Skip to main content

Snog, Marry, Avoid..............

Snog, Marry, Avoid..............

Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Messages
4,558
Location
Manchester
Sorry for the misleading title, but if you were Grayson and had the following squad at your disposal who would you 'snog', 'marry' and 'avoid' or what i really mean is who would you sell/release, keep and loan out of our current squad.

GK: Jamie Jones - Keep
GK: Thorsten Stuckman - Keep
GK: Steven James - Loan

DF: Callum Woods - Keep
DF: Nick Anderton - Loan
DF: Scott Wiseman - Keep
DF: Ben Davies - Loan
DF: Bailey Wright - Keep
DF: Paul Huntington - Sell
DF: David Buchanan - Sell

DF: Scott Laird - Keep
DF: Keith Keane - Sell
DF: Tom Clarke - Keep

MF: Alan Browne - Keep
MF: Will Hayhurst - Loan
MF: John Welsh - Keep (unless we sign Kilkenny)
MF: Chris Humphrey - Keep
MF: Lee Holmes - Sell
MF: Jack King - Keep
MF: Joel Byrom - Sell
MF: Josh Brownhill - Keep

FW: Jack Ryan - Loan
FW: Kevin Davies - Sell/Loan out
FW: Stuart Beavon - Sell

FW: Joe Garner - Keep


It's only when you note down our current squad that you realise how threadbare it looks.
 
You do realise that to sell a player, someone must first want to buy them. Who do you imagine will want to buy any of those players that you have proposed be sold?

For now, I'd like us to sign some players before we worry about getting rid of those we currently have.
 
GK: Jamie Jones - Keep
GK: Thorsten Stuckman - Keep
GK: Steven James - Loan

DF: Callum Woods - Keep
DF: Nick Anderton - Loan
DF: Scott Wiseman - Sell
DF: Ben Davies - Loan
DF: Bailey Wright - Keep
DF: Paul Huntington - Sell
DF: David Buchanan - Sell
DF: Scott Laird - Keep
DF: Keith Keane - Keep
DF: Tom Clarke - Keep

MF: Alan Browne - Keep
MF: Will Hayhurst - Loan
MF: John Welsh - Keep (unless we sign Kilkenny)
MF: Chris Humphrey - Keep
MF: Lee Holmes - Sell
MF: Jack King - Keep
MF: Joel Byrom - Sell
MF: Josh Brownhill - Keep

FW: Jack Ryan - Loan
FW: Kevin Davies - Keep
FW: Stuart Beavon - Sell
FW: Joe Garner - Keep
 
I propose to release those players and replace them with 'better' players who can take us over the finish line automatically.

So 12 out and what, 10 in? And after that you'll no doubt expect promotion? Nice one.

GK: Jamie Jones - Keep
GK: Thorsten Stuckman - Keep
GK: Steven James - Keep (maybe loan in 2nd half of season)

DF: Callum Woods - Keep
DF: Nick Anderton - Loan
DF: Scott Wiseman - Keep
DF: Ben Davies - Keep
DF: Bailey Wright - Keep
DF: Paul Huntington - Keep - but I think he will go
DF: David Buchanan - Keep
DF: Scott Laird - Keep
DF: Keith Keane - Sell
DF: Tom Clarke - Keep

MF: Alan Browne - Keep
MF: Will Hayhurst - Keep
MF: John Welsh - Keep
MF: Chris Humphrey - Keep
MF: Lee Holmes - Keep
MF: Jack King - Sell
MF: Joel Byrom - Sell
MF: Josh Brownhill - Keep

FW: Jack Ryan - Loan
FW: Kevin Davies - Keep
FW: Stuart Beavon - Keep
FW: Joe Garner - Keep
 
Loan the youngsters who aren't going to get a game, keep the squad from last year (and add to it) and sell Wiseman.

Why? he has only just arrived. Give the bloke a chance he did not do that badly and even if he had, he would not be the first player to start slowly and come good.

Agree with loaning out the youngsters who are not going to get a game.
 
Why? he has only just arrived. Give the bloke a chance he did not do that badly and even if he had, he would not be the first player to start slowly and come good.

Agree with loaning out the youngsters who are not going to get a game.

He didn't start badly he's just been blamed by some for giving away a free kick (harsh one at that) 40 yards from goal in the play offs because it's easier than blaming the defence for giving their guy a free run and header and for Rudd having soft hands. Since then he's suddenly become our worse ever signing.
 
I agree Tino, though he was good in some game ok in others, never really came away from a game thinking he was awful today.

Also what message would it give to anyone thinking of joining us now if we got rid of him already.
 
He didn't start badly he's just been blamed by some for giving away a free kick (harsh one at that) 40 yards from goal in the play offs because it's easier than blaming the defence for giving their guy a free run and header and for Rudd having soft hands. Since then he's suddenly become our worse ever signing.

Spot on, Wiseman played well before he got his injury, especially with Humphrey in front of him.
 
A couple of dodgy games when he clearly wasn't fit and Wiseman is a player who people want shipping out.
He looked decent before the injury, solid defender, set up goals against Tranmere and Oldham.
 
I would think that Huntington, Byrom and Buchanan are surplus now and that Holmes, Keane and Welsh may become so depending on who we bring in. I think that SG wants 5 strikers as Davies will be also used as a coach and can't be expected to be a regular squad player at his age.
 
Last edited:
GK: Jamie Jones - Keep
GK: Thorsten Stuckman - Keep
GK: Steven James - Loan

DF: Callum Woods - Keep
DF: Nick Anderton - Loan
DF: Scott Wiseman - Keep
DF: Ben Davies - Keep
DF: Bailey Wright - Keep
DF: Paul Huntington - Sell
DF: David Buchanan - Keep
DF: Scott Laird - Keep
DF: Keith Keane - Sell
DF: Tom Clarke - Keep

MF: Alan Browne - Keep
MF: Will Hayhurst - Loan
MF: John Welsh - Keep
MF: Chris Humphrey - Sell
MF: Lee Holmes - Sell
MF: Jack King - Keep
MF: Joel Byrom - Sell
MF: Josh Brownhill - Keep

FW: Jack Ryan - Loan
FW: Kevin Davies - Sell
FW: Stuart Beavon - Sell
FW: Joe Garner - Keep
 
Sorry for the misleading title, but if you were Grayson and had the following squad at your disposal who would you 'snog', 'marry' and 'avoid' or what i really mean is who would you sell/release, keep and loan out of our current squad.

GK: Jamie Jones - Keep
GK: Thorsten Stuckman - Keep
GK: Steven James - Loan

DF: Callum Woods - Keep
DF: Nick Anderton - Loan
DF: Scott Wiseman - Keep
DF: Ben Davies - Loan
DF: Bailey Wright - Keep
DF: Paul Huntington - Sell
DF: David Buchanan - Sell

DF: Scott Laird - Keep
DF: Keith Keane - Sell
DF: Tom Clarke - Keep

MF: Alan Browne - Keep
MF: Will Hayhurst - Loan
MF: John Welsh - Keep (unless we sign Kilkenny)
MF: Chris Humphrey - Keep
MF: Lee Holmes - Sell
MF: Jack King - Keep
MF: Joel Byrom - Sell
MF: Josh Brownhill - Keep

FW: Jack Ryan - Loan
FW: Kevin Davies - Sell/Loan out
FW: Stuart Beavon - Sell

FW: Joe Garner - Keep


It's only when you note down our current squad that you realise how threadbare it looks.

I think the OP goes some way to dispelling the myth that Westley did some good in assembling a squad. 40+ signings and only 4 we'd like to keep. Of which I'd hope only Garner would be a starter.
 
I don't want a squad of "jack of all trades" and fear this might be the route Grayson is taking us, I would want players who know and perform really well in their chosen position playing to a clear plan.

King, Woods, Clarke, Keane, Wright and Ben Davies all fall into the "JOAT" category. Perm any from half a dozen who can play somewhere in the middle, few proper wide players who can get to the line and whip a cross in, oh and only one goal scoring striker. Much work needed and players brought in who can do ONE job very well.

Out; Byrom, Beavon, Hayhurst, Holmes and sadly Keane, Gallagher in but only as a striker, K Davies more of a player/coach role and if King cannot command a place in midfield them get rid.

Keepers, they speak for themselves
R.B. Wiseman and Woods
C.B. Huntington, Wright, Clarke, Davies
L.B. Laird, Buchanan
R.M. Humphrey + 1
C.M. Welsh, Browne, Brownhill, King + 2
L.M. + 2
F. Garner, K Davies + 2 (one being Gallagher)

James, Anderson and Ryan out on loan for a season ala York
 
Back
Top