Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

He's not known for trying young players so on balance I think we might have a better chance if the price is right

Ruben Loftus-Cheek was pushed through because of him, he played Kenedy a lot too before he got sacked. He might not be as into it as van Gaal, but he's not oblivious to youth.

I think De Gea might stay now he's there, and Valdes won't be as overlooked as he was under van Gaal. Add Romero into the equation, and Johnstone could only realistically be 3rd choice at best.
 
Ruben Loftus-Cheek was pushed through because of him, he played Kenedy a lot too before he got sacked. He might not be as into it as van Gaal, but he's not oblivious to youth.

I think De Gea might stay now he's there, and Valdes won't be as overlooked as he was under van Gaal. Add Romero into the equation, and Johnstone could only realistically be 3rd choice at best.
This, I had read last week that De Gea had said he wasn't going to stay at Old Trafford if LVG was going to stay.
 
Time to move on from SJ in my opinion and look elsewhere. He didn't look all that hot in the championship anyway. There seems to be a bit of an obsession with him on here.
 
. He didn't look all that hot in the championship anyway. .


He played like what, 4/5 games? And from reports was very good in the games at Bristol City and Ipswich as well, he was poor against Brentford but the whole team was, seemed like he suffered from no first team football in 7 months
 
He played like what, 4/5 games? And from reports was very good in the games at Bristol City and Ipswich as well, he was poor against Brentford but the whole team was, seemed like he suffered from no first team football in 7 months
He will have had no first team footy in another seven months if we sign him this summer.
 
He will have had no first team footy in another seven months if we sign him this summer.

Yes, but if we sign him permanently then that will given him time to be ready for championship football. He played 5/6 games for us last season and people expect him to be fantastic! If we sign him this summer he is young and will develop into a top class keeper. I have seen enough to see that.
 
Yes, but if we sign him permanently then that will given him time to be ready for championship football. He played 5/6 games for us last season and people expect him to be fantastic! If we sign him this summer he is young and will develop into a top class keeper. I have seen enough to see that.
I feel there is an obsession with us getting him. And many seem to think the only keepers we should try to get are Johnstone, Pickford or Rudd. We'll probably end up with none of them.
 
I feel there is an obsession with us getting him. And many seem to think the only keepers we should try to get are Johnstone, Pickford or Rudd. We'll probably end up with none of them.

I tend to agree we've chased him for a very long time and it's probably time to move on, and I agree suggestions of Pickford and Rudd are unrealistic.

However I don't agree on your comment about SJ in the Championship. He did very little wrong.

Who do you suggest we sign ?
 
I tend to agree we've chased him for a very long time and it's probably time to move on, and I agree suggestions of Pickford and Rudd are unrealistic.

However I don't agree on your comment about SJ in the Championship. He did very little wrong.

Who do you suggest we sign ?
no idea but my point was there seems to be a feeling that whoever else we sign will be a disappointment to many because it isn't Sam Johnstone.
 
no idea but my point was there seems to be a feeling that whoever else we sign will be a disappointment to many because it isn't Sam Johnstone.
A bit like the attitude to Maxwell. Nobodys actually seen the guy play but straight away hes obviously not good enough.
 
Nobodys actually seen the guy play but straight away hes obviously not good enough.

Correct, so also on that basis, how could anyone have a clue if he's good enough to be our number 1 ?

I'll judge him based on how he does in pre-season and in the league if he does start as our number 1, which I don't think he will initially.
 
Back
Top