Skip to main content

Smoke bombs

Smoke bombs

Your inability to see other people's viewpoint is very frustrating!

Can you please back up your statement? Ensuring that, when you do the math, you take account of the fact that probably a hundred million fireworks are set off during organised dispays each year. And there are perhaps a thousand smoke bombs at football matches.

The issue is smoke inhilation. There's no other risk associated with smoke bombs, as far as I'm aware.

How many people do you know that have been injured at football matches due to smoke inhalation from smoke bombs?
 
People go to a firework/bonfire display knowing there will be smoke, fire and fireworks. Most people who go to a football match expect football, not fireworks and smoke.

I'd say there's a greater percentage of our away support that actually go for the day out and atmosphere (there's a laugh), rather than the actual game of football. The match is just a bonus/inconvenience, depending how you look at it.

At away games, I think it isn't unreasonable nowadays, to expect to see a smoke bomb or two being set off.
 
I'd say there's a greater percentage of our away support that actually go for the day out and atmosphere (there's a laugh), rather than the actual game of football. The match is just a bonus/inconvenience, depending how you look at it.

At away games, I think it isn't unreasonable nowadays, to expect to see a smoke bomb or two being set off.

Of course the away support goes off for a laugh. But you perhaps don't realise that for >90% of the fans, the match forms a critical part - however they get their laughs

And >95% would prefer to not have choking smoke bombs... although that figure would be lower if the smoke bombs were less choking. Perhaps released the smoke slowly, so you don't build up that intense levels of smoke (especially under a low roof on a calm day).

I don't have a problem that they add they add to the atmosphere. It's just not done right, and isn't fair to some of our supporters.
 
Last edited:
Most organised events also try to put more than 10 feet between the fireworks and the audience.

And they generally don't hem in the audience in confined spaces, where the smoke doesn't easily escape, and the spectators are unable to move upwind out of the way.

And, to be fair, if you've got asthma, you might well choose to avoid the event altogether.

I have asthma and they don't effect me, wonder if anyone on here's health has actually been affected by a smoke bomb..
 
What evidence do you have that they are harmful?
Well, the Premier League, FL and FA say they are - is that good enough for you?

They are dangerous for those with asthma or breathing difficulties and can cause panic in a tightly packed crowd. They are not designed for use in confined spaces and it is illegal to enter a football stadium with one and set it off.

Over half of fans have now witnessed pyrotechnics at a match, and 36 per cent have been directly affected: 24 per cent have had their view of the match obscured, 10 per cent have suffered from smoke inhalation and two per cent have been affected by heat from a flare.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/fo...-using-flares-and-smoke-bombs-in-grounds.html
 
What evidence do you have that they are harmful?

I've read several times from asthma sufferers (obviously not all asthma sufferers), saying it's bad for them.

A Google search for "asthma smoke bombs" immediately puts up a mixture of conjecture and credible sources.

I'm not qualified to interpret this info. If there is clear data that they cause no problems, then I'd listen.
 
I've read several times from asthma sufferers (obviously not all asthma sufferers), saying it's bad for them.

A Google search for "asthma smoke bombs" immediately puts up a mixture of conjecture and credible sources.

I'm not qualified to interpret this info. If there is clear data that they cause no problems, then I'd listen.

To be fair, after a brief google I can only see people talking about the dangers of flares, do smoke bombs come under the same definition do we know?
 
It would be very harmful to the twat who sets one off near me as they would be banjo'd straight away.

Muttley.jpeg
 
http://www.mpic.de/fileadmin/user_upload/pdf/Presse/Fussball_mainz2.pdf

From the popular bedtime periodical "Atmospheric Environment"

Anthropogenic sources of aerosol particles in a football stadium: Real-time characterization of emissions from cigarette smoking, cooking, hand flares, and color smoke bombs by high-resolution aerosol mass spectrometry Original Research Article

Atmospheric Environment, Volume 77, October 2013, Pages 1043-1051
Peter Faber, Frank Drewnick, Patrick R. Veres, Jonathan Williams, Stephan Borrmann

The whole picture is on pages 4-6.

Do not think I will be planning to walk into the smoke any time soon.
 
You didn't see my post then?

I hadn't, just read it now and I do see where you're coming from, however it seems heavily based towards flares rather than smoke bombs.

Do grounds in other areas of the world have safe ways of putting out flares? Most have open top stadiums so I guess no real smoke worry but the heat must be a concern.
 
Well, the Premier League, FL and FA say they are - is that good enough for you?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/fo...-using-flares-and-smoke-bombs-in-grounds.html


Having your view obscured and inhaling smoke used to be what Sat afternoon used to be all about, albeit not due to smoke bombs. There used to be far greater dangers decades ago like getting your head kicked in or trampled, but then you could just make sure you werent close to the trouble makers. Now we are all herded into seats, its more difficult to move away - but that wasnt the case on Sat - if Id been next to the bombers, i would have just moved - and not sat still and moaned like a tart afterwards.
 
I hadn't, just read it now and I do see where you're coming from, however it seems heavily based towards flares rather than smoke bombs.

Do grounds in other areas of the world have safe ways of putting out flares? Most have open top stadiums so I guess no real smoke worry but the heat must be a concern.
Well, it doesn't seem biased in that way to me.


Having your view obscured and inhaling smoke used to be what Sat afternoon used to be all about, albeit not due to smoke bombs. There used to be far greater dangers decades ago like getting your head kicked in or trampled, but then you could just make sure you werent close to the trouble makers. Now we are all herded into seats, its more difficult to move away - but that wasnt the case on Sat - if Id been next to the bombers, i would have just moved - and not sat still and moaned like a tart afterwards.
It's the usual way these threads go - eventually someone says "where's your evidence?", then when the evidence arrives, it's ignored and the argument goes back to "if you don't like it, why don't you move", as suggested back on post 4 or 5.

Waste of time.
 
Back
Top