Skip to main content

So - how is Stucky doing ?

So - how is Stucky doing ?

Wasnt there, obviously, but the BBC stats show that Yeovil didnt have a single shot on target.
 
Wasnt there, obviously, but the BBC stats show that Yeovil didnt have a single shot on target.

I wasn't there either yesterday but I did see somebody post (can't remember who sorry) that he didn't put a "foot or hand" wrong yesterday. Two clean sheet should go someway to prove he's doing a good job so far.
 
The point im making is that GOOD goalkeepers are thise who command their box, organise their defence in such a way that very few shots ever come at them. Keepers making saves is last ditch. To have few if any shots at them is what marks out good keepers from camera keepers.
 
The point im making is that GOOD goalkeepers are thise who command their box, organise their defence in such a way that very few shots ever come at them. Keepers making saves is last ditch. To have few if any shots at them is what marks out good keepers from camera keepers.

What a load of shit
 
The point im making is that GOOD goalkeepers are thise who command their box, organise their defence in such a way that very few shots ever come at them. Keepers making saves is last ditch. To have few if any shots at them is what marks out good keepers from camera keepers.

So, essentially, a keeper who has nothing to do in a match has done better than a keeper who makes 20 world class saves in a single game? What a load of rubbish.
 
The point im making is that GOOD goalkeepers are thise who command their box, organise their defence in such a way that very few shots ever come at them. Keepers making saves is last ditch. To have few if any shots at them is what marks out good keepers from camera keepers.

You've not put your point across very well pal...
 
So, essentially, a keeper who has nothing to do in a match has done better than a keeper who makes 20 world class saves in a single game? What a load of rubbish.

Commanding his box means he does nothing? I thought you were brighter than that.
 
Football is a lot like chess. You have the same number of pieces as your opponent, you face-off on the same playing surface and you both have the same aim. The great chess players know they need to get the most out of each of their pieces to win. This gives rise to the maxim: "The King is a fighting piece – use it."

With the king being the weakest and most important piece on the board, it would seem logical to ignore the maxim and do nothing but protect him at all times. But if you are to do that and your opponent uses their king as an attacking piece, essentially your opponent has one more piece than you. In tight games, against similar opposition, this small advantages can be the difference between victory and defeat.

By using your goalkeeper not just to protect your own goals but to actually participate in defending, building attacks and keeping the ball, you are utilising your 11th man. If your opposition are not doing this, you immediately have a man advantage.

There are teams that utilise the 11th man; in fact almost every team does, but you only see it for a very brief period of time. When a team is desperately hunting for a goal and the clock is ticking down to full-time the goalkeeper will become more involved in the game.

He leaves the safety of his six-yard box and lingers on the edge of his area; he sweeps behind his defenders who are camped on the halfway line; and he plays long, raking, diagonal balls to those further upfield. If he is able to play the role at this point in the match, why is he not able to do it earlier?

The conservative traditionalists within football see the reliance on a sweeper-keeper as a sign of weakness. The high defensive line and the involvement of the goalkeeper appear to be the last move of a desperate manager with nothing left to throw at the opposition. Perhaps the tactic has this reputation as it is only used in the dying moments of matches.

If anything, the use of the goalkeeper in the sweeper-keeper role is the opposite of desperation. Utilising the 11th man is a tactically intelligent innovation that is going to become more and more popular in the coming years.

BraaV7ICUAEZq0F.jpg


Neuer is not only a world-class goalkeeper, but he is a footballer as well. In the sweeper-keeper role he is more than just a net guard. His defensive skills, covering any through balls and sweeping up behind his back line, allow the defenders to push forward. This in turn restricts the space the opposition have in the middle of the pitch and forces the game into the opposition's half.
 
Commanding his box means he does nothing? I thought you were brighter than that.

A keeper commanding his box is important but how many shots the other team have will always be mostly down to how good a team the opposition are and who's in control of the match.
 
Considering he had little to nothing to do shot wise, he was very commanding! Always made calls for the balls he could collect, encouraged his team throughout the match and always got his head and hands stuck in to claim anything in and around his box.
 
Not that I'm particularly inclined to back up raefil 🙂 But are people willfully misunderstanding his posts on this forum at the moment? First, there was the poll about grayson... which was obviously using a bit of irony.. but loads of people got quite heated... And now this.

Now, he's spot on in saying that a good keeper can minimise the number of shots on his goal, using good organisation of his defence.

Does he really need to spell out every scenario for you people? It's obvious what he meant, and if you don't see the point, it's you who's the thick ones!
 
Commanding his box means he does nothing? I thought you were brighter than that.

I think if a keeper just plucked a few crosses out of the air and didn't have a shot to save, most people would consider he'd had little to do all game! Your theory doesn't seem to take into consideration the job of the defence to protect the goalkeeper, as well as the midfield to protect the defence etc. Quite why you can't just say fair play to Stuckmann for two clean sheets in the league and the winning penalty in the JPT is beyond me, instead we have this embarrassing thread. I'm sure Alan Kelly will inform Stuckmann this morning that the more saves that are required, the worse a keeper he must be! 😱
 
Back
Top