Skip to main content

Simon Grayson Analysis

Simon Grayson Analysis

Interesting how those managers deemed to be negative - Davies, Irvine and Grayson have produced much better results than those who apparently produce attacking sides who play with falir and freedom - Fergie, Brown and a tiny bit of Westley (though that's being kind).

I know which I'd prefer.

Taking his overall reign he gets a 9 from me and I fear some people have short memories. I understand the sitting back a little bit which cost us some points, but I think part of that is some fans think we have better players than we actually do.

Spot on
 
Taking his overall reign he gets a 9 from me and I fear some people have short memories. I understand the sitting back a little bit which cost us some points, but I think part of that is some fans think we have better players than we actually do.

Very well said.

I think it can't be overestimated how thoroughly poorly prepared, demoralised and generally washed up the squad was when Grayson took over. Some of that chaff is still being carried. Grayson has done an excellent job in a short space of time. But now we rightly expect him to maintain the trend.
 
Grayson is too negative for my liking, particularly at home. We drew far too many games at home, which were as a result of Grayson's tactics. Just prior to the play offs Grayson appeared to get things right at home, only to revert back to a negative line up for the play offs. Wolves were the only team to lose fewer games than us last season which suggests to me that we should have been nearer 2nd place than we were. In the end we got what we deserved.

I agree with the statement in bold.

I believe Grayson under achieved last season, and if he had allowed the team to play with more freedom, I think we would be planning a campaign back in the Championship, instead we are preparing for a 4th season in L1.

I don't think he underachieved at all, Wolves had the parachute payments Brentford spent a lot of money on that lad from Oldham and Judge. Plus retained most of the squad from last season. Like someone said we think he have better players than we do. Rotherham spent money and had the momentum and Leyton Orient were the surprise package this season, we will have one next year as well.

I don't believe in changing Managers, but if I was Hemmings, I would be telling Grayson that we were drawing too many games and to get it sorted. We tend to make 2 passes when 1 would suffice, which tends to exaggerate our pedestrian style. Maybe, he should allow John Dreyer more input, because he certainly put Bournemouth to the sword on his only game in charge.

The 2 passes comes down to being a solid team that only lost 7 games all season. However at home we should have taken a more free flowing approach, like against Nottingham Forest where we played them off the park.
 
I agree with the statement in bold.



I don't think he underachieved at all, Wolves had the parachute payments Brentford spent a lot of money on that lad from Oldham and Judge. Plus retained most of the squad from last season. Like someone said we think he have better players than we do. Rotherham spent money and had the momentum and Leyton Orient were the surprise package this season, we will have one next year as well.



The 2 passes comes down to being a solid team that only lost 7 games all season. However at home we should have taken a more free flowing approach, like against Nottingham Forest where we played them off the park.



But we lost... I'd give Grayson 7/10 so far.. It will be 10/10 if he gets us up next season. I honestly believe we are now only a couple of decent signings away from a promotion winning squad. A 10+ goal a season striker to compliment Garner, Davies & Beavon is a must. Plus a creative midfielder
 
A well balanced post from the OP and I agree with almost all of it.

When considering Graysons management, I think it's worth asking whether North Ends team last year was generally better than the sum of it's parts. My view is that it wasn't, whilst Orient, Brentfords and Rotherhams were.

I also think that North End defended leads far too early in the game. It felt like we were defending first half leads for virtually all of the second half, with the consequence that we threw away so many leads, that we missed out out on automatic promotion because of this. If we'd kept on attacking teams that were on the rack I am convinced that we would have got enough points for an automatic place.

Either way, he's proved a safe pair of hands, a sensible head and seemingly a decent bloke as well. 7 out of 10 for me.
 
Very well said.

I think it can't be overestimated how thoroughly poorly prepared, demoralised and generally washed up the squad was when Grayson took over. Some of that chaff is still being carried. Grayson has done an excellent job in a short space of time. But now we rightly expect him to maintain the trend.


so why in the very next game after Westley (and before Grayson) did that squad play so well against the league winners, they played with freedom and were well coached by Dreyer in what was probably our best display that season.
 
I'd give him 7 out of 10 but he'll have to step up to 8 or 9 this season to keep his job for me.Its going to be harder. We got 24 points last season against the 4 teams that got relegated. Can we repeat this against the promoted 4 teams, probably not. We had a great squad without being a great team.
 
so why in the very next game after Westley (and before Grayson) did that squad play so well against the league winners, they played with freedom and were well coached by Dreyer in what was probably our best display that season.

We, very occasionally, played OK under Westley as well. But Grayson took the same players consistently raised the level of performance and well hopefully continue to do so. Dreyer's one game doesn't tell us anything much (other than the players were delighted to be rid of Westley?). We don't know if Dreyer could have carried on getting that sort of performance out of them. We do know what Grayson HAS done though. And its mostly good.
 
so why in the very next game after Westley (and before Grayson) did that squad play so well against the league winners, they played with freedom and were well coached by Dreyer in what was probably our best display that season.

We won 7-0 in the game after Irvine left.

The games after a manager has been sacked often results in a better performance not in keeping with the previous dozen.

I don't think anyone really wanted Dreyer to be given the job over Grayson, however much of a good coach and guy he is.
 
I thought perhaps a debate on Simon Grayson was necessary.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.

OK, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but who gives you the authority and the knowledge to question a professional manager.
He has probably spent a great deal of his own money to get where he is and you can justify sitting on your fat arse and criticising what has been a successful season compared with those that are in the recent past.
I am sorry, I just don't get it.
If we had a barrowload of money, we could buy success. We don't.
There are people on here who are calling for the Managers head when we had a good season but a disappointing end.
Some people think that we are better than we are just because they support them.
 
OK, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but who gives you the authority and the knowledge to question a professional manager.
He has probably spent a great deal of his own money to get where he is and you can justify sitting on your fat arse and criticising what has been a successful season compared with those that are in the recent past.
I am sorry, I just don't get it.
If we had a barrowload of money, we could buy success. We don't.
There are people on here who are calling for the Managers head when we had a good season but a disappointing end.
Some people think that we are better than we are just because they support them.

Don't be ridiculous....... Anyone who doesn't question things is a bloody robot, incapable of independant thought....... Equation : He is a professional Manager = Therefore he shall not be questioned........... Yeah right !!
 
Last edited:
OK, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but who gives you the authority and the knowledge to question a professional manager.
He has probably spent a great deal of his own money to get where he is and you can justify sitting on your fat arse and criticising what has been a successful season compared with those that are in the recent past.
I am sorry, I just don't get it.
If we had a barrowload of money, we could buy success. We don't.
There are people on here who are calling for the Managers head when we had a good season but a disappointing end.
Some people think that we are better than we are just because they support them.

Our owner has a Barrowload of money and then some. Do you include him in the "we"?
 
No idea but I suspect that he will keep enough loose change handy.


You think?
Not many people get filthy rich by keeping loose change handy.
Especially how his wealth has gone up 290m in a year. That usually happens through smart longer term investing and asset rise.
 
OK, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but who gives you the authority and the knowledge to question a professional manager.
He has probably spent a great deal of his own money to get where he is and you can justify sitting on your fat arse and criticising what has been a successful season compared with those that are in the recent past.
I am sorry, I just don't get it.
If we had a barrowload of money, we could buy success. We don't.
There are people on here who are calling for the Managers head when we had a good season but a disappointing end.
Some people think that we are better than we are just because they support them.
I think you're very first sentence answers your question. I like every other fan is entitled to have his /her views on any manager. The manager gets payed handsomely to do his job correctly. I am a paying customer and am entitled to my views on SG. This is a forum and I think discussion and debate on all subjects PNE is necessary. You are entitled to your views and indeed entitled not to view the thread if it upsets you.
 
I thought perhaps a debate on Simon Grayson was necessary.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.

Ferguson, Brown and then Westley and you give Grayson only 6/10?
 
I think you're very first sentence answers your question. I like every other fan is entitled to have his /her views on any manager. The manager gets payed handsomely to do his job correctly. I am a paying customer and am entitled to my views on SG. This is a forum and I think discussion and debate on all subjects PNE is necessary. You are entitled to your views and indeed entitled not to view the thread if it upsets you.

Out of interest, if Grayson gets 6/10, how do you mark previous managers?
 
Back
Top