesting one. As you say, teams like Dortmund who have safe standing have an electric atmosphere, which makes the game and whole experience much better. Tickets would be cheaper meaning more fans and a dramatically enhanced atmosphere.

The AKTE would probably be the best option. Perhaps the mural could be brought further down to allow standing in the top half/quarter?
 
I would miss the AK mural and that would be a reason to not modify the Kelly, so making the Invincibles a standing area would be the second option. Using the old Invincible seats could possibly be the solution to replacing the seats at the bottom of the Kop and Town End.

Interesting one.

Like this idea. The seat situation needs sorting soon. I know they're hardly in use but it looks naff and probably cost us a fair bit of money for the United game. Could have sold another 2000 tickets.
 
Move the mural further downwards and make the last 10 rows of the AKTE Safe Standing then if it's to be done in the future.

This is probably the answer.


I thought this then thought a mural is only visible when the seats are empty so take all the seats off the town end paint the stone blue and paint the mural back in , it would raise the capacity of the town end to maybe 10,000 and bring the capacity of the ground up to about 28,000 .

Its all about choice as has been said and would still give home fans around 12,000 seats and it would bring the ground to life again , but i think fans would have to steward themselves to a degree to try to prevent surging . It wasn't standing that was a problem initially it was fans invading each others ends and lets be honest those fucking fences cost lives as when ends became over crowded the fans were trapped like animals as the government of the time saw us .

If were even going to consider it at some point might as well do it right and use the whole stand , it would also save restricted viewing for some .
 
If the seats at the front of the stands are prone to weather damage, surely that's where any future standing areas should be? On the front rows?
 
Personally I'm in favour of all seated stadiums. You can stand up enough if you want to as is.

Why on earth would be need to go back to olden days? No need whatsoever.

You can still shout and sing from a seated position.

The mind boggles.

jiFfM.jpg
 
Football has changed
The days of the terrace and rose tinted image of the stereotypical fan are a thing of the past
Today a family of grandad, mum and child are much more of the demographic- would they want to stand?
The concept of a particular area segregated for standing could work but then you could be accused of denying the sitters the opportunity to view the game from that particular area and of course the converse view for the standers?

Not all football fans attend as families. In any case, it's not, as Joan would put it, rocket science to create areas where people can sit and areas where they can stand. Choice. Which at the moment, people don't have.
 
Most clubs know about it, because it's what the majority of fans want. Bristol City are currently only on a pilot scheme and are waiting, like most clubs interested, for new legislation to be passed. Once this has been done the devolpment of Ashton Gate will ensue. There haven't been many major stands built in the past couple of years, and even if there has, I don't think it'd be too costly to install a standing section. After all the majoity of the clubs interested in safe standing are in either the Championship or Premier League. Inevitably it will be benefitting football fans in the near future, it's already being gradually introduced.

I think you misunderstood mate. ALL clubs know about it - safe standing options etc. there isn't a club in the world that doesn't. You made the point that Bristol City wouldn't be doing this if they didn't think legislation would change soon. I was saying that either they are they only ones that know it will change soon or of course this argument doesn't stand up. Which it doesn't.

At best (football wise) its a hopeful punt - legislation may eventually come in or they spiral down the leagues and use it. At worst they still get to use it for their Rugby games and any other use they can get out of it. Which PNE can't.

I am all for safe standing. I really am. I'm just being pragmatic. I can't see it happening. It certainly doesn't suit the infrastructure of our stands including the steep banking.

Dortmund have one stand where they store all the seating under the stand (thousands and thousands of rail seats) then bring them out when needed. North End couldn't perform that sort of operation - not viable financially for one bet. They'd have the ticket office staff out there doing it. The other type of fold up seating to create the standing space may work better and result in the murals staying in place? Maybe. Possibly. 😱/

One solution could be to keep the middle sections as seating, therefore keeping the faces of our legends and also providing unobstructed view for those sitting. Either side is terracing where view is also unobstructed as people are stood.

It would look awful when empty unless painted every where possibly.

Anyway, there you go.
 
Not all football fans attend as families. In any case, it's not, as Joan would put it, rocket science to create areas where people can sit and areas where they can stand. Choice. Which at the moment, people don't have.

And that's because the rules state if you want to be in the Championship or the Premier League then you need seats. There's just no way that the club will spend money on removing perfectly good seats to replace them with rail seats, which are actually quite expensive.

I'd actually say in 10 years time the stadium will look exactly as it does now (though hopefully with the extra IP boxes added, and we know how they'll get done.... 🙂)
 
And that's because the rules state if you want to be in the Championship or the Premier League then you need seats. There's just no way that the club will spend money on removing perfectly good seats to replace them with rail seats, which are actually quite expensive.

I'd actually say in 10 years time the stadium will look exactly as it does now (though hopefully with the extra IP boxes added, and we know how they'll get done.... 🙂)

Fuck the rules. 😉

Once upon a time, the powers were going decree a rule that would require us all to carry id cards to go to a football ground.
 
These rules were brought in by the Thatcher govt, I need say no more!


How do we make these animals behave ? turn football grounds into theaters and fence the bastards in if they die behind the fences so fucking what ! and you know what they did . Now all this time later when i see grounds with no option to stand i realize just how controlled we are and how we came to just accept being treat that way .

Its time to change again and no longer accept being treat like 2nd class citizens , football was a working class sport and 1 day it will be again just as soon as all the fans across the country unite and let any govt know that we have enough members in our sport to make or break the election of any govt because as well as animals and second class citizens were voters .
 
How do we make these animals behave ? turn football grounds into theaters and fence the bastards in if they die behind the fences so fucking what ! and you know what they did . Now all this time later when i see grounds with no option to stand i realize just how controlled we are and how we came to just accept being treat that way .

Its time to change again and no longer accept being treat like 2nd class citizens , football was a working class sport and 1 day it will be again just as soon as all the fans across the country unite and let any govt know that we have enough members in our sport to make or break the election of any govt because as well as animals and second class citizens were voters .

A treatise for wider society there Dirk, not just footy.
 
I think you misunderstood mate. ALL clubs know about it - safe standing options etc. there isn't a club in the world that doesn't. You made the point that Bristol City wouldn't be doing this if they didn't think legislation would change soon. I was saying that either they are they only ones that know it will change soon or of course this argument doesn't stand up. Which it doesn't.

At best (football wise) its a hopeful punt - legislation may eventually come in or they spiral down the leagues and use it. At worst they still get to use it for their Rugby games and any other use they can get out of it. Which PNE can't.

I am all for safe standing. I really am. I'm just being pragmatic. I can't see it happening. It certainly doesn't suit the infrastructure of our stands including the steep banking.

Dortmund have one stand where they store all the seating under the stand (thousands and thousands of rail seats) then bring them out when needed. North End couldn't perform that sort of operation - not viable financially for one bet. They'd have the ticket office staff out there doing it. The other type of fold up seating to create the standing space may work better and result in the murals staying in place? Maybe. Possibly. 😱/

One solution could be to keep the middle sections as seating, therefore keeping the faces of our legends and also providing unobstructed view for those sitting. Either side is terracing where view is also unobstructed as people are stood.

It would look awful when empty unless painted every where possibly.

Anyway, there you go.

Agree the steps are too narrow , the stands themselves are too steep ; that's whole idea , its 's so the seated spectators get a better view instead of players looking like matchstick men , if there was pushing and shoving , there'd be a likelihood of people falling , getting crushed and worse - once a purpose built seated stand has been built you can't go back to Terraces .

Also it was probably cheaper to knock those old terraces down which had probably seen better days and build a new stand than take the crush barriers out and put seats on the terrace steps ?

Then there are issues as to how you get people in and out , the entrances / exits would have to be wider .
 
A Choice........ End of argument for me.

The key thing for me is whether or not there really is a demand for standing. Sure, some fans might "prefer" the choice, but they'll still attend games anyway.

The question must be - will having a standing area attract new supporters? I imagine those tickets would need to be significantly cheaper to attract new people.

So while I'm all for choice usually, unless it can be proved it will add any on the gate then I'd rather the football club invested the money elsewhere. Liberation, sorry but you'll just have to enjoy the game from a seated position!
 
Back
Top