Skip to main content

Should we drop Stuckmann?

Should we drop Stuckmann?

I love Stuckers and I don't think he has done much wrong to warrant being dropped, but the cold truth is this Johnstone lad hasn't been brought in to warm the bench.
 
Stuckmann hasn't done much wrong since he came back into the side. In fact, we have looked better defensively since has returned. Apart from the last 2 games when individual mistakes have cost us, certainly against Walsall anyway.

However, Stuckmann is out of contract this Summer, and 34 in a couple of months. He's not really a long term option, and is likely to want to return to Germany at some stage. Johnstone is certainly capable of being a long term option, and is more then good enough now to be number 1. Bit harsh, but Johnstone should start on Friday.
 
How many loan players are allowed in any one team any given day?
Will this effect us getting another striker/cm/cb/any other player in on loan with a view to permanent?
It may be that Herman has to play if we become "overloaded" with loan players
 
Stuckmann hasn't done much wrong since he came back into the side. In fact, we have looked better defensively since has returned. Apart from the last 2 games when individual mistakes have cost us, certainly against Walsall anyway.

However, Stuckmann is out of contract this Summer, and 34 in a couple of months. He's not really a long term option, and is likely to want to return to Germany at some stage. Johnstone is certainly capable of being a long term option, and is more then good enough now to be number 1. Bit harsh, but Johnstone should start on Friday.

Very fair summary norks!

I doubt you will find many North Enders who will have a bad thing to say about Stuckers, especially for his efforts when he first joined us. If we some how get through he could be our keeper in a final at Wembley which would be great for him.

However Johnstone seems to be the future now and I'm looking forward to seeing him play.
 
He made a mistake on Saturday for United's second goal, but he has been pretty solid between the sticks since his recall.
If we follow that logic then should we drop Humphrey and Brownhill for giving the ball away cheaply, or Killkenny, Gallagher and several other players for not putting a tackle in while the Sheff Utd lad ran more than half the length of the field. Stuckmann currently has the shirt, I for one think it would be hypocritical of Grayson to put Johnstone straight in. Since taking over from Jones Stuckmann has done enough to deserve his place, till he hits a run of poor form or is injured, he should remain in the team. Johnson has to earn the right to the shirt, just as every other member of the squad must do.
 
Stuckmann hasn't done much wrong since he came back into the side. In fact, we have looked better defensively since has returned. Apart from the last 2 games when individual mistakes have cost us, certainly against Walsall anyway.

However, Stuckmann is out of contract this Summer, and 34 in a couple of months. He's not really a long term option, and is likely to want to return to Germany at some stage. Johnstone is certainly capable of being a long term option, and is more then good enough now to be number 1. Bit harsh, but Johnstone should start on Friday.

Yes, Johnstone will get the start.

Ideally, TS will have a player/coach role lined up in Germany when his contract is up this summer. He's been good for t'North End and I wish him all the best when he does leave.
 
Stucki is a great servant for PNE and a very good number two. He's not top drawer though, but better than Jones.

Goodness knows what happened in the summer when it would appear Johnstone was our first choice but he ended up at Donny and we ended up with Jones.

Jamie Jones joins Simon Farnworth and Barry Richardson on my board of honours for shit goalies (sorry Mr Siddall, you have to play more than 1 game).
 
If we follow that logic then should we drop Humphrey and Brownhill for giving the ball away cheaply, or Killkenny, Gallagher and several other players for not putting a tackle in while the Sheff Utd lad ran more than half the length of the field. Stuckmann currently has the shirt, I for one think it would be hypocritical of Grayson to put Johnstone straight in. Since taking over from Jones Stuckmann has done enough to deserve his place, till he hits a run of poor form or is injured, he should remain in the team. Johnson has to earn the right to the shirt, just as every other member of the squad must do.

Whilst your comments are well intentioned, Johnstone is as good as if not better than Rudd. He has been first choice at Doncaster & hasn't signed for us to play second fiddle to Stuckmann.
 
Stucki is a great servant for PNE and a very good number two. He's not top drawer though, but better than Jones.

Goodness knows what happened in the summer when it would appear Johnstone was our first choice but he ended up at Donny and we ended up with Jones.

Jamie Jones joins Simon Farnworth and Barry Richardson on my board of honours for shit goalies (sorry Mr Siddall, you have to play more than 1 game).
Some said on twitter that Johnstone injured his hand during pre season. So that might answer that question
 
Whilst your comments are well intentioned, Johnstone is as good as if not better than Rudd. He has been first choice at Doncaster & hasn't signed for us to play second fiddle to Stuckmann.

All signs are that Johnstone is a better keeper than Stuckmann, just don't think it is good for him or the squad moral to go straight into the side - especially with 2 important cup games comjng up, which Johnstone is cup tied for as I understand it
 
All signs are that Johnstone is a better keeper than Stuckmann, just don't think it is good for him or the squad moral to go straight into the side - especially with 2 important cup games comjng up, which Johnstone is cup tied for as I understand it

Johnstone has got to start every match except the cup games. He is on a level up from Stuckmann. As someone says, possibly better than Rudd. Doncaster fans are absolutely gutted to have lost him.
 
The second goal was drilled low and hard, right between his legs. Harsh to blame him considering the defending from the outfield players involved.

Johnstone straight in - looking forward to seeing him and confident he'll be a considerable step up in quality

For anyone who has seen the TV footage, it is not so much harsh, as stupid!

I think there's a fair case for keeping Stuckers in goal for a couple of weeks until the cup games are done.
 
The second goal was not his fault at all. It resulted from poor defending.
Alright, it went through his legs but you just have to put it down to bad luck in all honesty

Bad luck! You see decent goalkeepers save those every week. He has been poor in the last 2 games. If he hadn't been, we may not have gone in for Johnstone.
 
Bad luck! You see decent goalkeepers save those every week. He has been poor in the last 2 games. If he hadn't been, we may not have gone in for Johnstone.

Yes he should have saved the first goal vs Walsall but no way vs sutd.
Don't know what games you've been watching
 
Yes he should have saved the first goal vs Walsall but no way vs sutd.
Don't know what games you've been watching

The second goals against Walsall and SU both went through his legs!

Anyway the question is should Stuckmann be replaced by Johnstone. Of course he should be. We signed Johnstone because he is considered to be a better goalkeeper than Stuckmann who has been error prone again in the last 2 games.

You play your best goalkeeper.
 
The second goals against Walsall and SU both went through his legs!

Anyway the question is should Stuckmann be replaced by Johnstone. Of course he should be. We signed Johnstone because he is considered to be a better goalkeeper than Stuckmann who has been error prone again in the last 2 games.

You play your best goalkeeper.

So why wernt liverpool playing mignolet?
 
Terrible man management if Grayson drops him for the game on Friday.

May as well give Stuckman a free transfer if Grayson drops him.
 
Back
Top