Skip to main content

Simpson throwing it all away

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dabbler
  • Start date Start date

Simpson throwing it all away

It is perhaps no coincidence that most of the moaning threads start at 1700 (obviously from people using their mobiles on the way back from the game) and are based entirely on match facts rather than rooted in the broader picture of what actually happened between 1500 and 1700 this afternoon.

We can not be complacent, of course, that would just be plain stupid. I advocate no such policy, and think that constructive criticism is a useful tool and, when accompanied by sensible suggestions of solutions is really very positive.

However, the impressions given across the negative threads:

"Dichio and Carlo cost us the game" Match facts
"Sedgewick was poor" from a radio commentary 😕
"Simpson has no idea what he is doing" the result went against us so he can not possibly have a clue
"Matt Hill is useless" the results with and without him speak volumes, at one point today he stopped a 3 on 1 attack with a great slide, saving a certain goal (obviously this is irrelevant because of the match facts)

..do nothing of the constructive sort. Please provide solutions other than outspend Birmingham.
 
"Dichio and Carlo cost us the game" Match facts
carlo has one poor day in a blue moon. how many match saving saves has he made this season?

"Sedgewick was poor" from a radio commentary
He has been poor for a while so maybe could do with a rest

"Simpson has no idea what he is doing" the result went against us so he can not possibly have a clue
Bollocks.

If he is that clueless and rubbish, why are we second the league?
Does Fergie get slated every time United lose? No.I know its completely different but for me, Simmo is doing a fantastic job and gets my full backing.
 
Yet this is what you see spouted again and again, rephrased occasionally, but repeated ad nauseum until such point as others actually believe it is what happened.

I figured it would be easier to drag them all together, because it saves posting half of the arguments (I will no doubt post counters to each indvidual criticism while watching the ashes)
 
I might also be in the plough later. Wear a red rose and stand by the fire so I know its you!!

Or will you be the one looking depressed because we are 2nd????😀 😛
my dad who still regards himself as a grimsargh lad eventhough we moved to cosmopolitan frenchwood in 1963 won't thank me for saying it but this potential freindly confrontation sounds as if its the most exciting event in grimsargh this year!
 
Didn't read the rest

Didn't read the rest

Why can't Simpson see where the problems are and react? it has been painfully clear all season that our midfiled is not good enough and today is another classic example. Simpson is either nieve or just plain thick.

That result is a devastating blow to our plans, poor teams are within touching distance of us and we should be out of sight.

The only word for today is pathetic. I know you will say that it is a knee jerk reaction but we could have been 10 points clear of West Brom tonight.

The only saving grace is that it seems that the others around us have failed to win but that is scant consolation.

We all know and have done so for some years that Koumas is the danger man and it took him only 6 minutes to beat 2 men and show us up. Another team lacking in confidence until they play us. That result has put great pressure on next saturday at sunderland, another ever improving team.

Not good enough simmo,poor poor management and if i was the chairman he would be in my office at 9 am tomorrow explaining himself.

I would hate to plunge to the depths that I felt when that clown brown was in charge, but a result like that today and the in the manner it was lost it is like deja vu when moyes persisted with that idiot murdoch game after game, brown had no idea of anything now simmo is keeping faith with players not good enough and is not addressing the problem areas.We now need 6 points from the next 2 games just to hang in there.

I have got the tin hat on ready for the backlash


I did not read the rest of this.............Just that it was posted by somebody who was not at the game and therefore not really worth reading.
 
last 3 away games

last 3 away games

3 big defeats, first Luton beaten 8 on the spin, ripped us to shreds and 2 nil flattered us.

brum 3-1 with 2 big misses by Nugent b4 they scored, defence in disarray

WBA, defence appalling once again, not good enough

all 3 games conceded 9 scored 3 not good enough

poor mangement in my opinion, sedgewick is not up to the task and our midfield is sadly lacking, teams have sussed us out especially away from home.

We can all say we are in a great position considering what happened but we should be in an even greater position and just by making a signing or 2 and strengthening the obvious weaknesses that we have.
 
3 big defeats, first Luton beaten 8 on the spin, ripped us to shreds and 2 nil flattered us.

brum 3-1 with 2 big misses by Nugent b4 they scored, defence in disarray

WBA, defence appalling once again, not good enough

all 3 games conceded 9 scored 3 not good enough

poor mangement in my opinion, sedgewick is not up to the task and our midfield is sadly lacking, teams have sussed us out especially away from home.

We can all say we are in a great position considering what happened but we should be in an even greater position and just by making a signing or 2 and strengthening the obvious weaknesses that we have.

Not much you can do when the transfer window is closed though and even when it opens it will be tough to get the quality we need. I can understand why he did not bring in another centre half especially with a must play clause, but maybe that has changed now and St Ledger is ready for a rest?

It will be interesting to see where Derby spend their reputed £5M and whether it makes the difference.
 
panic%20button.jpg



nice one ! made me laugh 🙂

but I do think we need a good level experienced head at the back and to beef up midfield, and to get stuck in a bit more and get some decent tackling done, thought we deserved a point, considering we only had 10 men for the majority of the game (and according to, and agreeing with some comments heard after the match, could have nicked it) but unfortunately carlos howlers put paid to that. oh well though whats done is done lets move onto the next game, this one is history
 
There does need to be something done about the midfield and I think Simpson is aware of it but obviously we have to wait until the transfer window opens for him to strengthen that area.

You've got to accept to some extent that West Brom were in the Premier League last year and have managed to keep their squad together so despite their poor(?) league position they were always going to be strong unless we caught them on an off day.

But looking at the West Brom midfield, most of their players were quicker than ours, stronger, and could use both feet. Miller's not the answer, he was bought to be a goalscoring midfielder but doesn't get in those sort of positions and doesn't have anything different about him. Whilst I wouldn't be horrified to see him sign permanently, I wouldn't be over the moon about it either.

Personally I thought Sedgwick had his best game in a while once he had moved to the right wing. I thought playing Pugh and Sedgwick as "wingers" would have forced us to play too narrow but that wasn't the way that it turned out at all. Yes we were stretched at times but that's to be expected when a man's been sent off and when playing against a good passing side.

Basically it was the same story as the Birmingham game but with more controversy. We've got to learn how to be as clinical as some of the other teams in this division, its all very well the saying "if you don't shoot you don't score" but we found ourselves wasting opportunities by rushing our shots or by just shooting when their were better opportunities available.

Defensively we were all over the place as well, it may be unnecessary to start panicking, especially when we've only lost the same amount of games as Birmingham, but its a little bit worrying just how easy it is for sides to score against us when we're playing away from home.

Having said all that I still fancy us to get a result against Sunderland as long as we get back to basics, but Simpson needs to make it clear, some of these players are playing for their futures.
 
So guys we're second. What a marvellous view. Tell you what let's just stand here, do absolutley nothing and just admire what we've done before that slow but sure downward trend sets in.

You guys represent the very personification of complacency.

Simpson should now be demanding the players come in for training tomorrow but guess what ? Jarrett informs us they've been very kindly given the day off. If that's right isn't that jolly nice.

You only make progress by making demands of people. For too many of you that is an alien concept.

Best post I've read on here in weeks. This is the best chance we've ever had of promotion into the Premiership. Usually the top two are out of sight by now. Why should we sit back and do nothing. We need to push on now and bring in the right players that can finish the job. You know what will happen though. Nothing.
 
Best post I've read on here in weeks. This is the best chance we've ever had of promotion into the Premiership. Usually the top two are out of sight by now. Why should we sit back and do nothing. We need to push on now and bring in the right players that can finish the job. You know what will happen though. Nothing.

Apart from the first and last sentence I agree.

Who says we are sitting back and doing nothing?
Why will we do nothing?
Why are you pessimistic?

Derek Shaw has never failed to back a manager when he wants new players. The large squad we have now is testament to that!!
 
Simmo should be commended for the results acieved with the resources he has - there is no-one in the squad who could have made a difference on Saturday - Koumas and most of the WBA side are Premiership players.

Having seen his reactions to conceding goals and losing games - complacancy isn't something I'd imagine he'd tolerate from anyone!

Of the players available its insanity to argue that he isn't picking the correct starting line-ups.
With some funds available in January i'm mjore than confident he'll continue to improve are squad/results!

WELL DONE SIMMO!!!
C'MON THE WHITES!!!
 
Brutus the "large squad" you refer to contains the following none Championship type players:

Sedgwick, Neal L., Dichio, Jarrett, Smith, Anyinsah and Hibbert.

It also includes injury prone Davidson and Agyemang.

It also includes loan signing Miller on about £5K a week.

The worrying thing is that Simpson wanted to sign Sam Parkin which would have been a disaster and he hasn't pulled anything off with Miller.
 
Brutus the "large squad" you refer to contains the following none Championship type players:

Sedgwick, Neal L., Dichio, Jarrett, Smith, Anyinsah and Hibbert.

It also includes injury prone Davidson and Agyemang.

It also includes loan signing Miller on about £5K a week.

The worrying thing is that Simpson wanted to sign Sam Parkin which would have been a disaster and he hasn't pulled anything off with Miller.

Exactly!!

That is not simmos fault. It is the fault of previous managers. Give simmo the chance to improve things. He has bought St Ledger, Chilvers and Pugh, all valuable 1st teamers who have got us where we are. Miller is on loan. If he is not good enough send him back.

The point I was making is that Derek backs his managers, rightly or wrongly!!!
 
nice posts mjb and most informative.

We need players if we are to sustain a challenge as clubs like derby,wolves,west brom,soton will swamp us when the transfer window opens.

sam Parkin I agree would have been a huge error but he was looking for a forward to score goals and he probably thoght that he could work with him and improve him. Where did he go Luton? he hasn't set the world on fire has he so that could have been a blessing in disguise.

We may criticise players but some are not good enough for this league and are in need of replacing.

We have a big squad and some need moving on, it will not be that easy with some, I can see there being a big clear out in the summer when we will still be in this league.

I feel that getting rid of Brian Stock which looks likely is a huge mistake, lets give him a try, he should have been considered prior to the signing of Miller.
 
sam Parkin I agree would have been a huge error but he was looking for a forward to score goals and he probably thoght that he could work with him and improve him. Where did he go Luton? he hasn't set the world on fire has he so that could have been a blessing in disguise.

Sam Parkin has had a reoccurence of an old injury and may be out for a while. But before that he just wasn't scoring. What people forget is that Simmo only wanted to sign him for a low fee and moderate wages which is why he didn't want to get into a bidding war with Luton. Simmo was heavily criticised at the time on this very forum for not busting the bank to sign Parkin. But once again, Simmo was right and his many critics were wrong. Shame they never come out to admit it.

Parkin will come good one day perhaps but was always over-rated - probably because he topped the League One scoring charts one season at Swindon.
 
Back
Top