Skip to main content

Skylights

Skylights

Joined
Jul 21, 2010
Messages
39,386
For anyone who's not seen them... here they are

http://www1.skysports.com/watch/vid...reston-north-end/8640742/carlisle-1-1-preston

I can't decide on the Wroe's second yellow.

If you're chasing a ball and need to pull out of the challenge against any other player, you just side step them. But if the goalkeeper lies down to create a 6 foot wide barrier, if you can't jump over it, where can you go? It looked to me that Wroe avoided the Keeper's more vulnerable chest/head/arm area, which meant he made contact with the keeper's legs.

If the ref thought there was any more than that, he should have given him a straight red. Otherwise, he shouldn't have booked him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For anyone who's not seen them... here they are

http://www1.skysports.com/watch/vid...reston-north-end/8640742/carlisle-1-1-preston

I can't decide on the Wroe's second yellow.

If you're chasing a ball and need to pull out of the challenge against any other player, you just side step them. But if the goalkeeper lies down to create a 6 foot wide barrier, if you can't jump over it, where can you go? It looked to me that Wroe avoided the Keeper's more vulnerable chest/head/arm area, which meant he made contact with the keeper's legs.

If the ref thought there was any more than that, he should have given him a straight red. Otherwise, he shouldn't have booked him.

Second was definetly a booking, but the first is slightly debateable but still a booking IMO. He has pulled the player back when a counter attack was developing, I think the other player is lucky not to get a yellow as well because he lashed out at Wroe.

Usually I am very sympathetic towards PNE players getting sent off, but Wroe had to walk.
 
Second was definetly a booking, but the first is slightly debateable but still a booking IMO. He has pulled the player back when a counter attack was developing, I think the other player is lucky not to get a yellow as well because he lashed out at Wroe.

Usually I am very sympathetic towards PNE players getting sent off, but Wroe had to walk.

I am certain the other player received a yellow seconds before Wroe
 
It has given SG a good opportunity to see someone else in midfield - Mousinho or Byrom, if he is still assessing them, or even King.
 
It has given SG a good opportunity to see someone else in midfield - Mousinho or Byrom, if he is still assessing them, or even King.

Yes one or other of them should partner Welsh in central midfield on Saturday. Personally I don't think Byrom is good enough but if he is given the chance then it is up to him to make the most of it. I would still like to see King played in his proper position with, say, Cummins and Beavon upfront. SG has already indicated that Garner is in his plans for next season so he can be kept back.
 
Second was definetly a booking, but the first is slightly debateable but still a booking IMO. He has pulled the player back when a counter attack was developing, I think the other player is lucky not to get a yellow as well because he lashed out at Wroe.

Usually I am very sympathetic towards PNE players getting sent off, but Wroe had to walk.

OK... if there was intent, straight red then!
 
Back
Top