Skip to main content

Scott Laird

Scott Laird

Joined
Jun 25, 2004
Messages
9,049
Is just different class.... Of all our players he's the one in my opinion that could walk into any championship team and not look out of place. Our last three goals have been from three assits by Scott!. Some people say he cant do this or he cant do that but lets focus on what he can do. On the ball his awareness of what's around him means he sees things early which offensively or defensively is of tremendous benefit to the team, his deadball deliveries are something else, he drives us forward from deep dragging the opposition players out of position and he can score goals.

Like he said himself just the other day he's back to his best and the stats and his performances are showing just that.
 
He must be on about 7 or 8 assists this season, our last 3, Kevin Davies against Stevenage, the own goal against Swindon off the top of my head, must be a few converted corners too.

He nearly scored one of his trademark near post headers yesterday too.
 
I think he has struggled so far if I'm honest particularly at home. However the reason he is in the team is his ability from set plays and ability to cross the ball. He has got 3 assists in the last 2 games hence the reason he is probably keeping Buchanan out as Laird offers more of an attacking threat but can often be caught out defensively.
 
I think he has struggled so far if I'm honest particularly at home. However the reason he is in the team is his ability from set plays and ability to cross the ball. He has got 3 assists in the last 2 games hence the reason he is probably keeping Buchanan out as Laird offers more of an attacking threat but can often be caught out defensively.

Laird is just as good as Buchanan defensively if not better but gets doubled up on in the current system, even then I don't remember any glaring errors from him or any goals that stand out as his fault. He's in a different league to Buchanan imo.
 
Laird is just as good as Buchanan defensively if not better but gets doubled up on in the current system, even then I don't remember any glaring errors from him or any goals that stand out as his fault. He's in a different league to Buchanan imo.

He hasn't made any glaring errors however if you watch games recently there has been too much space for the attacking sides down our left a la Reid on Tuesday night. His passing in the middle third of the pitch has often been suspect and often given the ball away. I am in no way saying he should be dropped just saying he is not at the standard he was playing at prior to his injury.
 
He hasn't made any glaring errors however if you watch games recently there has been too much space for the attacking sides down our left a la Reid on Tuesday night. His passing in the middle third of the pitch has often been suspect and often given the ball away. I am in no way saying he should be dropped just saying he is not at the standard he was playing at prior to his injury.

The system doesn't help him at all, end of the day he is a full back who likes to over lap, he's at his best when there is a winger pulling their right back out wide and he can cut in and have a run. He can't do that as much when playing as a wing back and he's got to be more careful as there is no-one covering him.

I think he's doing well but his limited by the position he is playing, he's still been very effective though.
 
The system doesn't help him at all, end of the day he is a full back who likes to over lap, he's at his best when there is a winger pulling their right back out wide and he can cut in and have a run. He can't do that as much when playing as a wing back and he's got to be more careful as there is no-one covering him.

I think he's doing well but his limited by the position he is playing, he's still been very effective though.

This!
 
The way I see it. Laird is a better wing back than Buchanan would be by a long way, although it is not his best position. He is also the better option in a four man defence than Buchanan as he can get forward to better effect while being competent defensively. Laird is currently supplying a few assists which can only be a positive and is more than can be said for some. Overall, I don't really see how anyone could say we would be better off with Buchanan in the team as Laird is one of our better players and is performing well. I think there is also more to come from Laird, as while he has been getting into good positions, he has not been as dangerous as he had been last season before the injury. For a player who is not back to his best yet though, it's fair to say he's doing a pretty good job.
 
Laird is doing ok in my opinion, but I do feel he is still snatching at shots or set plays etc so in that sense he's not at his best just yet but it's coming. Ben Rhodes told SG yesterday in his post match video interview on PNE Player that laird has 5 goal assist. ( in saying that we do know that they can get their stats wrong at times HAHA)
 
He hasn't made any glaring errors however if you watch games recently there has been too much space for the attacking sides down our left a la Reid on Tuesday night. His passing in the middle third of the pitch has often been suspect and often given the ball away. I am in no way saying he should be dropped just saying he is not at the standard he was playing at prior to his injury.

Agree with most of this. I am not one of his biggest fans by any stretch of the imagination. Gives the ball away far too much in my opinion. Having said that I would still pick him in this formation, and probably even in a 4-4-2 due to the attacking threat that he does pose.
 
Lairds a quality player and would be one of only a few that would easily make the step up to Championship football. Considering what he's being asked to do ( totally alien to him ) I think he's doing a remarkable job........ That said, due to the formation and tactics ( as others have pointed out) I really don't believe that we are getting the best out of him !
 
I would still pick him in this formation, and probably even in a 4-4-2 due to the attacking threat that he does pose.

The only other player with the mix of attacking skill and defensive aptitude to play the left-sided 'wing-half- role would be Hayhurst. Holmes would be too weak in the tackle and Buchanan devoid of offensive capability. Humphrey seems to be serviceable, though no more, in that role on the other flank, though when King returns that might free up Keane to be given a trial run there.
 
Scott Laird is the best left back we've had in years, and he will always make & score goals. I also think he is a decent defender, but he offers us so much going forwards. I also feel he is better suited to playing behind a winger than being a wing back. He is the one good thing to come out of Westley's reign as I don't think he would have signed for us had Westley not been our Manager at the time.
 
Class player, not much point moving him at mo with his current form and his best position obviously is left back, but does any one think he could play the attacking central midfielder role better than our current options?
 
Class player, not much point moving him at mo with his current form and his best position obviously is left back, but does any one think he could play the attacking central midfielder role better than our current options?

Laird is a brilliant left-back and OK as a left-sided 'wing-half'. He is very poor as the wide left midfielder in a 4.4.2 formation. But oddly I have a sneak feeling he might be quite good as a more central midfielder.
 
Back
Top