Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

Correct, so also on that basis, how could anyone have a clue if he's good enough to be our number 1 ?

I'll judge him based on how he does in pre-season and in the league if he does start as our number 1, which I don't think he will initially.
Why dont you think he will?
 
Correct, so also on that basis, how could anyone have a clue if he's good enough to be our number 1 ?

I'll judge him based on how he does in pre-season and in the league if he does start as our number 1, which I don't think he will initially.

Not having a go at you Sedge but I'm not particularly bothered what you think of Maxwell. PNE monitored him all last season and felt he was good enough to be offered a 3 year deal. It obviously depends on who else we bring in, but I suspect Maxwell has been brought in to be the No1 keeper.
 
no idea but my point was there seems to be a feeling that whoever else we sign will be a disappointment to many because it isn't Sam Johnstone.

Nobody has said that. Sam johnstone is a decent goalie and if get him great but if not there are plenty of keepers out there who with a decent run of games under their belt will be very good goalies. The only thing that I and many fans will want is for this goalie to be permenent as although loan keepers have done well here over the last two/three years we need a goalie who could take the number one spot for years to come.
 
Not having a go at you Sedge but I'm not particularly bothered what you think of Maxwell. PNE monitored him all last season and felt he was good enough to be offered a 3 year deal. It obviously depends on who else we bring in, but I suspect Maxwell has been brought in to be the No1 keeper.

No he has been brought in to challenge for the number 1 spot when we sign another keeper.
 
Not having a go at you Sedge but I'm not particularly bothered what you think of Maxwell. PNE monitored him all last season and felt he was good enough to be offered a 3 year deal. It obviously depends on who else we bring in, but I suspect Maxwell has been brought in to be the No1 keeper.

I haven't said what I think of him. I've not seen enough of him to make a judgement, has anyone ?

I suspect he hasn't been brought in to be number 1 given the links today to Lindegaard, and a poster, think it was Chip Barm, mentioned a Premier League loan goalie the other week, but let's just wait and see anyway.

No he has been brought in to challenge for the number 1 spot when we sign another keeper.


This is what I think will be the case too, and it's not a criticism of Maxwell although some are taking it that way for some reason.
 
Last edited:
I'd be pleased with both keepers, but from what I saw of Johnstone when he was here this season I wasn't that impressed tbh. As with Lindegaard, I think his experience is key but similar with Johnstone he did make some mistakes. Think it all comes down to wages with Lindegaard, and for Johnstone I think it will be down to whether he wants to leave his boyhood club
 
I'd be pleased with both keepers, but from what I saw of Johnstone when he was here this season I wasn't that impressed tbh. As with Lindegaard, I think his experience is key but similar with Johnstone he did make some mistakes. Think it all comes down to wages with Lindegaard, and for Johnstone I think it will be down to whether he wants to leave his boyhood club
The fact that man Utd are his boyhood club, and the worlds biggest club (say some) makes a permanent move away such a huge decision for Johnstone. Because once he leaves, he will never return, and that must be a real tough one for him.
 
The fact that man Utd are his boyhood club, and the worlds biggest club (say some) makes a permanent move away such a huge decision for Johnstone. Because once he leaves, he will never return, and that must be a real tough one for him.

Well he needs to realise he isn't good enough for the Prem and the only way he might become good enough is to further his career elsewhere and why not do it at the second biggest club in the world (say some) Preston North End 😉.

I'd be surprised if he was in Mourinho's plans after the pre season, Mourinho has always had a good keeper on the bench and Johnstone would have to become world class to usurp the current number 1.
 
I haven't said what I think of him. I've not seen enough of him to make a judgement, has anyone ?

I suspect he hasn't been brought in to be number 1 given the links today to Lindegaard, and a poster, think it was Chip Barm, mentioned a Premier League loan goalie the other week, but let's just wait and see anyway.




This is what I think will be the case too, and it's not a criticism of Maxwell although some are taking it that way for some reason.

I know you haven't said what you think of him, but in your words, "I'll judge him based on how he does in pre-season and in the league if he does start as our number 1, which I don't think he will initially."

Hopefully, the second keeper that's brought in is decent, and capable of challenging Maxwell for the No1 spot, but from your comments you're expecting us to bring in a 'better keeper' than Maxwell. IF this is what you think, be prepared to be disappointed! I'd love us to bring in a top quality keeper, but if our budget is what several people have already suggested, I can't see it happening.
 
I know you haven't said what you think of him, but in your words, "I'll judge him based on how he does in pre-season and in the league if he does start as our number 1, which I don't think he will initially."

Hopefully, the second keeper that's brought in is decent, and capable of challenging Maxwell for the No1 spot, but from your comments you're expecting us to bring in a 'better keeper' than Maxwell. IF this is what you think, be prepared to be disappointed! I'd love us to bring in a top quality keeper, but if our budget is what several people have already suggested, I can't see it happening.

I just thought that if reports were to be believed, and Lindegaard returning is a serious possibility, it would probably be quite a big investment wages wise and he would no doubt be the number 1. Who knows, that may or may not happen.
 
I just thought that if reports were to be believed, and Lindegaard returning is a serious possibility, it would probably be quite a big investment wages wise and he would no doubt be the number 1. Who knows, that may or may not happen.

I think pilchard mentioned that Lindegaard wouldn't be coming back, and he usually seems to be clued up. That said, things change, and Lindegaard could return if he drops his wages substantially. I just feel that IF Maxwell wasn't a serious contender for the No1 shirt, he wouldn't have been offered a 3 year contract.
 
13260273_1036359236452206_4766334216741751787_n.jpg


Sam Johnstone said:
Another season finished, a very frustrating one!!! But been great to learn from DDG & Sergio. Time to chill and prepare for next season ��
 
Pickford still has plenty of splinters up his rear end and only featured once in the run in with Sunderland and that was the last game of the season when it was pretty much all over so why shouldnt we try and have a punt for him. He obviously continues to be overlooked in favour of Mannone. Maxwell to us is a pretty much unknown but was player of the year in the Cod Army's first season in Div 1 so hopefully with a decent defence in front of him and at 25 he is probably a good solid signing and will vie for the no.1 shirt.
 
Pickford still has plenty of splinters up his rear end and only featured once in the run in with Sunderland and that was the last game of the season when it was pretty much all over so why shouldnt we try and have a punt for him. He obviously continues to be overlooked in favour of Mannone. Maxwell to us is a pretty much unknown but was player of the year in the Cod Army's first season in Div 1 so hopefully with a decent defence in front of him and at 25 he is probably a good solid signing and will vie for the no.1 shirt.

Pickford will be number 2 for Sunderland this year with the possibility of him being a cup keeper.

The only way we could get him on loan for the season is if Sunderland sign a backup keeper, which I think is unlikely as Pickford is an able deputy as he has proved for us and them.
 
Pickford will be number 2 for Sunderland this year with the possibility of him being a cup keeper.

The only way we could get him on loan for the season is if Sunderland sign a backup keeper, which I think is unlikely as Pickford is an able deputy as he has proved for us and them.

Which they won't because they sold their back up keeper, Pantillimon, in order to promote Pickford to the number 2 role.
 
Back
Top