Skip to main content

Saturdays Ref against Brum.

Saturdays Ref against Brum.

Joined
Jan 15, 2005
Messages
2,525
Mike Riley supposedly is one of our top officials, so how is it that.....

1. He booked Sledge on his first tackle when the attacker was going nowhere?

2. He waves away a penalty appeal DIRECTLY in front of him, was it not a dive from McSheffrey then?

3. He watches McSheffrey continue to fall over at the slightest touch at every opportunity and then gives him the benefit of the doubt against Sledge when the `linking of arm` was the only visible connection and how the hell do you tell who `linked` in the first place.

Neither set of fans were impressed by him, and he`s one of our better officials.
 
Mike Riley supposedly is one of our top officials, so how is it that.....

1. He booked Sledge on his first tackle when the attacker was going nowhere?

2. He waves away a penalty appeal DIRECTLY in front of him, was it not a dive from McSheffrey then?

3. He watches McSheffrey continue to fall over at the slightest touch at every opportunity and then gives him the benefit of the doubt against Sledge when the `linking of arm` was the only visible connection and how the hell do you tell who `linked` in the first place.

Neither set of fans were impressed by him, and he`s one of our better officials.

1. A Referee is allowed to book a player EVEN if it is his first tackle and the opposition player was going nowhere. Its called Interpretation of Careless, Reckless or Excessive force.

2. Well was it a dive ???, if Mike Riley didnt think so then he is right to wave play on.

3. Sedgwick should of known better than to create contact with McSheffrey in the box, and if Riley thought the incident was more one sided than the other then he was right to award a spot kick.
 
1. A Referee is allowed to book a player EVEN if it is his first tackle and the opposition player was going nowhere. Its called Interpretation of Careless, Reckless or Excessive force.

2. Well was it a dive ???, if Mike Riley didnt think so then he is right to wave play on.

3. Sedgwick should of known better than to create contact with McSheffrey in the box, and if Riley thought the incident was more one sided than the other then he was right to award a spot kick.

It`s a bloody good job you`re only a Sunday league ref. If it wasn`t a dive it was a penalty, if it was a dive it`s a booking, he gave niether.
It was the first time I`ve seen a penalty given while shepherding the ball out, if this sets precedence I`ll be amazed, usually as I said before, you are allowed three submissions and a pinfall in these circumstances usually.
Mc Sheffrey was clever, he linked arms with St ledger and went down with minimal contact, the main contact if you watched was shoulder to shoulder.
A referee should use commonsense with the first tackle, the game hasn`t even warmed up. He should have had a word, but commonsense is lacking with a lot of refs, even at Sunday league standard it seems.

Over to the MIke Riley fan club.
 
I did not think that Riley was as bad as he may have been. I was really worried that he would have us out of the game straight from kick off, but he has waited until the last to be most decisive. I actually think it was a penalty, soft and not always given (Mr Rennie?), but nonetheless a penalty.

You can have contact but it not be a penalty, and that is how I viewed the Birmingham claim from the first half. This is not sunday park logic but something which is common in the game.
 
I did not think that Riley was as bad as he may have been. I was really worried that he would have us out of the game straight from kick off, but he has waited until the last to be most decisive. I actually think it was a penalty, soft and not always given (Mr Rennie?), but nonetheless a penalty.

You can have contact but it not be a penalty, and that is how I viewed the Birmingham claim from the first half. This is not sunday park logic but something which is common in the game.

Thankyou for bringing some common sense to this forum.

Oh and if my memory serves me right, quite a few Football League Refs continue to Referee Sunday League.

I cant wait to get on the Football League so I can give Penaltys galore against teams I dont like.😉
 
What about Bedtner nearly catching the ball on the half way line in the build up to the penalty - everyone in the ground could see it was hand ball.
 
I think this post raises the regular issue of consisency between referees. If you look at the bigger picture, look how much clubs have to gain by gaining entry to the Premiership. Referees can directly influence this through their decisions and yet, when there are poor decisions made, the referees appear to be unaccountable. In this day and age, this is unacceptable. These 'officials' need to be made accountable for their decisions and personally, I would train ex-professionals to be officials as they really know the game and will make decisionsbased on their experiences.
 
It`s a bloody good job you`re only a Sunday league ref. If it wasn`t a dive it was a penalty, if it was a dive it`s a booking, he gave niether.
...Over to the MIke Riley fan club.

You arrogant little ***. Are you really saying that every time a player goes down it's either a foul or a dive? And if you've got such good eyesight, why don't you start refereeing? Or are you too busy moaning about other referees?
 
3. Sedgwick should of known better than to create contact with McSheffrey in the box, and if Riley thought the incident was more one sided than the other then he was right to award a spot kick.

You would have thought a PNE 'fanatic' would be able to spot the difference between Sedgwick and St Ledger. If your eyesight is poor, what are you doing refereeing?
 
Riley blew his whistle the moment Ledge shouldered Shefrey, even BEFORE they touched the floor. As for arms, they both had their arms in a tangle, not Ledge holding Shefrey. A blatant dive although not as bad as the first half, when there was NO contact and Shfrey WAS looking to go down and con the ref. So, fanatic and the other one, why is that not a booking??? No doubt you`ll never get out of refing in the sunday league, with knowledge like yours.
 
You arrogant little ***. Are you really saying that every time a player goes down it's either a foul or a dive? And if you've got such good eyesight, why don't you start refereeing? Or are you too busy moaning about other referees?

I saw the replays, it was a dive and he should have been booked, if he thought it wasn`t a dive, it had to be a penalty, because there was no contact with the ball. The only other alternative is fair challenge, which it wasn`t either as he was nowhere near the ball.
Fuck me there`s some thick fuckers on here.
 
I saw the replays, it was a dive and he should have been booked, if he thought it wasn`t a dive, it had to be a penalty, because there was no contact with the ball. The only other alternative is fair challenge, which it wasn`t either as he was nowhere near the ball.
Fuck me there`s some thick fuckers on here.

Make a difference to the world, Show us all how its done.

Be a Referee, or are you scared of a load of blokes having a go at you right in your face.

Newspaper Joe tried it but he just couldnt help himself from battering nine players at once who dared stand up to him..... He's Nails
 
But Riley booked Sledger in the first half for an inocuous tackle on Bendtner, this made Saint wary of tackling for fear of a second yellow and was a poor decision by the ref. who allowed late challenges galore by the Brom forwards particularly Jerome who he did eventually book after his third or fourth late challenge.
 
Make a difference to the world, Show us all how its done.

Be a Referee, or are you scared of a load of blokes having a go at you right in your face.

Newspaper Joe tried it but he just couldnt help himself from battering nine players at once who dared stand up to him..... He's Nails

As said before, referees are usually inadequates who want to put on a uniform now and again and have a bit of authority which they`d never have in real life. Usually victims of bullying who couldn`t get into the police force, which was their real dream job to show everyone they aren`t as pathetic as everyone thinks.
I feel no need to go freezing my cobs off on a Sunday morning refereeing the local pissheads teams.
 
As said before, referees are usually inadequates who want to put on a uniform now and again and have a bit of authority which they`d never have in real life. Usually victims of bullying who couldn`t get into the police force, which was their real dream job to show everyone they aren`t as pathetic as everyone thinks.
I feel no need to go freezing my cobs off on a Sunday morning refereeing the local pissheads teams.

Well I must be the exception rather than rule as I am a Chief Petty Officer in the Royal Navy and have vast hordes of minions to order about.

And then theres Howard Webb who is a serving Copper, and Darren Drysdale who is a an RAF Sergeant, and Phil Prosser who is an RAF Chief Tech...............................Etc Etc

Go back to your pond.
 
Well I must be the exception rather than rule as I am a Chief Petty Officer in the Royal Navy and have vast hordes of minions to order about.

And then theres Howard Webb who is a serving Copper, and Darren Drysdale who is a an RAF Sergeant, and Phil Prosser who is an RAF Chief Tech...............................Etc Etc

Go back to your pond.

Pardon me for stating the obvious here, but how, as a serving Navy officer, do you get home every Sunday to referee these matches?
Petty officer,Copper, Sergeant, RAF chief. All people seeking authority as stated, thanks for proving my point.
 
As said before, referees are usually inadequates who want to put on a uniform now and again and have a bit of authority which they`d never have in real life. Usually victims of bullying who couldn`t get into the police force, which was their real dream job to show everyone they aren`t as pathetic as everyone thinks.
I feel no need to go freezing my cobs off on a Sunday morning refereeing the local pissheads teams.

Er... think it through. No referees = no football. This includes kids football. No kids football = no up and coming players = end of football once the current players retire. You really are thick aren't you? Refereeing is something which most other referees, myself included, do because they love the game, but maybe can't play to as high a standard as they'd like to. To suggest that referees are inadequates is ridiculous. At professional level, they are extremely fit, well trained individuals who, contrary to what you and your kind may think, have no vendette, no ulterior motive, and really couldn't care less who wins as long as the game is played according to the laws.

What's next - all teachers, police officers and members of the armed forces are inadequates because they like dressing up and telling people what to do?
 
Back
Top