Skip to main content

Scott Wiseman

Scott Wiseman

LostinSpace

The Optimist
Staff member
The Gentry (RIP)
Joined
Jun 15, 2005
Messages
29,601
Did anyone on here see the Scotland v Gibralter game? I was wondering how Wiseman did.
 
Did anyone on here see the Scotland v Gibralter game? I was wondering how Wiseman did.

I didn't watch it all but from what I saw he did OK. He was telling the other Gibralter players where to stand for corners, etc. Gibralter scored their first ever goal in the game but then again it was only Scotland they played 😉 BTW Scotland won 6-1
 
Is there actually any point of him playing for Gibraltar? It seems a complete waste of time, and for what...? He'd be better making himself available for selection rather than going off on international duty to play with inferior players and be hammered every game.

For me, Wiseman's got his priorities all wrong...
 
Is there actually any point of him playing for Gibraltar? It seems a complete waste of time, and for what...? He'd be better making himself available for selection rather than going off on international duty to play with inferior players and be hammered every game.

For me, Wiseman's got his priorities all wrong...

Because he wants to represent his country that's why?
 
Is there actually any point of him playing for Gibraltar? It seems a complete waste of time, and for what...? He'd be better making himself available for selection rather than going off on international duty to play with inferior players and be hammered every game.

For me, Wiseman's got his priorities all wrong...

Can understand your thoughts, but, are you seriously saying that if England were shit (gibraltar shit I mean) and you received an international call up to play in Euro Qualifiers against ANY team in Europe, you'd think twice about accepting?? It's every players dream to play on the international stage and even if the rest of your countries team is dogshit, you'd still want to be there!
Or maybe I'm wrong, maybe he just fucking hates Fleetwood?
 
Can understand your thoughts, but, are you seriously saying that if England were shit (gibraltar shit I mean) and you received an international call up to play in Euro Qualifiers against ANY team in Europe, you'd think twice about accepting?? It's every players dream to play on the international stage and even if the rest of your countries team is dogshit, you'd still want to be there!
Or maybe I'm wrong, maybe he just fucking hates Fleetwood?

I seem to remember when he first started playing for Gibraltar he said that his club football would still take priority. Not being funny but he'd probably have started for us today had he decided to give international football a miss this time around.

I'm all for players playing international football, but let's face it Gibraltar aren't going to come close to qualifying for a tournament and this game came at a time when we needed him here.

I'm not saying that he shouldn't play for them, but when it comes to club vs country, he should be picking Preston every time. It's not as if Gibraltar are spoiled for choice and won't pick him when there isn't a clash.
 
But he is eligible to play for Gibraltar at the highest level....

Shame Gibraltar can't compete at the highest level though isn't it? They're conceding 4 or 5 goals a game aren't they and, they won't even be able to enter qualification for the World Cup. Like I say it's about priorities, and for me, going to get thrashed by Scotland isn't particularly productive or useful to either the player or us.
 
Shame Gibraltar can't compete at the highest level though isn't it? They're conceding 4 or 5 goals a game aren't they and, they won't even be able to enter qualification for the World Cup. Like I say it's about priorities, and for me, going to get thrashed by Scotland isn't particularly productive or useful to either the player or us.

But Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland never qualify should their players not play either?
 
But Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland never qualify should their players not play either?

Not quite the same thing though is it? In the case of Scotland and recently Wales, they usually aren't too far away from qualifying are they? And in the majority of games they play they are at least competitive because they are all full-time professional players.

I don't have an in-depth knowledge of the Gibraltar national team but I'd say that well over half aren't professional, and they're conceding 4, 5, 6 goals a game typically.

In any case, if there was a club v country row and that country had no chance of qualifying then yes, I'd expect players to choose their club, especially when the club in question have something to play for.
 
So what? Half the Irish, Scottish, Northern Irish players weren't born there....Lawro, Kilbane etc etc

All I'm saying is he probably its probably the chance to play international football, rather than the country that he's representing that he finds so appealing. Given that he's a professional footballer, at a club that is still challenging for promotion to the Championship then it's unlikely that if he refused to play this time around that Gibraltar would have ignored him for future squad selections.

The better decision, in my humble opinion, would have been for him to make himself available to us today. If we get promotion then we'll have international breaks, and there'll be no club vs country conflict anyway.
 
Not quite the same thing though is it? In the case of Scotland and recently Wales, they usually aren't too far away from qualifying are they? And in the majority of games they play they are at least competitive because they are all full-time professional players.

I don't have an in-depth knowledge of the Gibraltar national team but I'd say that well over half aren't professional, and they're conceding 4, 5, 6 goals a game typically.

In any case, if there was a club v country row and that country had no chance of qualifying then yes, I'd expect players to choose their club, especially when the club in question have something to play for.

And Robinson he wasn't playing for full honours?

They are normally miles away from qualification...
 
Technically he's not our player, and we have to respect whatever Villa want us to do with regards to his development.

But he has the option.... as does Wiseman...

They are opting to play at the highest level and that should be respected....

You don't pick playing for a country solely on whether you qualify for a major tournaments
 
But he has the option.... as does Wiseman...

They are opting to play at the highest level and that should be respected....

You don't pick playing for a country solely on whether you qualify for a major tournaments

He has the option, but there's also more competition for Robinson to get into the team work his way up through the ranks. Also, if he was to withdraw then he'd likely be killing off his international career before he started - even if he was to go back to Villa and start banging in the goals, the media would be on his back from the off.

With Wiseman he's a 29 year old who isn't going to get any better, playing for a country that isn't going to get close to qualifying for a tournament, certainly not Euro 2016. If he decides to skip international duty to play for his club side, a side with a great chance of promotion, then I don't think anyone from Gibraltar would have any complaints.

They're being embarrassed at international level, they don't have a full squad of professional players, and that won't change anytime soon, especially not in the time that Wiseman continues to play. If they were being competitive then there's an argument that he should play, but they're not. If they were in with a chance of qualifying then there's an argument that he should play, but they're not.

Every call-up should be judged on its own case. But going to play for a team bottom of their group, with 1 goal scored, 27 conceded and zero points is just, well, pointless.

If you're in the Championship and there's an international break then why not go for a jolly, but Wiseman isn't. And the issue is that he's gone to play in a meaningless game, whilst we've been playing a far more important game.
 
He has the option, but there's also more competition for Robinson to get into the team work his way up through the ranks. Also, if he was to withdraw then he'd likely be killing off his international career before he started - even if he was to go back to Villa and start banging in the goals, the media would be on his back from the off.

With Wiseman he's a 29 year old who isn't going to get any better, playing for a country that isn't going to get close to qualifying for a tournament, certainly not Euro 2016. If he decides to skip international duty to play for his club side, a side with a great chance of promotion, then I don't think anyone from Gibraltar would have any complaints.

They're being embarrassed at international level, they don't have a full squad of professional players, and that won't change anytime soon, especially not in the time that Wiseman continues to play. If they were being competitive then there's an argument that he should play, but they're not. If they were in with a chance of qualifying then there's an argument that he should play, but they're not.

Every call-up should be judged on its own case. But going to play for a team bottom of their group, with 1 goal scored, 27 conceded and zero points is just, well, pointless.

If you're in the Championship and there's an international break then why not go for a jolly, but Wiseman isn't. And the issue is that he's gone to play in a meaningless game, whilst we've been playing a far more important game.

At 29 and now able to play against the worlds best. Recently he was able to play against the world champions...

Something not every footballer can say they've done
 
Back
Top