Skip to main content

Sink

Sink

Joined
Apr 1, 2015
Messages
190
So we're now 7 games into the new championship season and for most we've already seen enough of the players to have an idea of who can cut it at this level and who can't, so who in your opinion hasn't managed to make the step up...


BAJ
 
So we're now 7 games into the new championship season and for most we've already seen enough of the players to have an idea of who can cut it at this level and who can't, so who in your opinion hasn't managed to make the step up...


BAJ

Clarke, Kilkenny, Huntington. Jury out on Wright. Our defence just lump it away. No composure or skill to play the ball out, thus losing possession and inviting pressure. Garner also won't be good enough I fear, hope I'm proved wrong.
 
So we're now 7 games into the new championship season and for most we've already seen enough of the players to have an idea of who can cut it at this level and who can't, so who in your opinion hasn't managed to make the step up...


BAJ

Pickford
Cunningham
Johnson
Gallagher

These look good enough
 
Garner is struggling with the step up. Not effective in this league. The centre backs are stronger, faster and more athletic. He's unfortunately being marked out of games with ease.
 
Huntington and Wright are ok defensively but not good enough with the ball. Clarke is struggling, so is Kilkenny despite his goal tonight and Humphrey isn't good enough for this level. No massive worries about the rest of the side, other than Garner needing a goal, he hit the post on Saturday, hit the bar tonight, had a great chance against Middlesbrough on the opening day and has managed to compete well enough with defenders in the air, once he gets a goal he'll be fine IMO but it does need to come soon.
 
Garner will be fine once he gets a goal - I am entirely confident of that. SG has recognised that we need some more quality at the back. We also need something extra in midfield. We are not dire. We need two or three more players and bit of luck.
 
Garner is struggling with the step up. Not effective in this league. The centre backs are stronger, faster and more athletic. He's unfortunately being marked out of games with ease.

Not getting much service though so what chances he is getting he's making them for himself. I still feel he will get goals in this league he just needs 1 to get going.
 
I think Johnson is struggling to come to terms with lack of time on the ball. He is creating nothing for any forwards, who are missing Gallagher.
Huntington, Kilkenny are the 2 struggling most.
 
I think Johnson is struggling to come to terms with lack of time on the ball. He is creating nothing for any forwards, who are missing Gallagher.
Huntington, Kilkenny are the 2 struggling most.

You must be watching a totally different game then. I think Johnson actually looks a better player in the championship then league one. Last season he scored a lot but that was all he did - he went quiet afterwards (didn't influence the game as a midfielder should.) This season i think he tries to create chances, but when you have no width or no movement up front how can you blame him.
 
You must be watching a totally different game then. I think Johnson actually looks a better player in the championship then league one. Last season he scored a lot but that was all he did - he went quiet afterwards (didn't influence the game as a midfielder should.) This season i think he tries to create chances, but when you have no width or no movement up front how can you blame him.

Agree. He is carrying the midfield
 
Agree. He is carrying the midfield

agree as well, he's the only one looking to get himself in to space and move the ball forward. Welsh and Kilkenny are becoming obsessed with passing the ball backwards and starting again. I've got no problem with keeping possession but with us playing 5 at the back due to the wing backs being so deep the CMs have got no one to pass to. The point in playing wing backs is so they can have an attacking threat and we certainly don't have that.
 
Garner is struggling with the step up. Not effective in this league. The centre backs are stronger, faster and more athletic. He's unfortunately being marked out of games with ease.

Have you been to any games? Garner is his usual self, bullying defences and creating chances out of nothing. Very unlucky not to have scored so far.

The problem is service. I don't know how to pinpoint the actual problem cause, but we basically aren't creating anything from midfield and Garner is having to come deep to win the ball and therefore is out of position when we do rarely go forward.

Best I've seen us has been last 20 minutes v Derby when we had three strikers on. They complemented each other well. I'd go for a risky 4-3-3 against Wolves at the next home game and see how that gets on.
 
Clarke, Kilkenny, Huntington. Jury out on Wright. Our defence just lump it away. No composure or skill to play the ball out, thus losing possession and inviting pressure. Garner also won't be good enough I fear, hope I'm proved wrong.

Defence wise you're correct.

Have you been to any games? Garner is his usual self, bullying defences and creating chances out of nothing. Very unlucky not to have scored so far.

The problem is service. I don't know how to pinpoint the actual problem cause, but we basically aren't creating anything from midfield and Garner is having to come deep to win the ball and therefore is out of position when we do rarely go forward.

Best I've seen us has been last 20 minutes v Derby when we had three strikers on. They complemented each other well. I'd go for a risky 4-3-3 against Wolves at the next home game and see how that gets on.

Not a chance in hell that SG will go for that, though I think I agree with you.
 
Have you been to any games? Garner is his usual self, bullying defences and creating chances out of nothing. Very unlucky not to have scored so far.

The problem is service. I don't know how to pinpoint the actual problem cause, but we basically aren't creating anything from midfield and Garner is having to come deep to win the ball and therefore is out of position when we do rarely go forward.

Best I've seen us has been last 20 minutes v Derby when we had three strikers on. They complemented each other well. I'd go for a risky 4-3-3 against Wolves at the next home game and see how that gets on.

Derby were down to ten men and sitting back....
 
Interesting you say Johnson and Gallagher which I agree are good enough but personally don't think as a pair they are right for the Championship.

They would be if we had a more fluid system. Bristol last night had centre halves coming forward with the ball and attacking.

We are defence and attack
 
My verdict so far:

Middlesbrough and MK Dons - decent start
Rotherham and Ipswich - opportunity missed
Hull and Derby - disappointing
Bristol City - dreadful

We deserved something out of the first four games, even Ipswich, but Hull and Derby were both worthy of the three points and it was daylight robbery that Bristol City didn't put at least three past us last night.

Kevin Gallagher on Radio Lancs made me laugh saying we deserved a point last night, before going on to say Bristol City enjoyed the vast majority of possession in large spells of the game and had by far the best chances. The justification for us meriting a point seemed to start and end with us working hard. He also said it was a wonderful game to watch and strongly disagreed with a text or tweet saying 3-5-2 wasn't working! Words fail me.
 
Back
Top