Skip to main content

Sedgwick

Sedgwick

hindle

hindle

Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
131
Cant believe that he started again after the last 2 games i was surprised to see him playing. After listening to todays game too i dont think he should even be on the bench. He reminds me of a ten year old the way he has been playing recently....actually i think a 10 year old could play better!!! What do you make of him?? (this is my opinion so dont go mad if you dont agree😀 )
 
hindle said:
Cant believe that he started again after the last 2 games i was surprised to see him playing. After listening to todays game too i dont think he should even be on the bench. He reminds me of a ten year the way he has been playing recently. What do you make of him?? (this is my opinion so dont go mad if you dont disagree😀 )
Click to expand...
i don't disagree but i'll go mad at you!!😡
 
Sedgwick has played poorly against both Palace and Coventry and from the commentary today he didn't exactly play a blinder.

My team for the Birmingham game would be.

Nash, Alexander, St Ledger, Chilvers, Pugh, Whaley, McKenna, Miller, Neal, Dichio, Nugent.

Subs: Wilson, Neal, Ormerod, Ageymang, Sedgwick.

We have to shuffle our pack as next weeks game is a real big one. We cant afford to be carrying any passengers.

Shuffle it and sort it Simmo. Hopefully this is just a blip.
 
hindle said:
Cant believe that he started again after the last 2 games i was surprised to see him playing. After listening to todays game too i dont think he should even be on the bench. He reminds me of a ten year the way he has been playing recently. What do you make of him?? (this is my opinion so dont go mad if you dont disagree😀 )
Click to expand...

Mmmmmm.

I dunno.

I may just possibly agree with every fibre of my soul, every breath I've ever taken and every emotion I've ever felt. 🙄

But I wouldn't want to overstate my views on the issue.

😱
 
Neaty said:
i think he is great when he has space and time but when teams come to battle and fight for a result he doesnt know what to do
Click to expand...

I respect your opinion.

But how many teams give you space and time in the Championship? 😱
 
Sedge- the weakest link!

Sedge- the weakest link!

At the moment he is having a nightmare in every game. I should have been proved earlier this season that the partnership of Sedgewick and Pugh does not work as good as the Whalley/Alexander one does. There is no mutual support, ther is no overlap and Sedgewick inevitably drifts in field and is no where to be seen when an opposition attack goes down his flank. Add to this his poor form of late and you can see why opposition managers are targeting his flank.
I remember a Rotherham fan posted on here when we signed him to say that he could drift between brilliance and pub player standard.
Get well soon Matty Hill.
 
davetherave said:
At the moment he is having a nightmare in every game. I remember a Rotherham fan posted on here when we signed him to say that he could drift between brilliance and pub player standard.
Click to expand...

Well, we've seen plenty of the 'pub player' Dave.

As for 'brilliance' . . . errrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr . . . 🙄

Still, he was only £350,000 😱 😱 and at 26 he's supposedly at his 'peak' (ffs!!!!).

How much do you reckon we could get for him now? 😕
 
but if players are being dropped through not doing the job right shouldnt both our strikers be on the bench next week or are they on the top of too many peoples shirts at the back to even consider this . 🙄 ....
 
Sedgwick can do fine as a right-sided midfielder if he has a really fast fullback to provide some pace to complement his tenacity - which he does possess. As a central midfielder he is a supporting player, quite literally, in other words one who can provide a foil for a more genuinely creative and influential type of player. The problem is that McKenna is, ultimately, that sort of player as well. The result is the hardworking, but uninspired central midfield we possess now. I am not blaming Simmo for this - he has quite reasonably chosen to try to get the best out of what he inherited and he has done better than anyone could have expected. Remember we are still in an automatic promotion place. But it may be that the team is going to need a slightly more drastic reshaping in the New Year than we might have expected.
 
He ain't a player thats going to take the division by storm BUT he has performed when we have needed him this season & nothing short of a revelation in the CM slot.
 
yeah he has done well up until now, I just think it needs to be changed around a bit. If you know you are going to get a game no matter what complacency steps in, like grezza has been saying.
 
hindle said:
Cant believe that he started again after the last 2 games i was surprised to see him playing. After listening to todays game too i dont think he should even be on the bench. He reminds me of a ten year old the way he has been playing recently....actually i think a 10 year old could play better!!! What do you make of him?? (this is my opinion so dont go mad if you dont agree😀 )
Click to expand...

the only person whos reminds me of a ten year old is you my friend🙄
 
davetherave said:
At the moment he is having a nightmare in every game. I should have been proved earlier this season that the partnership of Sedgewick and Pugh does not work as good as the Whalley/Alexander one does. There is no mutual support, ther is no overlap and Sedgewick inevitably drifts in field and is no where to be seen when an opposition attack goes down his flank. Add to this his poor form of late and you can see why opposition managers are targeting his flank.
I remember a Rotherham fan posted on here when we signed him to say that he could drift between brilliance and pub player standard.
Get well soon Matty Hill.
Click to expand...


There ALL having a nightmare at the moment but lets not stop some having a go at the usual targets though eh.Its much easier afterall🙄
 
davetherave said:
At the moment he is having a nightmare in every game. I should have been proved earlier this season that the partnership of Sedgewick and Pugh does not work as good as the Whalley/Alexander one does. There is no mutual support, ther is no overlap and Sedgewick inevitably drifts in field and is no where to be seen when an opposition attack goes down his flank. Add to this his poor form of late and you can see why opposition managers are targeting his flank.
I remember a Rotherham fan posted on here when we signed him to say that he could drift between brilliance and pub player standard.
Get well soon Matty Hill.
Click to expand...

Erm, I hate to be the one to have to break this to you mate, but Sedgwick has been 'playing' in central midfield the majority of this season. 😉

Anyway, FWIW, personally I never saw Sedgwick as anything more than a stopgap in the centre, until someone more creative/threatening became available. It's too early to dismiss Tommy Miller yet, but the problem as far as I can see is that we may be on the verge of going through a transitional period of Simmo attempting to find his best team which we can ill afford right now.

To me, McKenna and Miller look the best bet and with Pugh back in midfield we'll see an improvement I'm sure - I just hope it doesn't cost us many more points while a new-look starting XI beds in.
 
Back
Top