Skip to main content

Smoke bombs

Smoke bombs

Well the FA etc. aren't exactly going to be in favour of them are they as it goes against their idea of what watching football should be like, i.e. all of us sat in silence eating prawn sandwiches and drinking tea.

It's a fair point you have to admit Thracia?
 
So the answer to my question "is that good enough evidence for you?" was "no".

How about specifying what sort of evidence would be good enough?

Because you know, a couple of anecdotes about "well, I saw a smoke bomb once and it didn't bother me" don't really cut it from my side either.
 
I notice no one bothered to check if my evidence was good enough...

But then air particle monitoring equipment and trials of various colors is still not enough?

I have to say I'm a cynic when it comes to football authorities but published science using established equipment...
 
I notice no one bothered to check if my evidence was good enough...

But then air particle monitoring equipment and trials of various colors is still not enough?

I have to say I'm a cynic when it comes to football authorities but published science using established equipment...

I read it and didn't understand a word. We're not bloody chemists!
 
So the answer to my question "is that good enough evidence for you?" was "no".

How about specifying what sort of evidence would be good enough?

Because you know, a couple of anecdotes about "well, I saw a smoke bomb once and it didn't bother me" don't really cut it from my side either.

There's plenty of evidence to suggest that Qatar won the right to hold the World Cup fairly ! 😉
 
The main lesson was don't walk through the smoke...

More poison in there than the air in Beijing.

But if anyone still wants to say they are not bad for health then that article stands as scientific proof they are.

Fair do's, but on what scale? How much/often do you have to be exposed to the smoke for it to actually affect your health?

You must be strongly against smoke bombs to go this far into researching them? Can't imagine what you'd be like if someone sparked up a cig next to you.
 
Fair do's, but on what scale? How much/often do you have to be exposed to the smoke for it to actually affect your health?

You must be strongly against smoke bombs to go this far into researching them? Can't imagine what you'd be like if someone sparked up a cig next to you.
As I said - waste of time.
 
Everyone seems to have missed the point of this.

As a result of the smoke bomb, Garner got injured and is now out for 4 months, Aston villa are disgusted with our behaviour and have recalled robinson because of it, Holmes has said hes had enough and cleared off to Pompey and whats more we`ll get fined by the FA and we`ll have no cash left to bring in any replacements. As a result of all this we`ll be in this division forever!!

Pah!
 
Everyone seems to have missed the point of this.

As a result of the smoke bomb, Garner got injured and is now out for 4 months, Aston villa are disgusted with our behaviour and have recalled robinson because of it, Holmes has said hes had enough and cleared off to Pompey and whats more we`ll get fined by the FA and we`ll have no cash left to bring in any replacements. As a result of all this we`ll be in this division forever!!

Pah!

At last.... The Truth !
 
I notice no one bothered to check if my evidence was good enough...

But then air particle monitoring equipment and trials of various colors is still not enough?

I have to say I'm a cynic when it comes to football authorities but published science using established equipment...

No one notice because you bore the shit out of everybody.
 
Everyone seems to have missed the point of this.

As a result of the smoke bomb, Garner got injured and is now out for 4 months, Aston villa are disgusted with our behaviour and have recalled robinson because of it, Holmes has said hes had enough and cleared off to Pompey and whats more we`ll get fined by the FA and we`ll have no cash left to bring in any replacements. As a result of all this we`ll be in this division forever!!

Pah!

On the positive side, Graham Westley angrily pointed out to Stevenage fans that their lack of smoke bombs was the reason he had signed a pre-contract agreement back at one of his previous clubs where they were more smoke friendly. Sadly someone caught this private conversation on film
 
Everyone seems to have missed the point of this.

As a result of the smoke bomb, Garner got injured and is now out for 4 months, Aston villa are disgusted with our behaviour and have recalled robinson because of it, Holmes has said hes had enough and cleared off to Pompey and whats more we`ll get fined by the FA and we`ll have no cash left to bring in any replacements. As a result of all this we`ll be in this division forever!!

Pah!

Good point well made & totally lost on those who do it. 🙁
 
Fair do's, but on what scale? How much/often do you have to be exposed to the smoke for it to actually affect your health?

You must be strongly against smoke bombs to go this far into researching them? Can't imagine what you'd be like if someone sparked up a cig next to you.

Cigarettes have been banned for their passive smoking effect 😉

Actually I do not worry so much about cigarette smoke as unless the person really is a chimney they are not going to produce anything like the volume of a smoke bomb. In China it is still perfectly legal to smoke in public so that happens to me all the time.

Interestingly in the German example the air recordings show exactly what cigarette smoke does, since smoking in stadia there is legal.

Oh, and how often do you need to be exposed? Similar to cyanide or any other poison I would always choose 0.
 
'Preston North End have received a letter from the FA in relation to recent fan behaviour at away matches for the second time this season.

Whilst it is widely accepted and appreciated that Preston North End have a terrific away following in League One and in cup competitions, recently a small minority of our travelling fan base have caused problems for the Club and the vast majority of our excellent supporters.

After recent events at Rochdale and most recently Bristol City on Saturday; on a day in which five pyrotechnic devices were recovered by the authorities, the Club have again received a letter from the Football Association in relation to the behaviour of our fans – in particularly the use of pyrotechnics.

The Club now need to respond to these charges and sanctions could include a reduced allocation of tickets for away matches and/or financial penalties which would of course be to the detriment of our playing squad which ultimately hinders our chances of promotion back to the Championship – something everyone associated with Preston North End is striving towards.

With this being the second time such a letter has been received by the Club, we feel it is vitally important than the Club reiterates our stance that detrimental behaviour, no matter how small the numbers involved are, will not be accepted by the Club in any way, shape or form.

We urge the small minority to please behave respectfully and to back the manager and the players like the vast majority of our support do when visiting other stadiums so we can all move forward together in achieving our ultimate goal – promotion.

In addition to the above, the Club have also received complaints recently from our own supporters, many of whom bring children to matches and will now not be attending.

All clubs need the next generation of supporters to look forward to coming to matches so that we can continue to grow our fan base – we pride ourselves on being a family Club, and to hear that families will now refuse to attend is both disappointing and frustrating from a Club perspective giving the time and effort put into making the matchday experience a positive one for all.

Once again we reiterate our stance in asking everyone who attends matches at Deepdale and around England supporting the Club to behave in a respectful manner to all otherwise the consequences will affect each and every one of us.

Thank you.'

Never seen the problem with smoke bombs myself, or flares if they aren't thrown. However the FA clearly do and as we're not a Premier League club where actions like this would be frowned upon but then ignored, this could get the club into trouble.

PS what happened at Rochdale?
 
'Preston North End have received a letter from the FA in relation to recent fan behaviour at away matches for the second time this season.

Whilst it is widely accepted and appreciated that Preston North End have a terrific away following in League One and in cup competitions, recently a small minority of our travelling fan base have caused problems for the Club and the vast majority of our excellent supporters.

After recent events at Rochdale and most recently Bristol City on Saturday; on a day in which five pyrotechnic devices were recovered by the authorities, the Club have again received a letter from the Football Association in relation to the behaviour of our fans – in particularly the use of pyrotechnics.

The Club now need to respond to these charges and sanctions could include a reduced allocation of tickets for away matches and/or financial penalties which would of course be to the detriment of our playing squad which ultimately hinders our chances of promotion back to the Championship – something everyone associated with Preston North End is striving towards.

With this being the second time such a letter has been received by the Club, we feel it is vitally important than the Club reiterates our stance that detrimental behaviour, no matter how small the numbers involved are, will not be accepted by the Club in any way, shape or form.

We urge the small minority to please behave respectfully and to back the manager and the players like the vast majority of our support do when visiting other stadiums so we can all move forward together in achieving our ultimate goal – promotion.

In addition to the above, the Club have also received complaints recently from our own supporters, many of whom bring children to matches and will now not be attending.

All clubs need the next generation of supporters to look forward to coming to matches so that we can continue to grow our fan base – we pride ourselves on being a family Club, and to hear that families will now refuse to attend is both disappointing and frustrating from a Club perspective giving the time and effort put into making the matchday experience a positive one for all.

Once again we reiterate our stance in asking everyone who attends matches at Deepdale and around England supporting the Club to behave in a respectful manner to all otherwise the consequences will affect each and every one of us.

Thank you.'

Never seen the problem with smoke bombs myself, or flares if they aren't thrown. However the FA clearly do and as we're not a Premier League club where actions like this would be frowned upon but then ignored, this could get the club into trouble.

PS what happened at Rochdale?

Oops, I started a thread with this, didn't see you had posted it.

At Rochdale one went off near us.. Not sure if any more went off
 
Back
Top