Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
3,052
....turned down loan transfer to Fulham on Friday. PNE still in regular contact with Man Utd according to Peter Ridsdale on the train home last night.
 
Why do you think he turned down a loan out to Fulham?
It can',t be in the hope of coming back to Preston as that might not happen. I thought he'd have jumped at the chance of playing every week.
 
Why do you think he turned down a loan out to Fulham?
It can',t be in the hope of coming back to Preston as that might not happen. I thought he'd have jumped at the chance of playing every week.

If the club know Pickford is going back for sure then surely we have offered Johnstone a regular start from January and that's better than going down to London.
 
I know Pickford would be a massive loss, but if we got Johnstone back that would be just as good. Hope it would be on a permanent transfer too. Instead of having a goalkeeper on loan every season.
 
Lets hope he is still at utd in January and Pickford is still with us , its one thing to be a very good keeper at league one level but Pickford has more than proved his worth at championship level and the leagues are worlds apart if we are being honest
 
Aye, it would be good if we got Sam Johnstone back but there seems to be an acceptance on here that Pickford will go in January.
we still have a very able keeper in Kirkland too.
And good as Pickford is, he ain't too great at positioning his walls at free kicks.
 
Johnstone wants to come back to us. He was devastated United messed him and us around, and we had no choice but to get Pickford. Pickford will be back at Sunderland in January or May. I'm convinced Johnstone will be back here permanently when that happens.
 
Last edited:
Lets hope he is still at utd in January and Pickford is still with us , its one thing to be a very good keeper at league one level but Pickford has more than proved his worth at championship level and the leagues are worlds apart if we are being honest

According to Doncaster fans, Johnstone was more than good enough in the Championship for them. We're in a fortunate position. Pickford short term, Johnstone long term. We have no chance of Pickford long term though as things stand.
 
I reckon we say goodbye to Pickford and aim to sign Johnstone rather than loan him.

Between the sticks, I think there is very little between them, they are both excellent. The one thing that stands out for me is Pickford's kick and eye for an opening. He can ping balls to wherever he wants. On the flip-side, I think Johnstone has just a little bit more presence. Put it this way - I wouldn't want to fight Johnstone. He will have the forwards of other teams scared of going near him for fear of getting battered.

Swings & Roundabouts, but I see Pickford going and Johnstone coming. I just hope we stop playing donkey/carrot to Man Utd. I seriously can't stand them.
 
We can't keep relying on loans for this position. If the chance to sign SJ permanently arises in the January window we should jump at the chance. Great keeper Pickford but if that means him leaving then so be it.
 
Still got Kirkland, tried and tested at this level. Keeper is not a problem position even if pickford is recalled.
 
Still got Kirkland, tried and tested at this level. Keeper is not a problem position even if pickford is recalled.

I'm no football expert, and will never pretend to be.

Had a quick look at Kirkland during the warm-up prior to the Blackburn game. To say that he struggles to run is a bit of an understatement. My 15yr old son pointed it out, and he was not wrong.
 
Still got Kirkland, tried and tested at this level. Keeper is not a problem position even if pickford is recalled.


Maybe... but only 4 league games in the last 18 months. He has the potential to be good... but I'd be nervous.
 
What I'm wondering is how much is it going to cost us to sign him permanently. If there was a 1mil fee on his loan last time to make it permanent do you think we'll have to pay more this time around to actually get the deal done?
 
What I'm wondering is how much is it going to cost us to sign him permanently. If there was a 1mil fee on his loan last time to make it permanent do you think we'll have to pay more this time around to actually get the deal done?

Having seen how Man Utd act, I'd say his price has definitely increased.
 
Maybe... but only 4 league games in the last 18 months. He has the potential to be good... but I'd be nervous.
that's pretty much par for the course for a 2nd string keeper though and it doesn't seem to do any harm. Look at Stuckman - didn't play for nearly two years then came in for Jones and kept about 9 clean sheets for us. Declan Rudd won't have played for nearly two years now either.
 
Back
Top