Skip to main content

Selection headache

Selection headache

Joined
Nov 17, 2004
Messages
2,870
With our decent win and performance at Roverum on Saturday that leaves SG with selection problems for the Wolves game in two weeks, particularly in midfield.

Pearson was outstanding prior to his suspension but, by the sounds of things, the midfield four did a great job in South Yorkshire. If we bring Pearson back in to the starting XI, who is sacrificed? Tough call.

Up front Hugill and Robbo are both doing fine jobs but you should never rule out Becks who (like another poster said recently) has terrific movement. May is coming back in a few weeks too, by all accounts.

Never known us to have such strong competition for places - love it! Quietly sensing a top six push in light of recent form. I'm an eternal optimist - sue me!
 
Pearson has to come straight back in. Of the 11 who started on Saturday, Pringle (whilst having his best game for us - that I've seen anyway) would be the one to make way, as overall he contributed least.

I'd like to see a return to the 4-3-3 formation on Saturday week.
 
Last edited:
I see no reason not to be an optimist, Bing. On present form that optimism isnt "Blind Faith," either.
 
I see no reason not to be an optimist, Bing. On present form that optimism isnt "Blind Faith," either.

You've got to wonder where we'd be if we didn't have such a bad start!

Great form, and every game we go into we're expecting to pick up points, not bad for a team costing so little compared to these so called 'big guns'.

When is the Grayson statue being built?
 
You've got to wonder where we'd be if we didn't have such a bad start!

Great form, and every game we go into we're expecting to pick up points, not bad for a team costing so little compared to these so called 'big guns'.

When is the Grayson statue being built?

Was thinking this myself recently. If only a couple of those losses could have been turned into draws, in fairness you could argue it was only a refereeing decision against Fulham that prevented us getting something and giving us a little morale boost going into the Derby game. 2 or 3 more points would have us right up there in the mix.
 
The team picks itself for me at the minute

Maxwell

Baptsite
Clarke
Wright
Cunningham

Gallagher
Pearson
Johnson

McGeady
Hugill
Robinson

Pringle I thought put in one of his better displays on Saturday. However I'd say he was still our weakest link on the pitch. And he was poor off the ball, leading up to their goal. So Pearson straight back in for Pringle.

Also got some good options off the bench now.

Vermijl has made a good impact since he returned from injury. So has Beckford. And Big Mak puts himself about.
 
What is pleasing is that when other players are called upon due to injury/suspension they are stepping up to the mark with goals and performances. There is not one guaranteed starter in our team in my opinion. We have various options and when called upon (Newcastle in the Cup aside) they seem to slide seamlessly into the squad and perform well.

As well as we played at Rotherham, Pearson would come straight back into the side (yes i did really say that) in place of Pringle. As much as i love Jon Welsh, i don't think that there is a need to play two 'defensive midfielders' at home and Pearson has been in the better form and is not coming back from injury. At present based on form and players we have available my preference woudl be the following 11 in a 4-3-3 formation to play Wolves: -

GK - Maxwell

RB - Vermijl
CB - Baptiste
CB - Clarke
LB - Cunningham

CM - Gally
CM - Pearson
CM - Johnson

RW - McGeady
LW - Robinson

ST - Hugill


However, i don't think that he will leave Wright out and so Baptiste will probably continue at RB.
 
You've got to wonder where we'd be if we didn't have such a bad start!

Great form, and every game we go into we're expecting to pick up points, not bad for a team costing so little compared to these so called 'big guns'.

When is the Grayson statue being built?

marsbars is constructing it as we speak😀
 
Pearson straight back in is a no brainer.

These 2 home games are, I feel, the springboard we have been waiting for and I can see 6 points coming our way.
 
Pringle I thought put in one of his better displays on Saturday. However I'd say he was still our weakest link on the pitch. And he was poor off the ball, leading up to their goal. So Pearson straight back in for Pringle.

I don't necessarily think Pringle's a bad player, but so far he doesn't seem to fit into this team at all. Imho he doesn't really have the attributes to play regularly in a Simon Grayson team and stands out as the weak link right now.

We're an organised, strong, physical team, in which every player does the nitty gritty stuff very well, and for me he doesn't suit it. He's clearly not interested in defending as shown by the goal on Saturday when he gave it away then 35 year old Peter Odemwingie glided past him like he wasn't there. Also, he's one of the slowest attacking players I've ever seen at PNE.

I don't know whether it's just because he's slow or not, but he doesn't seem to work as hard on the pitch as other players and it shows because at the moment he's offering nothing at either end of the pitch. It's still early days but he needs to do a lot more if he wants to stay in the team.

Daniel Johnson, on the other hand, was exceptional. Looking back to his old self after a dip in form last season.
 
Last edited:
JD said:
These 2 home games are, I feel, the springboard we have been waiting for and I can see 6 points coming our way.

Agreed - also, everyone around us are playing each other when we play Wolves. So a decent result should see us really strengthen our position...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Slightly off-topic like but I'll tell you what.......these international breaks aren't half annoying.

Agree especially with the form we are in and the injuries clearing, for me PNE cant get enough football at the moment. Normally Rotherham would be a ground we would drop points particularly after getting good points against the top 4 but again professional performance and I think SG treated Rotherham like he did the previous 4 games.

What a fab headache to have for SG though and this however is where a top manager stands out from run of the mill managers. Having to make tough decisions and keeping everybody happy is a job I wouldnt relish particularly with highly paid footballers.
 
I don't necessarily think Pringle's a bad player, but so far he doesn't seem to fit into this team at all. Imho he doesn't really have the attributes to play regularly in a Simon Grayson team and stands out as the weak link right now.

We're an organised, strong, physical team, in which every player does the nitty gritty stuff very well, and for me he doesn't suit it. He's clearly not interested in defending as shown by the goal on Saturday when he gave it away then 35 year old Peter Odemwingie glided past him like he wasn't there. Also, he's one of the slowest attacking players I've ever seen at PNE.

I don't know whether it's just because he's slow or not, but he doesn't seem to work as hard on the pitch as other players and it shows because at the moment he's offering nothing at either end of the pitch. It's still early days but he needs to do a lot more if he wants to stay in the team.

Daniel Johnson, on the other hand, was exceptional. Looking back to his old self after a dip in form last season.

I think Pringle's problem is he is so slow like you say, which is why he's half decent at set pieces, but closing down, getting close enough to tackle or going past players he's just not quick enough at doing it. I doubt he'd have been waiting at the back post like Vermijl was on Saturday. However his last 2 performances have been an improvement on the early season ones so there's still hope.
 
I think Pringle's problem is he is so slow like you say, which is why he's half decent at set pieces, but closing down, getting close enough to tackle or going past players he's just not quick enough at doing it. I doubt he'd have been waiting at the back post like Vermijl was on Saturday. However his last 2 performances have been an improvement on the early season ones so there's still hope.

Putting my tin hat in anticipation of the response to a suggestion about playing a player 'out-of-position' it does seem that when Vermilj came on on Saturday he was used in midfield and not at fullback. Could that maybe be a future role for him?
 
Agreed - also, everyone around us are playing each other when we play Wolves. So a decent result should see us really strengthen our position...

Hopefully Fulham v Sheff Wed and Birmingham v Bristol City end in draws but obviously more important to keep our run going. Leeds v Newcastle is on the Sunday.
 
Putting my tin hat in anticipation of the response to a suggestion about playing a player 'out-of-position' it does seem that when Vermilj came on on Saturday he was used in midfield and not at fullback. Could that maybe be a future role for him?

He was playing right midfield when he came on, Big Baps was still playing RB - you could perhaps argue that he was playing as a wing back but he seemed pretty much in front of Baptiste. I think he can play in that position (not much different to his ideal role as wing back) but I don't think he has the game to play anywhere else in midfield.
 
Back
Top