Sam Johnstone is not a good enough keeper for PNE. He is far too small and too inexperienced. With him in goal we have played 3 relegation fodder sides in Yeovil, Crewe and now Crawley. I expected 9 points from those games and clean sheets. We have managed 2 points. Crawley prior to today had not won since October, and for their 2nd goal Johnstone just stood there and watched a long range effort go past him. Meanwhile Stucky is dropped again following a decent performance against a tough Sheff Utd side.
Why was Johnstone given a starting place as soon as he arrived? He hadn't earned it and Stucky was doing OK. Johnstone has proved he cannot hack it against the worst sides in League 1 and I fear for our results when we play top sides if he continues to be 1st choice. He is better than Jones and a better prospect than Jones ... but at League 1 he is not as good or as experienced as Stucky!
Why was Johnstone given a starting place as soon as he arrived? He hadn't earned it and Stucky was doing OK. Johnstone has proved he cannot hack it against the worst sides in League 1 and I fear for our results when we play top sides if he continues to be 1st choice. He is better than Jones and a better prospect than Jones ... but at League 1 he is not as good or as experienced as Stucky!