Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

I thought his kicking was poor today, did he get his hand to the one that hit the post in the first half? He's not on the books of Man Utd for nothing but plenty have been and come to nothing, hopefully he for fills his potential here with us.

Fulfils, mate. 😉
 
Stuckmann's is much worse IMO.

It really isn't. Johnstone it better with the ball at his feet but he barely gets it over the half way line and that's if it's even on target - which it often isn't. It's a worry as we lose possession so easily as a consequence. Stuckers' kicks are massive and hang high in the air, even if their aim is inconsistent.
 
It really isn't. Johnstone it better with the ball at his feet but he barely gets it over the half way line and that's if it's even on target - which it often isn't. It's a worry as we lose possession so easily as a consequence. Stuckers' kicks are massive and hang high in the air, even if their aim is inconsistent.

Like that massive, high hanging one against Walsall in the JPT………which went right across the floor, gave them a free kick and they scored.

I don't mind Stuckmann, but his kicking is his major weakness. Slices them all over the place. All opinions though of course.
 
Good keeper. A couple of lads saying last night that he's going to cost us £1m at the end of the season. As good as he is, I'm not too sure that we should be splashing that out on him (unless it is massively associated with incentives). e.g. £250k up front, another £250k after 50 apps/100 apps, same if we stay up, etc.
 
i think Johnstone is perhaps a better communicator than any other GK at the club, Jones inability to both claim crosses and organize the back 3/4 was his downfall because eventually the defence lost all confidence in him.

Stuckmann has been good for the club but Johnstone is clearly a big improvement on him if we could sign him permanently in the summer he could be our number 1 GK for a long, long time, i can understand people around me at matches having some loyalty to Stuckmann but i can't understand why they also moan about Johnstone like he's the worst keeper in the clubs history after 1 bad kick/throw.

strikers get judged on goals, well if you judge a GK on clean sheets then i think Johnstone's record is 8 clean sheets in about 14 games which is a record i think most goalies would like to have.
 
I seem to recall a massive uproar of 'We need a midfielder/striker, not another fucking 'keeper!!!' when we got him on our books................
 
strikers get judged on goals, well if you judge a GK on clean sheets then i think Johnstone's record is 8 clean sheets in about 14 games which is a record i think most goalies would like to have.

+1

Johnstone's excellent clean sheet record isn't really mentioned, as oppose to Stuckmann's which was mentioned all the time when he replaced Jones in the side.
 
+1

Johnstone's excellent clean sheet record isn't really mentioned, as oppose to Stuckmann's which was mentioned all the time when he replaced Jones in the side.

Its simply because some just want to come on here and moan and all they want to do is highlight the failings of their football club instead of praising, you get those sort of people in life.

These people are clinging to this stick to beat Grayson, therefore even if Johnstone manages to pull off 20 world class saves and score a goal in one game if he concedes the doubters will say "Stuckmann shouldn't have been dropped" or "get Stuckmann in nets" because they have a weapon to berate the manager.

Its the next stick on the list after the JPT exit which has now been forgotten by many, strange because they were so upset at the time.
 
Its simply because some just want to come on here and moan and all they want to do is highlight the failings of their football club instead of praising, you get those sort of people in life.

These people are clinging to this stick to beat Grayson, therefore even if Johnstone manages to pull off 20 world class saves and score a goal in one game if he concedes the doubters will say "Stuckmann shouldn't have been dropped" or "get Stuckmann in nets" because they have a weapon to berate the manager.

Its the next stick on the list after the JPT exit which has now been forgotten by many, strange because they were so upset at the time.

Not by me it hasn't........... Bad style was that.
 
Its simply because some just want to come on here and moan and all they want to do is highlight the failings of their football club instead of praising, you get those sort of people in life.

These people are clinging to this stick to beat Grayson, therefore even if Johnstone manages to pull off 20 world class saves and score a goal in one game if he concedes the doubters will say "Stuckmann shouldn't have been dropped" or "get Stuckmann in nets" because they have a weapon to berate the manager.

Its the next stick on the list after the JPT exit which has now been forgotten by many, strange because they were so upset at the time.

And because some have an infatuation with Stuckmann and/or Rudd, when Johnstone has done pretty much everything right so far.
 
And because some have an infatuation with Stuckmann and/or Rudd, when Johnstone has done pretty much everything right so far.


Not seen many people knocking Johnstone to be fair but we all have our favorite players worth thinking about , i think all the lads have done well
 
I don't think he's "all that" to be honest, certainly not to the extent people have been raving about him on here.

I don't recall him keeping us in games with a string of wonder saves, and in most games he has had precious little to do.

If we'd have borrowed him from Huddersfield or somewhere, and word hadn't got out about the supposed £1m price tag, I reckon most would be calling him bang average.

People see what they want to see and factors such as playing for Manchester United and potential £1 million pound transfer fees, possibly subconciously, clouds peoples judgments.

I've no problem with the lad and he probably edges Stuckmann overall, but if we were to actually get promoted I think we could get a 'keeper of equal ability at a fraction of the outrageously inflated transfer fee being spoken of, or even another decent loan from a top club, costing us peanuts.

£1 million pounds would likely be a huge chunk of of our transfer budget, and I reckon it could be spent elsewhere on quality outfield players. Particularly when you consider Daniel Johnson cost us a mere £50K.

This lad could well turn out to be amazing, who knows, very early days, but I've yet to witness anything from him that would me convince to spend £1m quid on the boy.

Tin hat at the ready.
 
I don't think he's "all that" to be honest, certainly not to the extent people have been raving about him on here.

I don't recall him keeping us in games with a string of wonder saves, and in most games he has had precious little to do.

If we'd have borrowed him from Huddersfield or somewhere, and word hadn't got out about the supposed £1m price tag, I reckon most would be calling him bang average.

People see what they want to see and factors such as playing for Manchester United and potential £1 million pound transfer fees, possibly subconciously, clouds peoples judgments.

I've no problem with the lad and he probably edges Stuckmann overall, but if we were to actually get promoted I think we could get a 'keeper of equal ability at a fraction of the outrageously inflated transfer fee being spoken of, or even another decent loan from a top club, costing us peanuts.

£1 million pounds would likely be a huge chunk of of our transfer budget, and I reckon it could be spent elsewhere on quality outfield players. Particularly when you consider Daniel Johnson cost us a mere £50K.

This lad could well turn out to be amazing, who knows, very early days, but I've yet to witness anything from him that would me convince to spend £1m quid on the boy.

Tin hat at the ready.

Bang on the money again Neal - agree with every word pal.

And with posts like that you could be the new 'Voice of PNE Online'.
 
I don't think he's "all that" to be honest, certainly not to the extent people have been raving about him on here.

I don't recall him keeping us in games with a string of wonder saves, and in most games he has had precious little to do.

Good keepers don't have many shots to deal with.

The reason people think Lonergan is ok is because of his shot stopping whereas the fact he's glued to his line and is terrible at reading the game is why he's left in so many one on one situations.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top