Skip to main content

Selection "problems" at the back

Selection "problems" at the back

Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
2,392
Looks for now Stuckmann is the main choice, but what about the back 4?

Buchanan was out for a bit, Laird played his way back in, than Buchs had a good game today. Know the game has changed but when have we ever had 2 quality left backs? Struggled to get 1 for countless years!

Thought Bailey Wright had a good game, whilst not going to dislodge Clarke / Huntington in the short term, today I thought showed he will be challenging. Good to have in the run in.

Right back, another selection dilemma with Wiseman / Woods. Have we had such strength in depth?

Or am I just missing Turner McLean Devine et al.😀
 
These are brilliant problems to have and brilliant because these lads all support each other as well. There's no jealousy, which is testimony to SG and Snodin in how to manage a changing room.

For me, you could put a mix of any of our squad of 24 on the pitch and we would compete.
 
There are some real headaches for Grayson here. Huntington has been superb, and I don't just mean for him, I mean he's been absoloutley excellent. Wright had a very good return but as of now it's as we were:- Huntington and Clarke.

Woods has looked better, especially last week, but it's definitely Wiseman, as it stands.

Buchanan had yet ANOTHER great game but I feel Laird is our better choice if Grayson is to continue with the balanced 442 targetman approach. As we'll need extra imputus from the fullbacks.
 
As I've previously said I'm a Lairdy and think that he's really taken his chance since his return and against Crewe possibly/potentially MOM but Buchs today was outstanding serious headache time for SG. Bailey & Hunts were also solid too great to see....long may it continue
 
These are brilliant problems to have and brilliant because these lads all support each other as well. There's no jealousy, which is testimony to SG and Snodin in how to manage a changing room.

For me, you could put a mix of any of our squad of 24 on the pitch and we would compete.
grayson as said its the best team spirt he as ever had in any of his other teams
 
I am firmly in the Buchanan camp but until Laird slips up he will have to wait. CB's are easy, Clarke and Hunts all day. Probably our best players this season.

As for RB, I am not sure about his match fitness but the sooner Woods becomes a starter the better going off his performance against Tarn. I am not a huge fan of Wiseman, he always has a shocker of a mistake in him.
 
I am firmly in the Buchanan camp but until Laird slips up he will have to wait. CB's are easy, Clarke and Hunts all day. Probably our best players this season.

As for RB, I am not sure about his match fitness but the sooner Woods becomes a starter the better going off his performance against Tarn. I am not a huge fan of Wiseman, he always has a shocker of a mistake in him.

Wiseman always has a goal in him though.

If you play Laird I think you're forced to play Woods who is less adventurous than Wiseman and makes fewer mistakes, therefore when the ball is on the left we have a more solid shape at the back. When you play Wiseman I'd say you're forced to play Buchanan for the same reason.

Buchanan is the only one of the 4 who is rarely, if ever, caught out of position and also gets forward to support the winger. Some of his crosses into the box are excellent. He just doesn't get into scoring positions often enough - but is that his role considering who plays on the left wing?
 
Buchanan plays well with Reid and I don't believe Laird would have contained Redmond like Buchanan did yesterday.
 
Wiseman always has a goal in him though.

If you play Laird I think you're forced to play Woods who is less adventurous than Wiseman and makes fewer mistakes, therefore when the ball is on the left we have a more solid shape at the back. When you play Wiseman I'd say you're forced to play Buchanan for the same reason.

Buchanan is the only one of the 4 who is rarely, if ever, caught out of position and also gets forward to support the winger. Some of his crosses into the box are excellent. He just doesn't get into scoring positions often enough - but is that his role considering who plays on the left wing?

Wiseman has scored 5 goals in the whole of his career. 2 for us.His goals hardly warrant his selection in the team.
 
Wiseman has scored 5 goals in the whole of his career. 2 for us.His goals hardly warrant his selection in the team.

For me Woods was MotM against Barnsley but before that Wiseman was solid in the games leading up to that match and scored a valuable goal vs MKD.

I'm agreeing with the OP that for the first time in a long while we have competition in the back four/five and players are having to play MotM games to hope to stay in the team. That can only bode well for us this season.
 
Can I just say that the Wright-bashing bandwagon really confused me. A fair few people saying he's shit, which is laughable IMO. He was an absolute rock for us in the first half of last season but then his form tailed off (you have to remember he's still very young and learning his trade). 'He's too small to become a quality CB' - biggest load of bollocks I've ever heard; he wins the vast majority of headers. Clarke & Hunts is the chosen pairing at the moment, but Wright will definitely come in at some point this season and I'm sure he'll do a good job.

The fact of the matter is, with the rise of Huntington, we now have 3 quality CB's at this level and a combination of either 3 works well. On top of that we have 2 excellent options at both RB and LB. Not many teams in the division can say that! They say clean sheets win titles and we're certainly getting plenty of those this season!

UTW
 
Can I just say that the Wright-bashing bandwagon really confused me. A fair few people saying he's shit, which is laughable IMO. He was an absolute rock for us in the first half of last season but then his form tailed off (you have to remember he's still very young and learning his trade). 'He's too small to become a quality CB' - biggest load of bollocks I've ever heard; he wins the vast majority of headers. Clarke & Hunts is the chosen pairing at the moment, but Wright will definitely come in at some point this season and I'm sure he'll do a good job.

The fact of the matter is, with the rise of Huntington, we now have 3 quality CB's at this level and a combination of either 3 works well. On top of that we have 2 excellent options at both RB and LB. Not many teams in the division can say that! They say clean sheets win titles and we're certainly getting plenty of those this season!

UTW

Wright was injured and playing on the left side which made him suffer. Before his injury he was probably out best centre half
 
Back
Top