Shaw was accused of lacking ambition
Didn't back Billy Davies when he should have done.
and when Davies left for derby he bought all the players that Shaw would not allow him as the financial burden would have bankrupted pne, derby got promoted and immediately relegated, and these star players, derby and davies are where exactly, clearly his prudence was good judgement.
Shaw was accused of showing too much ambition
Sanctioned the signings of pure shite like Shumi, Carter, Ricketts........ and gave them all stupid contracts that nearly bankrupted the club.
And under pressure from supporters decided to back his managers judgement having failed to back Davies, but the idea that he financed this by picking Hemmings pocket whilst he was asleep and without his knowledge or cooperation is pathetic.
Shaw was accuse of sanctioning shit signing
Was Shaw really signing players without the knowledge of the manager or was he backing the judgement of Brown, Davies, Simpson, Irvine, and Ferguson .
Shaw was never accused of that when we signed Nugent and Claud Davis netting us over 8 million
Players both spotted by the managers and cost low sums, we should thank Billy and Craig for spotting there talent.
So when they are good it is through the good judgement of the manager, but when they are bad it is due to the incompetence of the chairman, frankly anybody who can get two million for Mears and more than half a crown for Etuhu is doing something right.
Shaw was accused of having fuck all to do with the revamp of the ground when suddenly the ground was completed
He was Chairman when the IPS was built which still is completed, with an embarrassing top bit with a wooden tv gantry and a lift shaft where you can not fit a lift. You could however argue that the NHS Contract which paid for it was a great deal.
The rebuild of the ground was driven by Shaw and the NHS contract was excellent business, the under utilisation is due to over ambition but it is there for the future and hardly the legacy of under ambition.
Baxi period is hailed as "the time" by many yet we contiued to push on in the championship for another 8 seasons hitting another play off final and semi final.
Baxi set the foundations. The day Tony Scholes was forced out by Steve Jackson and Derek was the day we lost control of our finances and any proper business structure.
The BAXI years saw PNE being sponsored by a local firm, Gray was far too busy being over ambitious bankrupting BAXI to have that much impact, their involvement is largely mythology.
Scholes went to Stoke as he saw them as a better prospect, they had just completed the Brittannia his ambition was the prompt for that move.
Shaw wasn't here when we got relegated
That was because he was kicked out because he was found to be totally incompetent.
Was he kicked out, he and others sold their shareholding to Hemmings at a considerable loss because they believed it was in the interests of the club, Shaw and others were no longer welcomed by the new owners
So he became MD of the plastics and did not return to the deepdale terraces, would you, I doubt it and the way the fans treated him and continue to do so it should not surprise anyone.
It is subjective whether your opinion considers Shaw to be an incompetent imbecile, what I remember is watching the
BEST football under his stewardship and useless he may be but at the end of the day he is the one driving a Bentley!!!!!