Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

I must be the only person who doesn't see SJ as the be all and end all. Yes he performed well in League One, but then came in and didn't keep a clean sheet during his loan in January, conceding 6 goals in his 4 games - which as a goals to game ratio represents the joint 7th worst in the division. In the 42 games he didn't play we conceded only 39 goals. Yes he's young, but what does he possess that makes him a better prospect than Maxwell?
 
Johnstone is good but not as good as Pickford - and any keeper we sign is going to be judged against Pickford and inevitably found wanting.
 
I must be the only person who doesn't see SJ as the be all and end all. Yes he performed well in League One, but then came in and didn't keep a clean sheet during his loan in January, conceding 6 goals in his 4 games - which as a goals to game ratio represents the joint 7th worst in the division. In the 42 games he didn't play we conceded only 39 goals. Yes he's young, but what does he possess that makes him a better prospect than Maxwell?

Maybe not as ruthless as this, but I'd have to agree with this post. SJ was decent in L1 and I wasnt overly impressed with his loan spell this season. He hasnt played a lot of first team football outside of the games for us so why is he being described as the answer?

Yes he is young and promising and may turn out to be a class keeper, but I havent seen enough to date that would 100% confirm that. Either way, we need 2 keepers this summer, if Maxwell is one then we need someone with more experience at our level to help sustain our excellent first season
 
I must be the only person who doesn't see SJ as the be all and end all. Yes he performed well in League One, but then came in and didn't keep a clean sheet during his loan in January, conceding 6 goals in his 4 games - which as a goals to game ratio represents the joint 7th worst in the division. In the 42 games he didn't play we conceded only 39 goals. Yes he's young, but what does he possess that makes him a better prospect than Maxwell?

Don't judge a goalkeeper on 4 games when he hadn't played in a competitive match for seven months previous to it. If there is one position that you cannot just drop someone into and expect them to perform at a high level, it's goalkeeper.
 
I must be the only person who doesn't see SJ as the be all and end all. Yes he performed well in League One, but then came in and didn't keep a clean sheet during his loan in January, conceding 6 goals in his 4 games - which as a goals to game ratio represents the joint 7th worst in the division. In the 42 games he didn't play we conceded only 39 goals. Yes he's young, but what does he possess that makes him a better prospect than Maxwell?

Won man of the match at Bristol City and played well against Rotherham & Ipswich.

Brentford was the only game when he didn't play well but even our player of the season, Cunningham was utter shit in that game.

Doncaster fans also raved about him when he was on loan there in the Championship.

Using stats from 4 games is a poor argument I think.
 
Apart from Pickford , SJ is the least risky signing we could make for a new GK.

He knows us , the team know him and Grayson knows that once he gets a run of games he is a fantastic young keeper who will only get better .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Apart from Pickford , SJ is the least risky signing we could make for a new GK.

He knows us , the team know him and Grayson knows that once he gets a run of games he is a fantastic young keeper who will only get better .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If we can get him I reckon he'll be our no.1 for 10 years. He's prem quality and will absolutely strengthen our team.
 
Won man of the match at Bristol City and played well against Rotherham & Ipswich.

Brentford was the only game when he didn't play well but even our player of the season, Cunningham was utter shit in that game.

Doncaster fans also raved about him when he was on loan there in the Championship.

Using stats from 4 games is a poor argument I think.

I wasn't particularly using the stats to say don't sign him, I was using them as part of my question as to what makes everybody think he is the answer to our goalkeeping situation. And you haven't answered my question as to what he possesses that Chris Maxwell doesn't.

May not be the most reliable source for statistics but looking at wikipedia:

Sam Johnstone - 23 years old - 74 competitive club games
Chris Maxwell - 25 years old - 243 competitive club games

One would cost upwards of a million, the other is free. Would you forgo spending the money elsewhere on the pitch to sign a still relatively unproven goalkeeper. Or would you take the gamble on a more experienced goalkeeper (in terms of game time) which would able you to strengthen the squad elsewhere with the limited funds available?

Your opinion of Sam Johnstone is formed on his performances for us in League One, where he impressed in a team that was expected to do well. Chris Maxwell has performed equally as impressively for consecutive seasons in the same division but for a team expected to struggle.
 
I wasn't particularly using the stats to say don't sign him, I was using them as part of my question as to what makes everybody think he is the answer to our goalkeeping situation. And you haven't answered my question as to what he possesses that Chris Maxwell doesn't.

May not be the most reliable source for statistics but looking at wikipedia:

Sam Johnstone - 23 years old - 74 competitive club games
Chris Maxwell - 25 years old - 243 competitive club games

One would cost upwards of a million, the other is free. Would you forgo spending the money elsewhere on the pitch to sign a still relatively unproven goalkeeper. Or would you take the gamble on a more experienced goalkeeper (in terms of game time) which would able you to strengthen the squad elsewhere with the limited funds available?

Your opinion of Sam Johnstone is formed on his performances for us in League One, where he impressed in a team that was expected to do well. Chris Maxwell has performed equally as impressively for consecutive seasons in the same division but for a team expected to struggle.

His age is surely a strength, he should get better, especially as keepers reach their peak later than outfield players, and will have a sell on value which should be higher than we pay if he's developed properly, we're looking to build a team of young players with promise and he fits into this.

He didn't look out of place with many of the current squad in L1, and in January, even if you don't think he was great, he didn't look out of place even having not played first team football in 6 months and without really having time to strike up an understanding with the defenders again.

He isn't the be all and end all, but he's a player who we've seen can perform decently with our players and at this level, and should only get better over the next few years. We know he'll get along with the players and SG and fit into the team spirit that has been so important in our success. Like any signing he would be a gamble but everything seems to point to him being able to nail down the no.1 slot for us for a good few years, if he keeps on developing properly, and there are fewer unknowns than a player who we haven't seen much of and who hasn't worked with Grayson or the rest of the squad. This possibility in a position that is often hard to fill and has been turbulent for us for the past few seasons must be worth a million or 2.

He also seems like a Grayson signing, he's worked with him before and knows what he's like, and would fit in with our recent transfer policy of buying younger player with sell on value who we can develop, so I think people are almost anticipating Grayson going after him.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't particularly using the stats to say don't sign him, I was using them as part of my question as to what makes everybody think he is the answer to our goalkeeping situation. And you haven't answered my question as to what he possesses that Chris Maxwell doesn't.

May not be the most reliable source for statistics but looking at wikipedia:

Sam Johnstone - 23 years old - 74 competitive club games
Chris Maxwell - 25 years old - 243 competitive club games

One would cost upwards of a million, the other is free. Would you forgo spending the money elsewhere on the pitch to sign a still relatively unproven goalkeeper. Or would you take the gamble on a more experienced goalkeeper (in terms of game time) which would able you to strengthen the squad elsewhere with the limited funds available?

Your opinion of Sam Johnstone is formed on his performances for us in League One, where he impressed in a team that was expected to do well. Chris Maxwell has performed equally as impressively for consecutive seasons in the same division but for a team expected to struggle.

I never compared Johnstone to Maxwell in the first place, i'm not in a position to say whether Maxwell is decent or not, plus we need two keepers anyway.

My reason for wanting to sign Johnstone is based on me watching him live for a decent period of time, impressing me more than a player who played in goal for Norwich in the Premier League this season (who is also a good keeper).

I'd be happy for us to spend over a million on Johnstone because i'd like to think I know a quality keeper when I see one, him & Pickford are the best we've had since Carlo Nash.
 
We should do all we can to sign Johnstone, Would love Pickford back on loan but thats all it will ever be a loan, where we need a main stay not just for the season coming but for the next 5-10 years, Which Johnstone could be this keeper, by all means he isn't fully Premeirship level yet, but he will be and I can see many a prem team interested in him in if he gets first team football for the next 2-3 years, Failing getting Johnstone, we know all about Rudd, Maxwell would be a class back up, But if I was a player I would rather be playing week in week out at League 1 level than sat picking my nose on the bench at Championship, " which funnily enough is a statement of sorts that Linedergaard came out with while at United".
 
I wasn't particularly using the stats to say don't sign him, I was using them as part of my question as to what makes everybody think he is the answer to our goalkeeping situation. And you haven't answered my question as to what he possesses that Chris Maxwell doesn't.

May not be the most reliable source for statistics but looking at wikipedia:

Sam Johnstone - 23 years old - 74 competitive club games
Chris Maxwell - 25 years old - 243 competitive club games

One would cost upwards of a million, the other is free. Would you forgo spending the money elsewhere on the pitch to sign a still relatively unproven goalkeeper. Or would you take the gamble on a more experienced goalkeeper (in terms of game time) which would able you to strengthen the squad elsewhere with the limited funds available?

Your opinion of Sam Johnstone is formed on his performances for us in League One, where he impressed in a team that was expected to do well. Chris Maxwell has performed equally as impressively for consecutive seasons in the same division but for a team expected to struggle.

Johnstone is more of a known quantity thats why people lean towards him, he did perform behind a team that was expected to do well but some of the saves he pulled off were very important and at times definitely won us points.

Vs Bradford 0-0 Stead clean through, he saves.

Vs Bristol City 0-0 Wilbraham header, he saves onto the bar.

Vs Chesterfield 2nd Leg 0-0 Clucas clean through, he saves and that would have been 1-1 on aggregate with a large proportion of the match to go.

He was there when called upon, a very important thing to have.
 
Johnstone is more of a known quantity thats why people lean towards him, he did perform behind a team that was expected to do well but some of the saves he pulled off were very important and at times definitely won us points.

Vs Bradford 0-0 Stead clean through, he saves.

Vs Bristol City 0-0 Wilbraham header, he saves onto the bar.

Vs Chesterfield 2nd Leg 0-0 Clucas clean through, he saves and that would have been 1-1 on aggregate with a large proportion of the match to go.

He was there when called upon, a very important thing to have.

Great quotes Ron, well remembered. JOHNSTONE is quality and just what we need, I think and it is only think but hope that he is on his way, he likes our club he supports our club and couldn't wait to play for us. He will at that age wanting first team football and he wont get it at Utd, he will here, come on Sam lets hope you are the first of many through the door.
 
Last edited:
Decent enough I suppose. Think he's a bit overrated, myself.
Me too.

Especially for the mooted £1m-2m price tag. That's no shrewd purchase, that's a top-bat price.

It would probably mean our main spending was done for the summer too. Risky.
 
I saw a retweet the other week from Sam, he was talking to fans at the Burnley game on the Invincibles so he clearly is still about the building.
 
Back
Top